2 ms·
What is the problem with that east Texas district?
by guelo 16y ago
What is the problem with that east Texas district?
- tzs 16y agoNothing. There's a common myth on the internet that it massively favors patent plaintiffs, but in reality it isn't even in the top five. There are two reasons so many patent suits are filed there. 1. It has judges that have experience with patent suits and like handling them. Whether you are plaintiff or defendant, you want this. 2. There isn't much federal crime there. Criminal cases always take precedent over civil cases on the court calendar. In some districts, especially those where the stupid "war on drugs" is highly active, it can take a long long time to get any court time for civil cases.
- leftnode 16y agoBasically a pissed off judge - http://www.technologyreview.com/communications/16280/page1/ http://www.technologyreview.com/communications/16280/page1/
- Natsu 16y agoIt's a rocket docket. So cases move through very quickly. And many of the rulings have been very patent-friendly. There aren't very many judges in that district, either, as I recall. Now, you will find stats saying that patent holders don't win disproportionately often there. What those leave out is how many EDT cases settle beforehand. Basically, only the strongest cases even go to trial there and they still lose about half the time. I can't remember if there's a rule requiring local counsel or not, but I know that several firms have set up shop in or near Marshall, Texas.