8 ms·
Two-sided market and multi-sided platform create situations where old antitrust paradigms break down and regulators must step in hard. It seems still be uphill
by nabla9 6y ago
Two-sided market and multi-sided platform create situations where old antitrust paradigms break down and regulators must step in hard.
It seems still be uphill battle to explain this to the public, because at least social media comment sections are filled with 'what it is to me' anecdotal thinking in personal level that is "Not even wrong".
- tomrod 6y agoMeh, it's straightforward. Platform should not compete on their platform. The incentives to muck around is too high. There is not a reasonable economies of scope argument here, in practice this self dealing tends to have lower quality products.
- jstepka 6y agoRight, so Target, grocery stores, hardware stores, and everyone else, can't sell their own value products too then right? Seems like those shelves are platforms to me. I'm fine with 'big tech' not being able to sell products/services on their platform, but i want the same standard for other businesses as well.
- naringas 6y agoa store (even a multi-location physical retailer) is not the same thing as a digital platform the crucial difference is due to the digial aspect. digital "material" does not have physical contraints. this simple fact changes everything.
- andreilys 6y agoSure they aren't the same thing, but doesn't mean you can't manipulate the physical layout among other variables in order to push your own products at the expense of your competitors. You also have access to sales trends for competitors, giving you a leg-up in market research (i.e. Target decides to enter Chips market because they see Lays data). I mean it's not that dissimilar to what Amazon does, it's just done in the physical world.
- gamblor956 6y agoIt's not the same as what Amazon does, not even close. Target owns the products on its shelves so it can do with them what it wants, even give them away for free. Importantly, the product manufacturers are not its competitors because they aren't in the retail business; they are in the wholesale business of making and selling to retailers. Amazon does not own the products in its marketplace. The sellers in the marketplace do not sell their products to Amazon. They are all sellers, like Amazon, and that is why Amazon's practices are an antitrust issue.
- ben_w 6y agoPotentially — loss-leaders, company towns with company stores, and state-run businesses all come to mind — but at the moment I don’t know of any examples of physical stores having this problem even across a single capitalist nation. First-party apps made a lot of sense in the early days, and still do for brand-new features, but I think it would have been better if Apple had promoted existing AR tape measures rather than preinstalling their own; ditto time monitoring.
- dantheman 6y agoYeah, I mean why have nice built in stuff - far better to go and buy everything separately. For instance cars should have seats, stereos, gps, etc... it'd be better for you to go to 3rd party sellers and buy them.
- ben_w 6y agoI think the analogy in this case would be a car company which gives you a choice of three different types of seat, five different types of stereo, and the option of built-in GPS from whoever when you configure your new car in the first place. I’m not even against first-party apps, I just want them to be competing fairly instead of being mandatory pre-installs (with the exception of security-critical parts like the OS, the phone and SMS apps, the wallet apps, the App Stores themselves; but even then, there is room for them to be opened securely, it is just harder to do right, and should probably be replaceable later rather than during setup).
- qppo 6y ago> at the moment I don’t know of any examples of physical stores having this problem even across a single capitalist nation. Retailers bully wholesalers and manufacturers all the time when they represent a significant amount of total sales. You always hear stories of "this was great until the bean counters told us we needed to shave 25c off the production costs and that killed its longevity." What you don't hear is that the bean counters were told by the sales managers that the retailer wouldn't list the product at $X because they didn't think their customers would pay more than $Y, and $Y would make the project unprofitable. And the retailer does 50% of our sales in the US, so we can't tell them to screw off! One solution to all these problems is to enshrine direct-to-consumer sales in law, for digital and physical goods.
- gamblor956 6y agoNot the same thing. Retailers are the customers of the product manufacturers. They pay for all of the products that show up on their shelves, even the store brands. (Note: only trial products operate on a consignment arrangement where the manufacturer only gets paid for units actually sold on.)
- treis 6y ago>Not the same thing. Retailers are the customers of the product manufacturers. They pay for all of the products that show up on their shelves, even the store brands That's not really true. They force manufacturers to accept returns of unsold product and have met 30-90 day payment terms. The effect is that these large retailers don't buy the product until after it's sold. They also just rent shelf space to companies and have little if anything to do with what is stocked there and how it's priced.
- gamblor956 6y agoThey force manufacturers to accept returns of unsold product and have met 30-90 day payment terms. The effect is that these large retailers don't buy the product until after it's sold. This is false. Net payment terms don't change who holds title to the product, just when the money changes hands. Additionally, retailers only force manufacturers to accept returns of unsold product for products that overwhelming failed to sell. They don't return small batches of unsold product. They also just rent shelf space to companies and have little if anything to do with what is stocked there and how it's priced. True, but this is such a small portion of the retail market that it would be a rounding error of a rounding error. Generally, most retail companies don't do this.
