13 ms·
> air of vague menace and treachery (a) Considering their track record of wanting to monopolize and control markets, I wouldn't put it past them. (b) Many sto
by dheera 6y ago
> air of vague menace and treachery
(a) Considering their track record of wanting to monopolize and control markets, I wouldn't put it past them.
(b) Many stores do put out announcements if they remove products for ideological reasons.
- echelon 6y ago(Of course you got downvoted...) How can Apple be, 1. An operating system and business software company 2. A cell phone company 3. An exclusive marketplace for apps 4. A movie studio and streaming service 5. A music studio and streaming service 6. A hardware company whose products predominantly work with and favor other Apple branded hardware 7. ... How can Google, Amazon, and Apple all do this? Pretty soon they're going to be providing us insurance, doing our dentistry work, and selling us caskets and cremation services. These monopolies are sucking the air out of so many industries. And they honestly do a lackluster job at the random spaces they enter - they just happen to have the money and weight to push out the smaller players and not have to worry about actually competing. I don't want America to have three Samsungs. It's not healthy. I don't want the arts to be dominated by advertising, grocery, and luxury computing/accessory brand companies.
- Spivak 6y agoI mean the answer to all of these and more is having lots of cash needing investment vehicles that do better than just passively investing it in the market. None of these companies are menacingly laughing in board rooms, they’re just seeing other companies prove markets for them and betting that they can compete. If you want to get that first party integration/advantage these companies are happy to partner with you, but you have to have a product that can’t be replicated with 5 devs, a PM, and a Domino’s gift card. And don’t expect to charge a premium, if you try to ask for any more than a sliver above cost the numbers work out in favor of building it in-house.
- echelon 6y agoSo you're saying Sonos'/Bose's efforts are trivial? Audio is a solved problem for five people and a pizza? What isn't? I mean, Apple is building a Hollywood studio. That's insane. I get the feeling nothing is safe. If Apple wants to do it, they'll do it. Same for Amazon.
- epicureanideal 6y agoMaybe this is a good thing? Companies that have developed the ability to do things well enter new industries and raise the bar. Also it weakens them in their core industries if they take their eye off the ball, giving more opportunities in their core industry.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThose are the spoils of developing a product that has transformed many, many aspects of basically everyone's lives and cut out many, many middlemen. It's also a characteristic of software, with its near zero marginal costs allowing a small number of people to obviate and dominate entire fields.
- unishark 6y agoI'm not sure I follow your point. Of course technologies mature and opportunities dry up. The people that do technology (e.g. us here?) need to move on for greener pastures. Audio had a lot of problems to solve as digital signal processing rolled out... 20 years ago. Now, it seems very hard to come up with a product that can make good margins. An alternative would be a field like computer security, where people throw money at you do to stuff you learned as an undergrad in college. Seems like this is the same calculation everyone needs to make when planning or evaluating startup ideas. I'm always curious to hear about the current unsolved technology areas are (other than poorly-defined concepts "data science" and "A.I", that is).
- Spivak 6y agoYou’re putting words in my mouth. I just made a general statement about what it takes to get a partnership with a med-large tech company where there are strong cultural biases toward build over buy. I have no idea if Sonos’ products are trivial or not. If they’re just off-the-shelf-ish audio equipment and good software then maybe. Bose definitely not because their R&D work is legendary. Hence why Apple bought them. The movie studio thing isn’t as doom as you’re thinking. It’s just Apple writing checks and getting put their name on stuff. This isn’t Apple disrupting Hollywood or anything, they just need exclusive content for Apple TV+.
- ksec 6y agoI actually have no problem with them being a 1-3, I just dont understand why they had to do 4 and 5. Music was understandable given there are no Streaming Music alternative other than Spotify. ( But Apple Music still sucks after so many years, and barely caught on to Spotify ). But Making Apple Originals? Pouring Billions into it? And Apple Card? Yes I think Banking and Finance will be there soon. If they have some sort of Apple Cash will minimal cash balance that doesn't require as much regulation as a bank, they will start with a potential 1 Billion customers. And then you have insurance, investment options....
- sjwright 6y agoApple Music is mostly a holdover from the decade of the iPod and iTunes Music Store. They already had a strong market position and it would have been capitalist suicide to abandon it wholesale. I don't agree that it sucks compared to Spotify, but it does cater to a different audience, preferring curation over algorithms. Apple TV+ is indeed a curious one. Personally I think it's as simple as being a placeholder to allow Apple to make strategic choices in future, if they ever choose to compete aggressively with Netflix, Amazon etc. I think the real weird one is finance. While Apple Pay is obvious, Apple Card is not. Banking is desperate for technological upheaval but many fintech start-ups are already doing a good job of this—at least in some countries like the UK.
