2 ms·
Once you move into the realm of untestable vague hand waving statements, it’s not really even science anymore. Philosophical discussions that dress up like sci
by kortilla 6y ago
Once you move into the realm of untestable vague hand waving statements, it’s not really even science anymore. Philosophical discussions that dress up like science are infuriating for anyone who went in looking for science.
- pegasus 6y agoIt's not dressing up as science, though. I understand that for someone who appreciates science, but not philosophy, the book turning out as straddling those two fields might be a letdown. But that's not the authors fault since those books are not presented as academic research, but only informed by it. Infuriating for me are philosophical discussions which don't draw substantially on science.
- Angostura 6y agoI felt let down by Penrose, because the book was dressed up as sonething it was not. By comparison Dennett and Pinker and Hofstadter were much more satisfying.