4 ms·
What I can see, literally, by looking around is that my phone is made by Huawei, my TV by Samsung, my medicine is made by a large pharmaceutical company, the tr
by Barrin92 6y ago
What I can see, literally, by looking around is that my phone is made by Huawei, my TV by Samsung, my medicine is made by a large pharmaceutical company, the train I take to work and the rail network are built by a state owned company, the web framework I used yesterday is made by a colossal tech giant, so is the text editor I use (granted that one may vary), and the cloud infrastructure my software runs on. So are the cars on the sideways looking out of the window. All big firms.
Large firms are quite literally who built all the complicated stuff at huge scale that pretty much everyone relies on all the time. I actually have to search around before I find something that was made by a small business.
And that's not because of some conspiracy, it's because they happen to make the best stuff cheap, which is a consequence of their scale. It's not a myth, you can literally confirm that by I suppose checking who makes the stuff you voluntarily buy each day.
- koluna 6y agoNone of those things were “invented” or truly brought to the edge of technological abilities by the companies you described. They piggyback off of existing invention, and pretty much are interested in keeping things as-is. Your phone manufacturer doesn’t care about invention as much as they care about you buying the next, slightly better model. Your TV manufacturer is interested in recouping the losses they have on selling you a cheap device by pushing as much advertising as possible. The pharma company is interested in gouging as much money as they can through holding patents - they don’t develop medicine out of the goodness of their hearts. You get the point.
- jfim 6y ago> None of those things were “invented” or truly brought to the edge of technological abilities by the companies you described. Actually, the large conglomerates do have R&D labs working on semiconductors, chemistry, manufacturing, and so on, so that they can come up with improvements to sell. The reason why semiconductors get smaller, TVs get brighter colors, larger panels have acceptable manufacturing yields, is exactly because of this R&D.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Judgmentality 6y agoA few large firms competing with each other is very different from a monopoly. Some of the things you mentioned have reasonable competition (phones, TVs, cars) and some are deeply steeped in anti-competitive practices (medicine, public transit). Your argument was used to make Boeing into a monopoly and look how that turned out. It's easy to cherry-pick examples for either side, but I'd say take a step back and look at the trends and which way the evidence favors. At the end of the day it all comes down to incentives - and what incentive does a monopoly have to compete?
- Barrin92 6y ago> few large firms competing with each other is very different from a monopoly. very true but that's what we've been talking about in the comment chain, there's no actual global monopoly or one static entity, hence the explicit reference to Schumpeter's 'monopolistic competition'. There is still competition between large firms, but the dynamism is temporal, few firms for years or decades seize outsized marketshare to dominate and innovate sectors before being replaced by other substantial firms, rather than a sort of bazaar economy of small firms competing at the same time. It's myspace being superceded by facebook maybe being eaten by tiktok that's going to drive technological innovation in social media, not mastodon instances. Of course it's easy to cherry-pick, but you don't need to cherry pick. You can look at the economic development in mature economies vs developing economies. This tendency towards consolidation and innovation occurs in every single one. That's why South Korea and Japan have more large firms and are more productive than most of their Asian peers, it's why China with its economic model has outgrown India, where the same process is occuring now (see Jio).