- rangoon626 6y agoI’m not trying to be an annoying nitpick, you bring up good points and I have just a few observations... Apple Music curation. Has anyone been impressed by this? I found maybe 2-3 songs I didn’t already know about, over the course of at least a year. I was never impressed, even SiriusXM has more variety and relevancy. I think they blew the chance to really do something great. AppleTV+ makes me feel fatigued. Yes to being a “curious one.” Apple Card seems to me like Apple’s version of a co-branded airline card. As much as I like to dunk on Apple these days (I used to be a huge fan), Apple Card is something they executed really well on. I’d like to give props to the Apple Pay/Card team. I think they’re doing a great job here and have a solid foundation for wherever they take this. That said I have a hard time imagining using Apple for all my transactions and balances, especially with the callous way they seem to behave lately. But you never know.
- thetechimist 6y agoOh please. Name three suitcase companies. Quick. Samsonite, American something... (traveler??), and.... a bunch of bit players that don’t have their own stores, commercialized branding with billboards and full-page ads, etc. The word monopoly means one. Mono = One. All this crying and hubris about Apple being a monopoly. It’s Apple, Android/Google, Microsoft, and some heavy hitting wanna-be companys. Want your Windows Phone back? Go get it. Caterpillar makes amazing Android phones. Blackberry is pumping out some nice keyboard based phones. There are privacy-based phones with manual off switches. There are Linux phones. There are many bit players. I have the new Nokia 3310 too. Lots of but players and a few big ones. Why everyone keeps meaning about “monopoly” is disturbing. Half the time, it mostly sounds like a cesspool of burnt out developers just jealous they didn’t come up with some of this modern stuff first. There is no monopoly. Not even close. Even when the Windows Phone was a major player, not enough people wanted it to warrant Microsoft to continue selling it. What do you want? Government forced third options and funded by taxpayers? Did Microsoft have the right to discontinue it — or not? It’s not Apple and Google’s fault that consumers mostly chose to avoid the Windows Phone. I personally think it was a smart decision by Microsoft to get out of that market back then (and they should have done it sooner) and focus more on Azure, Office 365, and Windows O/S - along with GitHub and VSC, etc., all of which they’ve been firing on all 8 cylinders lately.
- actuator 6y agoYou nailed it so well in this comment, I have been pointing out this from when they launched Apple Music. The classic excuse which people hide behind is "but they don't have a monopoly". Sure, they don't have a monopoly in precise terms. But the power they have to push products in new verticals is just unfair to the competition as they can't compete on equal terms. Jabra's parent company in total earns less than 10% of what Apple earns selling just Airpods. It would be really sad if we lose iconic companies like Bose to these "want to own everything" tech giants. Sidenote: This downvoting pattern on critical comments on any threads related to Apple has been absurd for quite some time. Somehow we have entered into a territory where say a company like FB always is upto no good for most here but the opposite is true for Apple.
- hindsightbias 6y agoInteresting. I haven’t used greasemonkey in years, but was considering looking at it to filter out Apple threads. One week it’s all valiant Epic and fervent downvoting of those questioning the viability of the lawsuit, to a next week everyone agreeing with the judges surly review of the case. Looking at the top Apple threads for the last month, it hardly looks like HN is some positivity echo chamber: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=pastMonth&page=0&prefix=false&query=apple&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=pastMonth&page=0&prefix=fa... Bose used to be a gorilla in IP and was happy to sue Beats as soon as Apple announced they were buying it. Highly probable any settlement may have included carrying their products for some period of time.
- actuator 6y ago> Bose used to be a gorilla in IP and was happy to sue Beats as soon as Apple announced they were buying it Maybe they saw the writing on the wall and chose that path to fight on. > Highly probable any settlement may have included carrying their products for some period of time. Apple would have sold Bose products just for the retail cut they can get. They are considered premium and for a lot of categories Apple didn't have competitors till now, so it was better to just sell products like Bose for the retail cut.
- 6y ago
- babesh 6y agoApple is applying the suite strategy to the consumer device/services market. Each new market results in a new product integrated into its suite. Individual products don’t have to be best in class since part of the value is in the integration, part of the advantage is in distribution, etc...
- dr_dshiv 6y agoHey, don't worry, big companies will be way easier to nationalize. Then we will have an apple store on every block!