3 ms·
> Dark-skinned women are told their photos are poor quality 22% of the time, while the figure for light-skinned women is 14% That doesn't surprise me even a ti
by mschuster91 6y ago
> Dark-skinned women are told their photos are poor quality 22% of the time, while the figure for light-skinned women is 14%
That doesn't surprise me even a tiny bit, given that the problem will already present itself in the camera - exposure settings are calibrated for white-ish people, and automated photo booths don't have a human to correct it or offer multiple different exposures to the user. Scanning the photo has the same problem.
- fogihujy 6y agoThere is definitely something to be said about the quality of pictures taken in photo booths, but the study specifically used pictures that were all of sufficiently high quality: > Photos of politicians were collected from parliaments around the world. The gender and skin tone were recorded for each photo using the Fitzpatrick skin-tone scale. Each image met the Home Office standards for a passport photo. That definitely suggests the software used for automatic image quality check simply isn't up to par.
- jmkd 6y agoWhile this sounds plausible - yet simply shifts the blame for the bias elsewhere in the technology supply chain - it does not adequately explain the experience of Elaine Owusu cited in the article. Her photo shows a clear-as-day mouth closed, which was repeatedly interpreted by the system as mouth open. No exposure settings would change that outcome.