4 ms·
Oral arguments have already happened: https://www.c-span.org/video/?469263-1/google-v-oracle-america-oral-argument https://www.c-span.org/video/?469263-1/google
by jcranmer 6y ago
Oral arguments have already happened: https://www.c-span.org/video/?469263-1/google-v-oracle-america-oral-argument https://www.c-span.org/video/?469263-1/google-v-oracle-ameri...
I wasn't able to listen to all of the arguments, but some general takeaways I had:
* The justices seemed to be asking mostly technical legal questions of Google (e.g., discuss merger doctrine) and mostly doom-and-gloom questions of Oracle (e.g., how does your argument impact QWERTY keyboards?). This suggests to me that they're more in favor of Google's position, and are querying how to arrive at that decision from a legal basis.
* Some of the questions suggest to me that the justices agree with Google's view that declaring code is categorically distinct from implementation code, and perhaps that copyright for the former doesn't exist.
* Thomas had an interesting question that went unanswered: "the four factors to determine fair use are not exhaustive, can you think of any other factors?" (paraphrased).
- foota 6y agoHuh, that last note is pretty interesting. You seem pretty tuned in, do you know when we might be able to expect a written decision?
- jcranmer 6y agoThe decision can theoretically come anytime between now and the end of next June, largely dependent on how complex the decision is. My personal guess is somewhere between January and March of next year.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AmericanChopper 6y ago> This suggests to me that they're more in favor of Google's position, and are querying how to arrive at that decision from a legal basis. I wouldn't read that much into it. Google has made the argument that "this means doom-and-gloom" and Oracle that "this is technically illegal". It makes sense that they're interrogating the parties along the lines of the arguments that have been presented. I wouldn't say it's a signal that they favor one over the other.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bitwize 6y agoThe expert to turn to in cases like this is Florian Mueller. While everybody else insisted the Alsup ruling was a slam dunk for Google and would settle API copyrightability once and for all, Mueller insisted that Oracle would win on appeal -- and they did. Mueller is now telling us that the Court will find for Oracle in a near-unanimous, if not actually unanimous, decision: http://www.fosspatents.com/2020/10/supreme-court-inclined-to-affirm.html http://www.fosspatents.com/2020/10/supreme-court-inclined-to... He points out that the justices have been asking some really pointed questions of Google since you made this post, questions which suggest that they don't buy Google's crap for a second and they think Google is trying to pull a fast one. The law is pretty unambiguous that Google is liable for copyright infringement. Just because techies thought the law didn't work the way it does for decades doesn't actually change anything.