- treis 6y agoHolding title and nitpicking return policy doesn't change the core of my point. Retailers haven't paid for the products on their shelves. Holding title doesn't change that nor does having a minimum return size.
- nabla9 6y ago> Platform should not compete on their platform. This is just one issue. Not even one of the the major ones.
- DenisM 6y agoDo tell?
- basch 6y agoThere's no way it's that simple. It's the equivalent of telling Wal-Mart, Costco, and Target they cant sell Great Value, Kirkland, and Good & Gather. Does that mean if Ikea mostly sells their own brand, they cant also sell some third party products. Is this rule only going to apply in the digital realm, to non physical goods? Does that mean that game publishers can no longer own game studios? Are game engines a platform, or only virtual stores? Can GameStop no longer make an inhouse game? Making a "simple" rule like that, would cascade much further than you lead on.
- DenisM 6y agoActually I like all the rules you proposed, except that smaller players should be exempt. Not what you in mind probably, but here we are.
- basch 6y agoIf thats the way to fix problems (I'm not convinced necessarily) thats fine. It's just not simple.
- cblconfederate 6y agoYou do have some good ideas there I do find it kind of strange that Walmart has such a big monopoly in the US, but i can only assume that they are viewed positively by most people or else they 'd have faced antimonopoly action. Same with their brand products, I m sure some other brands will have complained about unfair competition , but maybe their anticompetitive behavior hasn't been egregious enough to bring the ire of politicians. Tech OTOH has been quite aggressively monopolistic in certain areas, and needlessly so, with things like the App Store(apple has way too much profit to justify keeping the app tax so high). In a way ... they make themselves look overly greedy and bring it upon themselves.
- gamblor956 6y agoNote: while Walmart has potential antitrust concerns, it's due to how they impose pricing demands on suppliers, and possibly for their online marketplace. The fact that they sell store brands in their retail locations is immaterial, as that has been a part of retail since before third party brands existed. See, e.g., the Sears case, in which it was Sears' ability to fix prices due to its market dominance that concerned antitrust regulators. They didn't care that Sears sold store brands alongside competing products.
- spideymans 6y agoI'd be cautious about this. Unless the regulations are carefully crafted, this might lead to a situation where platform owners decide to completely vertically integrate software on their platform, rather than allow third party vendors to play in their walled garden. Look at gaming platforms and their respective stores, for example. If Microsoft isn't allowed to compete with third party publishers on their platform, they might very well say, "screw it, Xbox doesn't run third party games anymore, it only runs Microsoft games". Then you're in a situation where the Xbox is nothing but a vessel for Microsoft software. To a certain extent, we've already seen the gaming industry move slightly in this direction, with Microsoft and Sony buying an ever expanding list of gaming studios. It's wouldn't exactly be a huge leap for them to restrict their respective consoles to running games coming from their in-house studios. Heck, the console manufacturers might actually prefer this model, as they get to keep 100% of game sales revenue, rather than 30% (or whatever it is).
- silexia 6y agoThe firm's who are treating their customers best are the FAANG companies. I know a lot of folks here nitpick the things they do wrong, but why aren't you more concerned about the far greater wrongs of tobacco, oil, pharmaceutical companies? About patent trolls? I know FAANG companies are easy to beat up on, but going after these is just bullying. Go after the actual evil companies.
- sk5t 6y agoDon't you think this comment represents tremendous whataboutism? Don't cure one tractable problem--which may yet develop into a greater, less tractable problem--because there exist other troubles?
- thisiscorrect 6y agoThe parent comment asks why we can't we prioritize handling the companies which the author perceives are a greater evil. Why can't that prioritization happen without it being "whataboutism"?
- sk5t 6y agoDo you imagine the same governmental bodies and regulators work on all of trade and antitrust, public health (tobacco), and energy and environmental policy? In other words, does it really follow that the problem of oil is being ignored in order to address monopolists?
- paxys 6y ago> The firm's who are treating their customers best What customers? They offer you a good service, sure, but what relationship do you really have with Facebook or Google?
- thisiscorrect 6y agoWhat relationship do I have with Verizon, or Comcast, or Pfizer or Du Pont? It seems to be one where they sell call metadata logs and consistently under deliver on contracts (Verizon, Comcast, other telcos), dump chemicals, push doctors to prescribe medicines unnecessarily, etc. etc.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]