3 ms·
> I feel like there are a lot of background assumptions involved in that process Like what?
by lisper 6y ago
> I feel like there are a lot of background assumptions involved in that process
Like what?
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoIn your informal example, I’m assuming that the person I’m speaking to is an honest interlocutor. In the scientist’s formal counterpart, he is assuming that the phenomena he observes correspond to the representation he assigns in the formal model. For a specific example, in order to infer the composition of a star, one must assume that the spectra emitted by a star are products of the same emission process as observed in a laboratory here on Earth.
- lisper 6y ago> I’m assuming that the person I’m speaking to is an honest interlocutor. OK, but you have taken it upon yourself to assume that. I never asked you to assume it. It is entirely possible that the person you are talking to is not being honest. They could be gaslighting you. It is even possible that they are not a person. They could be a shape-shifting space alien disguising themselves as a person as part of a grand conspiracy to prevent you from discovering the fact that you are a 13-dimensional being with super-powers who would take over the universe if you became aware of your true nature. So... among these two theories which I have now proposed to explain your observations, which do you think is more likely?
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoI’m not sure which is more likely, I have interacted with honest interlocutors and with gaslighters before. That’s kind of the point, isn’t it? I can easily assume good faith and move forward, which involves an assumption of good faith. Or I can refuse to assume anything and do what now?
- lisper 6y ago> I’m not sure which is more likely. Seriously? You assign the same probability to classical physics as you do to people around you being shape-shifting space aliens disguising themselves as people as part of a grand conspiracy to prevent you from discovering the fact that you are a 13-dimensional being with super-powers who would take over the universe if you became aware of your true nature? You'll have to excuse me if I find that hard to believe.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoNo, the 13th dimensional being was your theory. I just didn’t believe the person in the scenario you described, the same way you are doubting my sincerity in this little conversation.
- lisper 6y ago> the 13th dimensional being was your theory Yes. So? > I just didn’t believe the person in the scenario you described, Why not? > the same way you are doubting my sincerity in this little conversation. Not quite the same way, because I can answer the "why not" question, and I'm pretty sure you can't. But let's leave that aside and try a different experiment. I presume you have a mobile phone? If not, substitute some other common object. For the next week, for everyone you encounter, show them your cell phone (or whatever common object you choose) and ask them, "Do you see this? What is it?" and see if you don't observe a certain consistency in their answers. How do you account for that consistency?
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> Why not? Because thats the exercise we agreed to practice; how to make a theory without assuming anything. I neither believe nor disbelieve this person, how am I to use their testimony to construct a theory without taking it as some English words with particular meanings that are presumed to be presented in good faith as an accurate representation of their perspective? > Not quite the same way, because I can answer the "why not" question, and I'm pretty sure you can't. Ok how do you answer the “why not?” question? > How do you account for that consistency? Ok if I correctly understand you, you’re saying that I can infer a consistency between phenomena by observing that they appear to be similar. Is that an accurate restatement of your thesis?