2 ms·
> private groups affairs. No such thing. They are relying on societal assurances that contracts they enter will be enforced, that property they hold will be p
by whimsicalism 6y ago
> private groups affairs.
No such thing. They are relying on societal assurances that contracts they enter will be enforced, that property they hold will be protected, etc. Society is free to regulate those "private group affairs" since they are externalizing the costs onto society.
> there is a lot of value there, more importantly it's not obvious
Sure, but generally in the cases where politicians mistakenly intervene in markets with distortionary effects, economists are pretty united that the intervention will be a bad idea (see: rent control).
On anti-trust, economists recognize monopolies as a pretty clear market failure and it seems to be the tech employees who are deploying the "free market" arguments in defense of Google, FB, et al.
- jariel 6y ago" Society is free to regulate those "private group affairs" since they are externalizing the costs onto society." Private property, freedom of association is a very real thing. It's a very serious thing to take private people's stuff from them. So we have to be careful.
- whimsicalism 6y agoThere's no state of nature where people are engaging in private transactions with legally enforced contracts, creating corporations with limited liability up to the size of the investment, etc. Those are all constructs of society. Your idea that there are these transactions and property 'outside of society' that we have to protect from interference from society does not seem coherent to me, when the existence of a society that does grant private property rights is what allows a Google to exist in the first place.
- jariel 6y agoThis is totally upside down. What is 'coherent' is a civil society that is consistent with the application of it's constitution. Of course 'private property' is a construct - but that construct is fundamental, Constitutional. It's like voting. If you take away people's property, your making some very deep transgression of the societal compact, and it's wrong. There are cases where we need to make change - like lowering or increasing the voting age, we have to be careful with that.
- Frondo 6y agoIt's also a very serious thing to use the resources of society to protect people's private accumulations. If people get to use the force of law to keep their stuff from being stolen, they do have an obligation to pony up for the shared costs of that law enforcement.