30 ms·
This is one of those Shut up and Take my Money Product announcement. ~20% Increase in IPC, ~10% Increase in Boost Clock Speed. It doesn't matter how Intel spin
by ksec 6y ago
This is one of those Shut up and Take my Money Product announcement.
~20% Increase in IPC, ~10% Increase in Boost Clock Speed. It doesn't matter how Intel spin it, single thread performance will no longer be an Intel only selling point. 32MB L3 Cache is going to be very useful for certain types of Application.
Some of these were rumoured for quite some time. But having it confirmed is a completely different matter. And the pricing is still very good compared to what we used to get from Intel.
My only concern is stock availability. And not just at launch but over its life time. AMD has been very conservative with their production estimate. ( Again It is not TSMC's fault ) It wasn't long ago they were on the verge of bankruptcy, so it is understandable but at the same time I wish they took a little more risk.
It is also interesting there is no mention of EPYC 3. I am quite concern about their lack of progress in the Enterprise / Server segment.
- old-gregg 6y agoIsn't this how it's always been? New tech shows up in enthusiast/consumer segment first, bugs are ironed out, manufacturing ramps up & yields go up, then new server parts are announced? Besides, isn't EPYC2 the best server CPU already? There's no time pressure on AMD, they're comfortably in the lead.
- wahern 6y agoRegular EPYC CPUs have too high a TDP for smaller server installations, such as so-called edge servers. EPYC Embedded is still stuck on Zen 1. Intel hasn't upgraded their comparable line of mid-range server CPUs (e.g. Xeon D line), either, but AMD won't win on performance alone. Intel has a huge SKU lineup, much more volume, and a much richer vendor and platform ecosystem. If the vendor demand isn't there to push AMD on EPYC Embedded, Ryzen Emedded, and other market segments, AMD should build demand, otherwise they'll just recapitulate their rise & fall during the 2000s.
- xigency 6y agoCloudflare recently announced that they would be building out some data centers with EPYC CPUs. Do you believe that the situation has changed since February? They did a pretty exhaustive analysis [0] of price, performance, and power where they saw an advantage in switching away from Intel for that generation at least. If the existing server hardware is already in a decent spot, then maybe they need to spend more resources on sales rather than making changes to keep it cutting edge. [0] https://blog.cloudflare.com/an-epyc-trip-to-rome-amd-is-cloudflares-10th-generation-edge-server-cpu/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/an-epyc-trip-to-rome-amd-is-clou...
- wahern 6y agoI think Cloudflare is a different kind of "edge" service than what EPYC Embedded targets, and I would think Cloudflare uses regular EPYC chips. The "edge" that EPYC Embedded, Xeon D, etc target is, I think, more about the hardware configurations (smaller enclosures, minimal number of drives and other devices) and the type of facility (usually not a colocation facility, so power and heat are of significantly more concern). But the workloads are still very much server-class. EPYC Embedded chips are competitive with Intel's offerings (Xeon D, etc), but as I said Intel's ecosystem is richer--for example, more, better motherboards. It's not enough that AMD's chips are competitive with Intel's. AMD has a huge ecosystem handicap, and so either they need to improve the ecosystem or sell chips that are dramatically better than Intel's, and for EPYC Embedded neither is the case. Long term a better ecosystem is necessary for AMD to survive because a broader product and customer base brings consistent income and mindshare--staying power. I would hope and assume AMD is working closely with cloud vendors on their proprietary hardware, but the results are opaque; judging by traditional channels (Supermicro, etc), AMD hasn't even begun to close the gap.
- pdpi 6y agoI don’t think survival is at stake. AMD powers both XBox and PlayStation for the second generation in a row and that ought to help keeping them alive. It’s more a matter of whether they can capture enough of the market so they’re not merely “surviving”.
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoAMD and Hector Ruiz sat on their temporary advantage and were in denial of Intel's investment in the Core architecture. AMD is keeping the throttle down this time.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y ago> but AMD won't win on performance alone. Yup. Let's talk about price and TDP... > Intel has a huge SKU lineup, Why is that supposed to be an advantage? > much more volume, ok > and a much richer vendor and platform ecosystem This is just marketing-speak. richer vendor...ecosystem = more resellers richer...platform ecosystem - what does that even mean? > AMD should build demand How? And have you noticed how many people here saying they want to buy intel? > otherwise they'll just recapitulate their rise & fall during the 2000s. Who's in the stronger position now in terms of price and performance?
- kristopolous 6y agoA huge sku lineup according to every marketing book every made is a terrible idea here. I hope they don't view it as a strength. I'd be slashing like hell.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tyldum 6y agoAMD lacks AVX512 instruction set, which is a show stopper for many applications.
- gameswithgo 6y ago1. not many 2. avx2 with twice the cores is about as good as avx512 a lot of the time
- gnufx 6y agoWhich applications, and why? Some computational ones will go significantly slower on the same number of cores if they could have kept avx512 fed (perhaps small data in cache), but most don't spend all their time in something like GEMM. The new UK "tier 1" HPC system is all EPYC.
- smarx007 6y agoAutomatic vectorization for AVX512 would work on the simplest of cases and using intrinsics or writing inline assembly is beyond the scope of 99% of software projects.
- nate_meurer 6y agoAVX512 is garbage. It incurs a massive performance hit from both frequency and mode-switching penalties. Apart from a few niche HPC and ML applications which you'll never encounter, AVX512's most compelling use cases are to drive Intel's shady market fragmentation, and to create more bullshit FP benchmarks that Intel can claim to win. https://www.extremetech.com/computing/312673-linus-torvalds-i-hope-avx512-dies-a-painful-death https://www.extremetech.com/computing/312673-linus-torvalds-...
