4 ms·
> This is way overstating the complicated-ness of marginal income taxes for 99.9% of people. Only because it is a cause of 99.9% of people operating that way.
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> This is way overstating the complicated-ness of marginal income taxes for 99.9% of people.
Only because it is a cause of 99.9% of people operating that way. The amount of tax and other paperwork involved is one of the primary reasons people don't commonly take on small side jobs (or do but don't report them). That is one of the major costs of the complexity.
> And with the use of computers and electronic databases containing individual's unique ID # (e.g. social security #) and the internet to transmit payroll information
You don't see how this is, itself, a dramatic increase in complexity? With a flat tax individuals wouldn't even need to have a unique ID.
That we might be able to dump the complexity of this on businesses instead of individuals isn't making it go away, it's just making it harder to do business because now you need complicated tax software and central databases.
Also, the individual is still doing paperwork, because how else is the employer getting their ID number?
> This is irrelevant and I don't see why anyone would have a problem with people "minimizing" taxes in the way shown as it's above board, and tax policy taxes individuals, not families.
It's clearly a violation of the spirit of a progressive tax system. If a rich person buys his nephew a car, he has to pay his own marginal tax rate on it. If he instead pays his nephew the value of the car as a salary, he pays no tax on the money and the nephew pays the lower marginal rate. And that assuming the entire thing isn't just a kickback system where the rich person ends up with use of the car anyway and they privately agree to do it that way to split the "savings" from the marginal rate arbitrage.
It's subverting the intent of the system, in a way that can't be done if they were both paying the same marginal rate and progressivity was achieved by giving everyone a large fixed starting credit (i.e. UBI).
> That kind of stuff doesn't last too long in my experience though, once people get a taste of financial independence, the individuals in a "family" start looking out for themselves first.
But it's still a dependent relationship. The nephew only continues to get the money by staying on the good side of his "employer" -- it's the same situation where the wealthy use their money to control those in their social circle, but now you're giving them a tax discount for doing it.