3 ms·
> I also dont believe the original intent of the question was ever meant to be ambiguous with regard to whether he had knowledge of the goat door or whether he
by tshaddox 6y ago
> I also dont believe the original intent of the question was ever meant to be ambiguous with regard to whether he had knowledge of the goat door or whether he chose at random.
That’s extremely obvious! The entire reason to phrase the problem as a game show with a game show host is to make it abundantly clear that the host “knows the answers.”
- basch 6y agoIt might be semantics, but it doesn't matter if he knows or just always chooses goat. Reordering the sentence makes it clearer. "In all games where Monty chooses goat...". The premise creates a subset.
- tshaddox 6y agoNo, if Monty sometimes opens the door with the prize, and you ignore those games, then the result is different, and you don't benefit from switching doors.