3 ms·
This is why TJ needs a better history curriculum. Support for confederate statues is not support for history or even support for Lee himself. The AHA even put o
by UncleMeat 6y ago
This is why TJ needs a better history curriculum. Support for confederate statues is not support for history or even support for Lee himself. The AHA
even put out a statement to clarify since people don’t seem to ask historians what they think about the subject.
- hnracer 6y agoHistorians are politically biased, with about 90 percent of them leaning left. See Jonathan Haidt for more information on political bias in the humanities. On such a politically charged issue they are not to be trusted and are a corrupted group of individuals. This is exactly why we need a politically balanced team to do any vetting on a platform like Facebook. Also, to say that protesting in support of a Robert E Lee statue is not showing support for Lee is prima facie absurd.
- UncleMeat 6y agoThe argument has nothing to do with political leaning and instead everything to do with how historians interact with primary sources. It is absolutely consistent with ordinary historiography to say that a statue of Lee is not a historical record of the man. I do hope supporters will stop claiming they are defending history when they immediately turn around and declare that the thousands of professional historians around the country are all fools.
- JamesBarney 6y agoWhat is it support for and why do historians have special access to the internal motivations of contemporary protesters?
- UncleMeat 6y agoHistorical documents are more evidence about the people who created them than the people described in the documents. It would be very poor historiography to use a book written about somebody as raw data about that person. This sort of thing is taught in intro college classes and makes it very clear that people who claim to be interested in defending history are not trained in the field and haven't actually made an effort to learn it. The conclusion then is that there is some other reason why they insist that said statues must remain up.
- rayiner 6y agoI agree with that today in 2020, but that’s not what I learned growing up in northern Virginia in the 1990s. I thought nothing of driving in Lee Highway, and didn’t know that all these monuments are created in the 1930s. And that doesn’t even mean Trump’s assertion is even incorrect. Maybe the protesters had the same misconceptions about history as many people who grew up in a fairly liberal place in the 1990s. That actually supports Trump’s point that people who oppose taking down the statutes aren’t necessarily raving white supremacists.
- UncleMeat 6y agoThus why I wish TJ had a better history curriculum. Its truly terrible that such a strong school is graduating people off two years of history, one of which is designed by the College Board. Thinking nothing of the historical objects around us is not terrible. Most people are ignorant of most things, lord knows I am. A problem arises when people insist that defending confederate statues is protecting history, when if you went and asked the people who actually do history for a living they'd fairly universally disagree. As for Unite the Right, I'd agree with you that there are people who want the statues to stay up and aren't white supremacists. However, it would not be possible to spend a few hours marching at Unite the Right and not notice the literal Nazi flags, the speakers giving speeches about whiteness, and the marchers shouting "gas the k--es, race war now". At that point, I'd expect an ignorant defender of confederate statues to think "wow, I've made a big mistake" and leave.