5 ms·
Ford's had about 112 years, and Tesla's had 17. I'm not saying that makes it excusable but I think the scale is important, other major car manufacturers have b
by pc86 6y ago
Ford's had about 112 years, and Tesla's had 17.
I'm not saying that makes it excusable but I think the scale is important, other major car manufacturers have been around 4-5x as long.
- vowelless 6y agoThis is such a dumb point. When Ford started, horses were the main means of transportation. Comparing that to Tesla’s beginning, which was at the peak of car manufacturing, is stupid.
- jnwatson 6y agoNo, but it fair to start, say in 1980. It took Ford a solid quarter century to catch up to the quality innovations present in Japanese manufacturers.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoI think nostalgia is clouding your judgement. By the mid 90s the domestics had more or less closed the gap. They just didn't apply the techniques and processes to the product lines they didn't care about (i.e. economy cars, they were selling SUVs hand over fist after all). And if you look at MRSPs for foreign and domestic economy cars throughout the 90s the prices more or less reflect the respective OEM's level of investment in those product lines. If you wanted an economy car you bought a Civic. If you wanted a shitbox you bought an Escort for less money.
- anthony_d 6y ago> By the mid 90s the domestics had more or less closed the gap. I completely disagree with that. I bought a Cadillac in 2012. Its build quality was lower than anything I've seen from BMW, Audi or Volvo. I'm talking about really inconsistent panel (internal and exterior) gaps and misc vehicle rattles. It's also worth mentioning the Cadillac was the most expensive vehicle of the group and very much a line that GM cared about. I have no idea how Ford is doing, but GM is still not comparable to German/Swedish/Korean manufacturers.
- kazen44 6y agoAlso, manufacturing engineering and mass production was just getting started. hell, Ford was famous for adopting scientific management and the assembly line to cranck out a massive amount of cars at that time. I would even argue ford's model of manufacturing turned the last remnats of workshop based work into the mass producing factory.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoYes, Tesla may not have the best manufacturing quality, but compared against American cars from the 80's... They've only been mass manufacturing for about 4 years now; previous models are low volume models with a lot of hand assembly. Musk says that manufacturing is a couple of orders of magnitude harder than designing and building prototypes. He's learning these lessons the hard way. If you can survive the lesson, it's the best way to learn them. Little consolation to those who buy the lemons during the learning period, though. This is also a tale about America. Tesla's Chinese factory gets first place on a similar survey to the JD Powers initial quality survey that Tesla America got last place in. America just doesn't have the deep well of manufacturing knowledge that a new company like Tesla can draw on.
- buran77 6y agoThe problem is the conscious choice to prioritize quantity over quality. Make no mistake, Tesla's leadership consciously chose to let quality slide in order to meet the delivery volumes because the latter is what pumps stock prices. And they did this knowing it could (and did) very well lead to direct loss of life. This is what would worry me as a potential customer. That the manufacturer selling me their product considers such disasters acceptable in order to ship a few more units. It's not that often lately than manufacturers are willing to do this (think GM ignition key scandal, rather than VW pollution cheating).
- abduhl 6y ago>> America just doesn't have the deep well of manufacturing knowledge that a new company like Tesla can draw on. Is this serious? America has been offshoring domestic auto manufacturing for a couple decades now. The people who worked in those factories didn’t just die, they’re mostly still available for hire. There is no metric in manufacturing knowledge where America lags that far behind other first world countries, let alone the rest of the world.
- bumby 6y agoThe age is a bigger issue than you might think. When I worked in automotive manufacturing, I bet the average age was approaching 50. Combine that with work that is more manual in nature and there might be more concern that there is a skill/worker shortage. The DoD has identified this as a risk [1] and notes that a majority of manufacturing workers are over 45 years old [2] [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/04/opinion/america-military-industrial-base.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/04/opinion/america-military-... [2] https://www.defensenews.com/pentagon/2018/05/22/americas-industrial-base-is-at-risk-and-the-military-may-feel-the-consequences/ https://www.defensenews.com/pentagon/2018/05/22/americas-ind...
- DanBC 6y agoBut Ford and other car makers are not keeping their TQM / Kaizen / etc methodology secret. Tesla aren't starting from nothing, they're able to use all the existing knowledge about putting together a factory to build product.
- TehCorwiz 6y agoThose methodologies don’t proscribe the bests places to hold a piece of glass for optimal adhesion. Just how to structure and operate just-in-time workflows.
