2 ms·
I'm not sure it's that simple, because even _after the fact_ people were talking about how 538 "said Clinton would win". They're doing so in this comments secti
by rsynnott 6y ago
I'm not sure it's that simple, because even _after the fact_ people were talking about how 538 "said Clinton would win". They're doing so in this comments section, in fact.
I also seem to remember seeing a study that people made better probability-based decisions if given probabilities phrased as fractions than percentages; I wonder if something similar is going on with the cards example.
- impendia 6y agoI think what people sense -- and this is related to the "Bayesian vs. frequentist" debate -- is that an election is not really a random event. The source of uncertainty is different. The Card Sharks example is a genuinely random event. If you draw a random card, it will probably be higher than 5, but it could be lower. Whereas an election is not truly random. By election day the outcome is essentially foreordained. The "randomness" that 538 is trying to model are things like uncertainty and unreliability in the polls. What is the relationship between what voters said they will do, and what they actually will do? You can make inferences based on the past, but every election is different, and the mood of the electorate is definitely unique this year. Nate Silver knows from his experience to hedge his bets, as he did in 2016. It's much more complicated and subtle than a genuinely random event. I find it understandable that people get confused.
- noneeeed 6y agoAnother area of complexity in presidential elections is the electoral college. People see the headline polling numbers and assess them as if it were a straight popular vote with a simple outcome, when I'm reality the end result is highly dependent on where votes are cast.