4 ms·
I think Linus forgets that at one point he too was inexperienced and liable to make these hit-and-hope fixes. I agree with his point in general, but the dickish
by smcl 16y ago
I think Linus forgets that at one point he too was inexperienced and liable to make these hit-and-hope fixes. I agree with his point in general, but the dickish manner in which it's delivered isn't particularly helpful ("Why don't we write code that just works?")
- qq66 16y agoThe thing is, if you're inexperienced and mistake-prone, work on a pet project to gain experience (like the Linux kernel in 1992, or your flavor of location-based mobile social coupon sharing app today). Don't start pushing magic numbers into a software product that millions of people depend on.
- smcl 16y agoYep, that'd be an excellent way to word it. As I said I don't disagree with the point, I just dislike how Linus addresses people sometimes.
- alextingle 16y agoWhy so sensitive? Seriously, when someone criticises your work, do you listen to what they say or do you just listen to their tone of voice? If all you do is listen to the tone, then YOUR WORK WILL SUFFER. Because if someone comes up to you and says, "you dick! What the fuck were you thinking putting that double dereference there?? There's no way it could ever work!" If you stop listening after, "you dick! What the fuck were you thinking..." then you will miss out on learning something that you should know. The person is angry BECAUSE you have been stupid. Yes, that sucks, and perhaps they should learn to control their temper. But you can't do that for them. What you CAN do is be less stupid next time!
- smcl 16y agoI listen to what they say. I just lose respect for the person if they act like a bit of an idiot while delivering it. This is not helpful if the person is meant to be in a supervisory\managerial role.
- smcl 16y agoConfusing downvote, I honestly can't see what could be disagreeable or controversial about this comment (particularly given it's inflammatory parent comment) but never mind!
- alextingle 16y agoYou got an upvote from me. But, you seriously think my comment is inflammatory? You don't think that learning to deal with people is an essential part of the job??
- to3m 16y agoWell, I always listen to the tone of voice. This gives me a good indication of whether they're worth listening to or not. Usually, people speaking with a scornful tone of voice (or the written equivalent) are more venting than they are providing useful information. There's no need to pay too much attention to whatever they have to say, because if it's a big deal they'll say it again once they've calmed down. I've noticed that when programming computers there are very few problems that can be fixed by behaving like a dick. And those that can be fixed by behaving like a dick, can also be fixed whilst behaving in a more gentlemanly fashion. The rest can be left unsolved, politely. There's really no reason not to do this.