4 ms·
Personally I think there's a middle ground that's very important, which is that I think anyone who received a university degree in the US and passes the backgro
by dheera 6y ago
Personally I think there's a middle ground that's very important, which is that I think anyone who received a university degree in the US and passes the background check should be able to get an unrestricted work visa.
The US should want to keep the talent it selects and trains. These are people who build the economy, generate IP, and create jobs in the long run. Not only that, but these people who have spent 4+ years in the US university education system are extremely well-adapted to life in the US and will thrive at making the US a better place.
(Yes there's OPT, but it's not long enough and doesn't provide a path to permanent residency.)
- HarryHirsch 6y agoanyone who received a university degree in the US No. No. No. That would mean that anyone from the University of Oxford would be out until he got himself a masters degree from the Christian College of Lost Hope, AR. There are far too many paid masters degrees around already that serve exactly that purpose and that are good for no one except the useless college.
- jedberg 6y agoThey're not saying to exclude everyone else, just that if you are here for four years getting a degree, you should be able to stay.
- dheera 6y ago> masters degree from the Christian College of Lost Hope, AR Yeah no, screw that crap. I don't know the exact regulation framework that would accomplish my intent but you understand what I mean. I'm talking about all the people with bonafide degrees and skillsets. 4-year bachelor degrees, PhDs, MDs, and the like. These people should be treated as assets to the country. (Maybe just excluding masters' degrees is the answer, but I'm not sure.) It's dumbfoundingly stupid as a national policy to invest so much in resources to train a person and then send them back to another country instead of giving them every incentive to stay. Singapore and Australia (and maybe others I don't know about) allow international students to apply for permanent residency if they meet certain very reasonable qualifications and it works out very much in their favor for retaining talent.
- munk-a 6y agoThe issue is that America is allergic to sensible regulation so never would you find a way to craft a law that allowed those 4-year bachelor degrees to be counted without pulling in all the for-profit unis and if you attempted that you'd be buried in lawsuits and public outcry.
- Larrikin 6y agoTalking with friends that were international students, who also knew about the abuses of the current system, we came to the conclusion that to avoid abuse and get actual world class talent you would want to tier the system. Master's and PhD holders already benefit in the current system so better to expand the idea. Undergraduate degree holders would only be rewarded for completing degrees in in the US in emerging and vital fields (mostly STEM). Awarding permanent residency to someone completing an Bachelors in communication at the worst college in the US is simply inviting abuse. Master's holders would get permanent residency in an expanding set of fields and ideally PhDs in every field. There may be some cases of abuse, but there should never be the case where a smart person educated in the US, especially in a growing or important field is forced out of the country because they didn't win a lottery.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoemerging and vital fields (mostly STEM) You'd be surprised there. The degree that gives best odds in law school is actually philosophy. If you want to keep the tradition of Latin alive you need kids who have taken decent Latin in school. Chemistry and the life sciences, on the other hand, there is a terrifying oversupply of graduates. I agree with the need for quality control.
- nrmitchi 6y agoHaha are you arguing that the US needs more lawyers? /s
- dheera 6y agoYes I agree with this. GP:> completing an Bachelors in communication at the worst college in the US I think the key here should be "worst college in the US" and not the Bachelors in communication. If you got a communication degree from Mizzou or Columbia that's a totally different bar than a communication degree from a community college. The institutions and programs should be accredited, and demonstrate some standard of selectivity. You want talented people in every field to stay in your country and create value and jobs, and selectivity for university admission is often a good proxy for that. The bar doesn't need to be insanely higher either; anyone who creates value and by doing so either directly or indirectly creates more jobs is worthwhile to keep.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]