3 ms·
Let's get some terminology right. Immigrants are defined in US law as lawful permanent residents, i.e. green card holders. Congress caps the number of green ca
by arcticbull 6y ago
Let's get some terminology right.
Immigrants are defined in US law as lawful permanent residents, i.e. green card holders. Congress caps the number of green cards issued at 366,000 per year. Therefore, the number of new immigrants to the US each year is 366,000. The 140,000 number I initially used incorrectly was the number of employment based green cards as compared to family based. I've updated the math. [edit] It's 1M once you factor in family of citizens.
Everyone else is a non-immigrant visitor, and not relevant to my numbers.
> The U.S. foreign-born population reached a record 44.8 million in 2018.
The immigrant and descendent of immigrant population of the US is roughly 100%, because there are only 5 million native Americans in the US.
> What amazes me is how much hate the US gets for being one of the most generous countries on Earth.
Canada brings in 25X per capita the number of refugees and 10X per capita the number of new lawful permanent resident.
You're simply mistaken.
- newfriend 6y agoUnfortunately your smug reply is wrong, as I said before. From: https://www.dhs.gov/immigration-statistics/yearbook/2018/table1 https://www.dhs.gov/immigration-statistics/yearbook/2018/tab... Table 1. Persons Obtaining Lawful Permanent Resident Status: Fiscal Years 1820 to 2018 Year Number 2018 1,096,611 2017 1,127,167 2016 1,183,505 This also obviously doesn't even count the number of illegal aliens coming here every year. > The immigrant and descendent of immigrant population of the US is roughly 100%, because there are only 5 million native Americans in the US. Native Americans came from elsewhere at some point too, I suppose they are immigrants also according to your meaningless definition. Forgive me if I don't care about the per-capita number of refugees in Canada. You are the one who is mistaken.
- arcticbull 6y agoI likely excluded the number of US citizen direct family members, which means Canada brings in 5X per capita not 10X - or even the 20X from before. That's still a startlingly large delta. > Forgive me if I don't care about the per-capita number of refugees in Canada. Well then why are you replying to me? > You are the one who is mistaken. I'm wrong about lots of things, and my goal is always to get it right, and I've edited my responses for clarity, with a statement of why. However, the fact remains, 25X more refugees per capita and 5X more immigrants per capita is a lot. Thank you for your help in figuring out where the delta was! I didn't mean to come off smug though, I saw other folks had varying definitions of what an "immigrant" was.