- pixelpoet 6y agoNow that we've covered both ends of hyperbole, it's maybe worth noting that a lot of CPU parallel tasks can be well accelerated by ISPC, which can make reasonably effective use of AVX512 (with the aforementioned clock speed caveat): https://www.mail-archive.com/ispc-users@googlegroups.com/msg00202.html https://www.mail-archive.com/ispc-users@googlegroups.com/msg... Also, AVX512 is a much nicer (orthogonal) ISA than SSE or AVX2. While there are some niche applications that need larger amounts of memory than GPUs can offer, it's worth noting that this speedup comes from making the CPU act more like a GPU, and they aren't as fast as GPUs acting like GPUs (which are essentially many 32-wide vector units, rather than AVX512's 16-wide).
- smolder 6y agoIt's not a given at all, even if that's common. As a fresh counter-example, Nvidia released Ampere on TSMC 7nm for the enterprise many months before they released chips of the same architecture for consumer devices on Samsung's cheaper and significantly less dense 8nm node.
- DrBazza 6y ago> There's no time pressure on AMD, they're comfortably in the lead. Intel thought this way, and that's why AMD are where they are now. And Microsoft to a lesser extent. Sitting on huge piles of cash helps though.
- kar1181 6y agoMy last AMD processor was the Athlon 64 x2 circa 2005, it's going to be nice going back.
- phkahler 6y agoI ran one of those until a couple years ago when I got the 2400G APU. What a nice upgrade. Even better parts available now.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- incompatible 6y agoI'm using a AMD Athlon II X2 260, released in 2010.
- rhizome 6y agoI'm still running an Ath 64 x2 6000+ for a web server, I think it's from about 2006. That with an old hard drive are running 120W, which would be nice to hack down. I don't remember if I jumped straight to this from my Pentium Pro 200, but the role of this box started with that one.
- dghughes 6y agoMy Athlon is in a case next to my left knee. I was almost scared off by the Intel hyper but not too sure of AMD spin. We're all casualties of marketing departments. In the end I bought AMD because it was cheaper than Intel.
- nl 6y agoYeah I had one of those. It was great but so noisy. Then Core2, then i5. I built my son a computer last year on Ryzen and it's great, but I don't see myself upgrading my i5 for a couple of years. My money will go on GPU upgrades (currently a 1070) instead I think.
- myself248 6y agoI just upgraded an Athlon64 x2 to a Phenom II x4 because I could get the chip for $20 and a cooler for $30. Heck of a speed boost on that box, which was looking a little long in the tooth otherwise. It's now beefy enough to run a modern OS and GUI and even do some light gaming on, but the mobo has serial and parallel and PATA and floppy ports so it serves as my media archiving mule too.
- agumonkey 6y ago`buy the rumor, buy the news` -- amd
- genpfault 6y ago> 32MB L3 Cache is going to be very useful for certain types of Application. Are there applications where more cache is actively detrimental?
- foota 6y agoNo? Other than the next best use of that silicon/heat budget, to whatever degree the latter is relevant for cache. But not afaik from an architectural point of view.
- phire 6y agoGeneral rule of thumb is that bigger caches are slower to access. If AMD have traded a bit of access latency for their larger cache, then theoretically there will be a memory heavy application with a working set that fits in 16MB that will see a preformance hit. Though, we don't know Zen 2 was running into area based speed limitations for it's L3 cache. It's entirely possible Zen 3's cache runs at the same speed.
- shaklee3 6y agoSlower, but always faster than dram. So no, there are no downsides.
- wolrah 6y agoA larger but slower cache would be a downside for an application that did not need the extra capacity. Now it's cache accesses are slower with no gains anywhere else. Of course if you don't have enough memory at a given tier and are overflowing in to the next adding more will always make things better, but once you hit that point adding more just adds cost at best and might actually make things worse if it's slower for the extra capacity.
- Entalpi 6y agoThere are a bunch of downsides to large caches. Everything from access time to chip layout to latency and even power consumption. Everything cant be cache and be awesome.. :P
- nwallin 6y ago> 32MB L3 Cache is going to be very useful for certain types of Application. "Going to be"? The Ryzen 3600 ($199) and above already have 32MB L3 cache, the 3900X ($499) and above already have 64MB. The big L3 cache is already a big selling point of Zen 2.
- cma 6y agoThe difference they talked about is it is now uniform latency instead of split into two blocks of 16MB accessible at different latencies depending on which group of four cores you are on.
- sbierwagen 6y ago3990X has 256mb of L3.
- bcrl 6y agoBut only 16MB of L3 is accessible to each core in Zen 2 - no single core can utilize all 256MB of L3 cache. That's why Zen 3 cores being able to access the full 32MB of L3 cache that's on die is a big deal.
- ShinTakuya 6y agoYeah but it's not as relevant to the discussion given it's in a different class of CPU not really aimed at average consumers. It's fair to mention it, though.
- sadness2 6y agoThe performance is in the same ballpark for cost-performance as Intel 10th gen, and the 10th gen Intel platform will be compatible with Intel's 2021 chips, whereas if you get an AMD board now, this will be the last processor which it supports. The AMD boards are more expensive for comparable features. Intel 10th gen also has better all-core boosting, which might be important for upcoming games with better multicore support.
- Spooks 6y agoIntel current platform does not support PCI4 though, if that is important to you, you will need a new mobo anyways. Also I don't think many people are going to upgrade from intel 10th gen to intel 11th gen, assuming gen 12 will have DDR5 (worth skipping a gen)