4 ms·
>Should that be counted? Yes. The Supreme Court ruled the mandate is a tax. ”The mandate is an amendment to the Internal Revenue Code, and it is calculated ba
by bumby 6y ago
>Should that be counted?
Yes. The Supreme Court ruled the mandate is a tax.
”The mandate is an amendment to the Internal Revenue Code, and it is calculated based on a percentage of adjusted gross income or a fixed amount, whichever is larger. Starting in 2014, it will be collected on your form 1040 just like your other taxes.” [1]
The issue wasn’t with your claim that wealthy pay a disproportionate share. That’s literally what the intent of a progressive tax regime is supposed to ensure. The issue was with the biased representation of a subset of taxes to make your point.
Would you claim that long distance commuters pay unfair levels of taxes because they are disproportionately represented in gasoline taxes? Or does it make more sense to frame it in the overall context of total tax revenue?
I’m not quite sure if your stance is that the tax code is wrong morally or pragmatically but it’s doing exactly what a progressive tax schedule is supposed to do.
[1] https://amp.theatlantic.com/amp/article/256706/ https://amp.theatlantic.com/amp/article/256706/
- WalterBright 6y agoThe point I was making was a response to: > Also, you're ignoring Sweden and Denmark. Many countries have discovered oil - the USA is a massive producer, far more than Norway - they just didn't create a fund with it, preferring to give the profits to the few.
- bumby 6y agoAre you insinuating the US’s tax structure is preferential, worse, or just different? Again, you stated a statistic but it wasn’t immediately clear what the larger point you were getting at