6 ms·
From everything I've read, Wine would quite clearly be illegal if the court rules in favor of Oracle. I am very worried about this case.
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
From everything I've read, Wine would quite clearly be illegal if the court rules in favor of Oracle.
I am very worried about this case.
- Spivak 6y agoI don't think it would be infringement. The main difference between WINE and Android is where the interoperability integration points are. WINE is using the Windows names for the purposes of allowing Windows programs to run. This is a case where a judge would easily grant fair-use because you have to use the API surface area to provide compatibility for existing programs. Android is using the Java names for the purposes of allowing existing Java developers to be productive, not so that existing Java programs can run.
- jasode 6y ago>I don't think it would be infringement. The main difference between WINE and Android is where the interoperability integration points are. [...] Android is using the Java names for the purposes of allowing existing Java developers to be _productive_, not so that existing Java programs can run. >Since Oracle's claim is that Google's use of the Java APIs wasn't to provide compatibility to existing software written in Java but to have a _familiar_ language for Java developers it becomes a novel but normal copyright case. You're making a distinction between "interopability" and "end user familiarity". But Lotus also sued Borland on the basis of "familiarity" of the menu "names and structure" and they lost. The Supreme Court's 4-4 split decision left the lower appeals court's ruling intact. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotus_Dev._Corp._v._Borland_Int%27l,_Inc.#Background_information https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotus_Dev._Corp._v._Borland_In...
- dontblink 6y agoYou are making a distinction when there isn't one from the legal opinion perspective.
- simiones 6y agoThere is actually, and the court argued as such: if Android had been compatible with Java programs, Google could have claimed a fair-use exemption. Since Android can't run many Java programs, by design, they can't claim such an exemption. WINE could very likely win a legal battle through claiming a fair-use exemption (of course, if the case fails, they wouldn't have to go to court at all).
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoWhy is the distinction between "runs with zero changes" and "runs with minimal changes"—or even just "runs with fewer changes"—so critical? Where is the line? Is Android "compatible" with Java programs if those programs need to be recompiled first, but no source edits are necessary? What if source edits are necessary, but can be automated? What if recompiling isn't necessary, but you need to hex edit the binary? "Compatibility" is a spectrum, and I'd say Android falls within that range.
- Spivak 6y agoBecause the actual implementation isn't what the courts are looking for. This is a case about Google's intention for copying the Java API. Oracle is claiming that Google copied their API because it was easier than designing a new language; Google is claiming that they did it for interoperability reasons. There is no distinction between the two because these things are presented as evidence of Google's intent, it's not proof. There's no line. Google's case would be much stronger is Android-Java could run most Java software unmodified but it doesn't mean they'll lose just because it's not true.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoThanks, that's interesting! It seems reasonable—if Google was explicitly trying to enable compatibility, that should be allowed, whereas if they were just trying to save a buck, that should be illegal. Of course, in reality Google's decision was probably a little of both, right? They selected a technology based on a wide range of factors, including development costs and compatibility. I'm still concerned that a decision in Oracle's favor would have a massive chilling effect on everyone else. All companies want to limit their potential liabilities. How can you prove in advance that you selected a language or API for the sake of compatibility, even when that is in fact the driving factor?
- Eyas 6y agoIt's not just about "developer interoperability" vs "program interoprability". Implementing Java APIs means that entire libraries can run. Sure you might not be able to take a legacy SWING Windows Java app and run it on android, but you can run entire libraries in your android app. It absolutely _is_ about interoperability in both cases. Perhaps to varying degrees
- orangecat 6y agoCorrect, and I was always surprised that Google didn't argue this point more. In my Android apps I've used Java libraries that were created years before Android even existed, and they work perfectly. And vice versa; I've reused code I originally wrote for Android in a Java desktop app with zero changes.
- treis 6y agoWine makes programs written for Windows work on Linux. The key difference is that Linux is an independently developed system. The extent that wine copies Windows code is limited to a compatability layer. It doesn't transform Linux into just a copy of Windows. In contrast, Google didn't have their own independently developed programming language. They needed one so they copied the Java api and created one from there. They did not use the Api to create a compatability layer. It was used as a starting point to make their own copy of Java.
- jayd16 6y agoDidn't they though? They've had their own vm and bytecode for as long as Android has been released. The use of Java is for making libraries compatible.
- treis 6y agoThey did have their own vm and byte code but not a programming language.
- jayd16 6y agoIs bytecode not a language?
- tmccrary55 6y agoYeah, so mov or iload instructions would be protected copyright if Oracle wins.
- treis 6y agoI would say no but either way it's not what Google copied.
- CobrastanJorji 6y agoIf I'm understanding your argument, if Google independently developed a programming language, and then they implemented a compatibility layer that accepted Java bytecode invoking Java APIs and translated it in realtime to their not-Java programming language, then this would be okay? How would such a programming language be detectably different from being an implementation of Java?