3 ms·
I agree with the content of the article, but feel a summary is sufficient to get the point across. Beginning with a quote: > If someone claims to have better i
by usmannk 6y ago
I agree with the content of the article, but feel a summary is sufficient to get the point across. Beginning with a quote:
> If someone claims to have better information than a mainstream financial market on the value of Google stock, or of copper, they ought to either use this knowledge to make a huge amount of money or stop talking about it. However, it is not true if we are discussing prediction markets. Current prediction markets are so bad in so many different ways that it simply is not surprising for people to know better than them, and it often is not possible for people to make money from knowing better.
Ok so why is this?
- Betting markets are illiquid, there is not enough activity for good price discovery.
- Betting markets are capital inefficient. In real life I can short a security without putting up any cash up front, paying interest as my position ages. To make a x:1 return in the betting market I must collateralize (lock away) the entire "1" at the outset. Another example: Say I think Trump will make it to the end of his term as president, right now on PredictIt I can make $1 for every ~$0.80 bet. In real markets I'd sell "no" shares to collect the $0.20 premium for essentially free (if I'm right). On PredictIt I have to stake $0.80 upfront (by buying "yes" shares) for every $0.20 I want to make.
- Betting markets are EXPENSIVE. PredictIt takes a 10% fee on profits and then a 5% fee on all withdrawals. So not only do you have to be right, you have to hit it on a huge margin!
- jonas21 6y agoIn my opinion, the most important section (and one I did not know about before) is: > PredictIt places a limit of $800 on your position in any one bet. At the market level, this means that you can no longer rely on small numbers of intelligent people to fix market prices for you... If you face a 35% tax rate, and think Trump's chance to win is literally zero, after investing $800 you end up with: [equation] = $1049.44 > making a profit of about $250 in exchange for knowing with absolute certainty that an event a prediction market has at a 40% probability is guaranteed not to happen. This is not sufficient to merit dedicating time and effort to research.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]