- DanBC 6y agoI'm a bit confused. Do people really think that "gluing the glass in" is some bit of advanced engineering?
- steffan 6y ago> Do people really think that "gluing the glass in" is some bit of advanced engineering? Conversely, do _you_ really think that - evenly applying an adhesive to an incredibly smooth surface (repeatably) to bond it to a frame and have it undergo twisting, vibration, and extremes of heat and cold, aerodynamic effects / pressure, exposure to moisture, UV and atmospheric contaminants and retaining its adhesion for the expected life of the vehicle - isn't advanced engineering?
- bumby 6y agoDon't forget to add the nuances of automation, machine wear, etc.
- DanBC 6y agoBut you're talking about chemical engineering of making glue, and luckily 3m (etc) have already done all that work. All Tesla have to do is "buy the right glue", and then "make sure it gets put on correctly". That is a bit of production engineering but seriously it's not hard to lay down a bead of adhesive, place the glass in, and then check that it's been done.
- drcongo 6y agoNobody at Ford has been working there for 112 years. The thing is, Tesla could just hire people who have experience working in quality control for car manufacturing and then they'd be just as experienced at it as Ford. Your logic suggests either a) they haven't bothered hiring people experienced in quality control for car manufacturing, or b) they have, and yet their cars are _still_ this badly made. Neither is a good look.
- qppo 6y agoOr c) they can't because people don't want to work there
- bigmattystyles 6y agoI think you have a valid point but institutional knowledge and processes outlast any one employee's tenure.
- bumby 6y agoCorporate culture doesn't just shift overnight. The Big Three didn't get serious about quality control until Japanese automakers started eating their lunch. Even then, it took time to really ingrain it into the company culture. I don't know what the Tesla culture is like, but if it skews toward the tech "move fast and break things", just hiring experienced QA folks won't magically get everyone onboard to strict, controlled processes.
- Dig1t 6y agoThis is so true, look at any GM or Chrysler car from the 90's. Complete abominations of cars with cheap plastic everywhere and myriad mechanical problems. You can see their attempts to catch up to Japanese cars during this time.
- mcculley 6y agoI would like to buy a Tesla. How many years do you think I should wait?
- zeroxfe 6y ago-5 (which is when I bought mine -- as much as people like to hate on it, it's an incredible car.)
- dayjobpork 6y agoDepends if you want a convertible or not
- ivraatiems 6y agoPersonally, I am waiting until Tesla's competition gets their act together and starts producing more EVs. Mercedes and Volkswagen are both moving in that direction, for instance. I think in the next 5-10 years there will be plenty of EVs on the market in most countries, and Tesla will no longer stand out simply because they were first. I drive a Subaru now. If I could get an EV version of my present car with comparable range, I'd buy it today and never look back. They say by 2035 they'll have electric versions of all their major models[1], so I guess... sometime in the next 15 years, for me? [1] https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a30613610/subaru-crossover-concept-ev-hybrid-plans/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a30613610/subaru-crossover...
- qchris 6y agoI'm very much in the same boat. It's one of the things that has always confused me a little about Subaru, since they seem like they've been really well-placed to take advantage of the transition to electric vehicles. A lot of their customer base cares about things like the environment, usually has some degree of disposable income (they're not the cheapest car on the market) and places a high value on areas like reliability and simple functionality. Electric cars already are supposed to require less maintenance than your average ICE vehicle, and the four-cylinder boxer engine/CVT combo isn't exactly known as a hotrod combo either, so it's not as if the need to satisfy their customer base on 0-60mph time anway (for that type of car, ignore the WRX for a moment). If they made a Crosstrek/Forester-type vehicle with 300-400 miles of all-electric range, kept the ground clearance, roof rack, and usual interiors, I've always imagined that those vehicles would sell like hotcakes. I know I'd be interested in immediately trading up, in a way that I probably won't be otherwise for a long time.
- kazen44 6y agoand car and production technology has shifted massively in those 100 years. Producing cars in itself is not a new process from a manufacturing perspective, especially not the non EV parts. (like body work and structural work). What kind of quality control does tesla have, when it is not able to reliably produce cars with the same finish and fit. Most manufacturers have been able to do this for atleast 30 years. it is not like the industry doesn't have solutions to tackle these issues at scale.
- donarb 6y agoFastening one piece of metal to another piece of metal is a solved problem. Why is Tesla having to relearn that problem?
- davidgould 6y agoThe roof is glass,not metal.