10 ms·
> In contrast, Google didn't have their own independently developed programming language. They needed one so they copied the Java api and created one from there
by nl 6y ago
> In contrast, Google didn't have their own independently developed programming language. They needed one so they copied the Java api and created one from there. They did not use the Api to create a compatability layer. It was used as a starting point to make their own copy of Java.
This isn't an argument that has been made in court in anyway, and Google's use of the Java language hasn't been questioned.
Google could have used the Java language with completely different APIs (google.lang instead of java.lang for example). It's the APIs that this case is about.
Also, the key analogy is wrong anyway: while Android used java.lang and java.util and other related APIs, the key functionality of the phone was accessible via custom APIs that aren't copied. Note that the "interoperability" argument was lost by Google because of this exact thing.
- monocasa 6y ago> Google could have used the Java language with completely different APIs Well, no, because many Java language constructs are defined in context to the standard library, for instance all classes being children of java.lang.Object. They'd need quite a bit of java.lang at the very least.
- pjmlp 6y agoWhich even after their adoption of OpenJDK still isn't compatible out of the box with the standard library available at https://adoptopenjdk.net/ https://adoptopenjdk.net/ In 2020 it is still pretty much hint and miss getting a Java library working without changes on Android, given that the Android team cherry picks whatever they feel like from OpenJDK for their own Android API implementation purposes. Easily to find that out from Gerrit commits and AOSP source code. Meanwhile, effort has been spent ensuring that 100% of ISO C and ISO C++ are available on Android NDK. Thus out of the window goes the interoperability argument.
- monocasa 6y agoNothing happens to the interoperability argument. Nothing says it need to be 100% interoperable, or else you wouldn't be able to ship an MVP for any reimplementation of an API. And hell, the official JDK isn't even 100% interoperable with it's past selves. Maybe if Sun didn't play games with access to the TCK in the past we wouldn't be here adn there'd be a valid test for compliance that wasn't "do what the official JDK does".
- pjmlp 6y agoMaybe if Google had bought Sun after torpedoing it, we wouldn't be having this discussion and everyone was enjoying a Go style management with Java stuck at version 6.
- monocasa 6y agoYou shouldn't have to buy someone to ship a competing implementation. And Sun wasn't torpedoed. Do you have anything else to pivot to?
- pjmlp 6y agoIf Google didn't wanted to be sued (IBM would likely have done the same), their solution was to own Java instead of hoping that their torpedo would have sunk Sun's ship without a hiss. I am not pivoting, Google has only itself to blame for their little J++ adventure. "James Gosling Triangulation's Interview on Google vs. Sun" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYw3X4RZv6Y&feature=youtu.be&t=57m42s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYw3X4RZv6Y&feature=youtu.be... Basically wanting Java as free beer, without paying Sun any money given that Java actually required licenses for handsets/embedded deployments in pre-OpenJDK days, in the not so good economical situation that they were, withdrawing them from possible Android license revenues. That is torpedoing, regardless how Google employees, or wannabe employees play it.
- monocasa 6y agoExcept Sun never charged for handset/embedded deployments. They charged for access to the J2ME trademark. This case is neither about trademarks nor J2ME. That means they wouldn't have gotten any money from SavaJe like phones either. The only people who "torpedoed" Sun was Sun themselves. And yes, switching from an interoperabilty argument to 'they were morally obligated to buy Sun' is very much pivoting to a different argument. Also, here's James Gosling later saying that APIs should not be copyrightable. http://nighthacks.com/jag/blog/397/index.html http://nighthacks.com/jag/blog/397/index.html