3 ms·
Not really in an ecosystem where there's some hundred startup opportunities in addition to the big established players. The mathematics on that are far more com
by shadowgovt 6y ago
Not really in an ecosystem where there's some hundred startup opportunities in addition to the big established players. The mathematics on that are far more complicated than "big company doesn't pay more ----> everyone's wages are lower."
Besides, I have a hard time worrying about if my wages were lower than they "should" be when they're already more money than I'd see in any other field. Apple, Google, Pixar, et. al. employees are extremely well-compensated.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> Besides, I have a hard time worrying about if my wages were lower than they "should" be when they're already more money than I'd see in any other field. Ah. So yes, CS majors don't understand marginal thinking.
- shadowgovt 6y agoOr they're not as monetariliy greedy. There's multiple forms of value.
- whimsicalism 6y agoSo you've retreated from "actually there was no harm" to "maybe CS majors don't care if they are paid substantially less than they could be due to collusion in the labor market." I'm not going to continue responding.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIt really depends on how you define "harm" and who is harmed. Classifying "not paid as much as some theoretical model claims a person should be paid" as "harm" without examining the theoretical model in detail is naive. For example, let's assume we care about improving people's lives. It's probably a short walk to assume that more independent software companies (both big players and smaller startups) satisfy that goal better than only a few players, or one player. A collusion-free labor market encourages players at the top to spend on labor until they bleed. Eventually, if nothing checks that cycle, they bleed out competing for a small pool of top talent, with the winner being the one with the deepest pockets who can afford to bleed longest. Then, the winner gobbles up the talent and resources of the bankrupting companies, and there are fewer players in the market (and the remaining players get to dictate labor prices on the grounds of being the only players). Ironically, a soft salary cap can benefit the ecosystem in the long-term; employees aren't paid as much as they could be, hypothetically, short-term, but there's more job security because a price spiral is unlikely to disrupt their employer. And there's a more diverse set of independent companies in operation, likely leading to a more diverse set of software solutions and more improvement in people's lives than if salary spirals meant that only big players could afford to play. It's one scenario among many possible, but it's interesting to observe how maybe not paying software engineers much as they could be in a completely laissez-faire market creates long-term benefits for the engineers, their employers, and consumers.
- srtjstjsj 6y ago> salary spirals meant that only big players could afford to play. The collision was between big players, who were already outbidding smaller players except Facebook with had absolutely massive funding. Smaller players weren't helped by this. (Pixar was smallish but in context it's best seen as part of Apple/Jobs) > laissez-faire market Calling anti-collision regulation "laissez-faire market" is strange.
- ryandrake 6y agoAre you assuming all of these companies are going after the same top talent? There are plenty of average and above average talent who they can hire and not "bleed". You don't need to hire a team of Ken Thompsons to build a CRUD service. If companies would stick to hiring the developers they can afford given the needs of whatever project they are hiring for, there would be no (or less drastic) upward spiral of labor cost.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIn the case of Apple / Google / Pixar / etc., yes. They are definitely trying to grab every Ken Thompson they can. For Google in particular, I believe it is part of their hiring goals.
- hnracer 6y agoIt's undoubtedly true that these companies' actions suppress wages at the margin. The first order effect is some level of harm to the impacted employees. I can understand the argument you put forward about second order effects but I don't agree with it, underpriced labor will lead to overconsumption compared to what is optimal. I'd also like to note that the soft cap is the outcome of laissez-faire policy, it's regulations and law that is attempting to remove it.
- hnracer 6y agoThis talks to a society wide problem, basic logical thinking tools (thinking at the margin, elementary statistics, etc) aren't taught in school and most of the population are ignorant of them. They're not the most difficult concepts to grasp but high school students are busy memorizing facts instead, and these thinking tools are only taught in very specific university courses that not everyone will take.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThere's an interesting book on how learning these tools changes one's political philosophy. https://www.amazon.com/Myth-Rational-Voter-Democracies-Policies/dp/0691138737 https://www.amazon.com/Myth-Rational-Voter-Democracies-Polic...
- triceratops 6y ago> I have a hard time worrying about if my wages were lower than they "should" be when they're already more money than I'd see in any other field. Never get complacent. Always demand more. Give it away if you don't need it, but get what you're worth.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThat's one philosophy but not one I subscribe to. I target win-win.
- newen 6y agoYou won’t be hired and you won’t work for a company in the first place if it wasn’t a win-win agreement between the employer and employee. What working for lower wages than you’re worth contributes to is a win-lose situation between employers in your field and employees in your field where the employees lose. It will become a problem for you not now, but in the future when you are looking for a different job or when you want a raise (even if you’re satisfied now with your salary, inflation can catch up with you quickly, for example).
- triceratops 6y agoWin-win is a fine philosophy when negotiating person-to-person. Not so much when it's person-to-organization.
- specialist 6y agoHow do you feel about profiting sharing?
- shadowgovt 6y agoIt doesn't seem like a bad idea.