5 ms·
> They ultimately controlled where those people worked [citation needed]. I was a "victim" of that scandal, but if I ever decided to change employers I knew wh
by shadowgovt 6y ago
> They ultimately controlled where those people worked
[citation needed]. I was a "victim" of that scandal, but if I ever decided to change employers I knew where the door was and I knew my résumé would get me considered at the other players. The agreement was mostly to keep their phone bank of recruiters from polling me continuously and the managers like four levels above me from playing pachinko with the pay and benefits packages (to the detriment of the folks at my level).
Regardless, the agreement was illegal and existing law broke it up without breaking up any of the companies. I don't see how the existence of that scandal supports the hypothesis that larger corporate breakups are either needed or beneficial.
Microsoft of today is an OS company, browser company, videogame development company, and cloud computing company, and they seem to be doing pretty well overall at it; happy users, good products, decent inter-operation.
- seg_lol 6y agoThere is a lot to unpack here, but I think it needs to be addressed since your comment is getting so much exposure. >> They ultimately controlled where those people worked This is entire point of the anti-solicitation agreement. I don't need to cite anything. Read the transcripts from Jobs and tell me again how it was to protect you from recruiters. How did you get sufficient protection after they lost the suit? The point is showing the behavior of large companies that wield too much power and control large portions of the market, either from the customer's standpoint or the employees. They stopped their behavior only after being sued by the employees, who gained very little, the lawyers won and the GAFS ultimately profited from this endeavor. Microsoft today is immaterial to the MS that should have been replanted in the 90s. Does not follow. BTW it is hard to respond when your post is continually ninja-edited.
- shadowgovt 6y ago> Microsoft today is immaterial to the MS that should have been replanted in the 90s. Does not follow. Microsoft of today follows from the MS that wasn't replaced in the '90s. Of course it's material.
- seg_lol 6y agoFollows it in time only. MS today is not because of the stagnated Microsoft, but in spite of it. Nadella saved MS. You are committing fallacies of conflating cause and effect and surviorship bias.
- shadowgovt 6y agoYou claim MS "should have been replanted" in the '90s, but that claim makes the assumption that the end-result would be better than what we have now, does it not? I don't think that's a safe assumption.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> The agreement was mostly to keep their phone bank of recruiters from polling me continuously and the managers like four levels above me from playing pachinko with the pay and benefits packages Do CS majors not understand marginal thinking? High-level people in business certainly do. Yes, each of those things might not sound that bad - who cares if the recruiters don't poll me if I "know the door." The problem is that phone polling does have a real impact on people switching jobs and it does depress wages if businesses agree to not do it.
- shadowgovt 6y agoNot really in an ecosystem where there's some hundred startup opportunities in addition to the big established players. The mathematics on that are far more complicated than "big company doesn't pay more ----> everyone's wages are lower." Besides, I have a hard time worrying about if my wages were lower than they "should" be when they're already more money than I'd see in any other field. Apple, Google, Pixar, et. al. employees are extremely well-compensated.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> Besides, I have a hard time worrying about if my wages were lower than they "should" be when they're already more money than I'd see in any other field. Ah. So yes, CS majors don't understand marginal thinking.
- shadowgovt 6y agoOr they're not as monetariliy greedy. There's multiple forms of value.
- whimsicalism 6y agoSo you've retreated from "actually there was no harm" to "maybe CS majors don't care if they are paid substantially less than they could be due to collusion in the labor market." I'm not going to continue responding.
- mistrial9 6y agodo you know Fred Huxham? What you say about "mostly recruiters" is literally false
- shadowgovt 6y agoI'm afraid I don't. All attempts to learn more are telling me about track & field, which is not what I assume you're referring to.
- dmos62 6y ago> decent inter-operation We don't want interoperation only between Microsoft products, but between all products. Customer lock-in is an anticompetitive act. That's a big deal, and breaking up companies would be very advantageous to the consumer in that regard.
- shadowgovt 6y agoWould it? Because in general, when I look at the software ecosystem (in the open-source community and the closed-source cross-company community), I see a minefield of impedance mismatches and a programmer's lifetime of writing shim code. The one-company ecosystems are incentivized to make their software work with its siblings. I've never seen any such strong incentive in other environments. I'd expect open-source to succeed at it, except instead it's a compatibility nightmare because people are interested in their own apps and not in making them talk to each other.
- dmos62 6y agoA textbook example is interop in email vs interop in instant messengers. Email was standardized, while instant messengers are left to the whims of individual companies. Normal interop isn't a hard problem, unless there's complicating circumstances (but then you have bigger problems), it's just that companies are incentivized to restrict it for their benefit.