3 ms·
On a national level, the polls really did, well, not amazing, but fine, last time. 538's final polling average was Clinton+3.8, actual result was Clinton+2.1. T
by rsynnott 6y ago
On a national level, the polls really did, well, not amazing, but fine, last time. 538's final polling average was Clinton+3.8, actual result was Clinton+2.1. That's not at all bad; you wouldn't call that an upset.
The real problem was a lack of high-quality state-level polls, and in one or two cases major misses on what state polls there were; there wasn't all that much visibility on many states.
And ultimately, the final result was so close that it was below the margin of error of any reasonable poll to detect. Even assuming the highest quality polls conducted in each state, every day, the best they'd have been able to say would have been, pretty much "It's 50/50", in retrospect.
- nl 6y agoAnd the state level polling errors were highly correlated, which 538 called out in their pre-election coverage, but people ignored.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The real problem was a lack of high-quality state-level polls That wasn't even really a problem; the error in state polling was pretty consistent with the error in national polling; the problem with predictors other than 538 is they treated state variations from polling averages as independent, 538 correctly assessed them (based on past evidence) as highly correlated, which is why Trump had a nearly 1 in 3 chance in 538s forecast. The problem is people taking (honestly or just for the purpose of after-the-fact criticism) "1 in 3" to mean "absolutely won't happen".