11 ms·
> I don't want autopilot so I can actually sleep at the wheel, I want it in case I do. You should never get behind the wheel if there's a chance you'll fall as
by echelon 6y ago
> I don't want autopilot so I can actually sleep at the wheel, I want it in case I do.
You should never get behind the wheel if there's a chance you'll fall asleep! You shouldn't be driving. Period. This is incredibly dangerous and puts innocent people at risk.
No technology should compensate for this. We don't design technology to help drivers under the influence feel better about their driving.
Please don't get behind the wheel if you're drowsy.
- agentdrtran 6y agoYou know people are going to do it, though, so it's good to have checks on it.
- echelon 6y agoI disagree wholeheartedly. This technology empowers people to make stupid decisions and rationalize them. We never had people deliberately sleeping in cars (with pillows!) before autopilot was a thing. If the kinds of people prone to make these types of decisions come to trust technology to save them, we're going to wind up in a worse spot than before the technology existed. People will rely on the tech to save them when it was never meant for that.
- randallsquared 6y ago> This technology empowers people to make stupid decisions and rationalize them. Not just "this" technology -- technology in general. There are always risk adjustments; airbags and seat belts had similar riskier-driving effects.
- 14 6y agoI have the unfortunate ability to be wide awake when I leave and then suddenly be tired. I often have to stop on even 1-2 hour drives. But I recognize when I am tired and am know for just pulling over to nap even if I have passengers. Sleep driving is like drunk driving.
- danudey 6y agoThis sort of technology would be great, even if the data never leaves the user's account, is never farmed by Tesla, and is never used by the autopilot. Imagine if the parent poster falls asleep at the wheel and does injure or kill someone. They could point to the fact that it's never happened before, but if the court can subpoena Tesla to get data that indicates this guy dozes off with some regularity (and can see indications that he knew about it), then he's going to face a harsher sentence, possibly even bumping it up from involuntary manslaughter to second degree murder if they can argue that it was extremely reckless disregard.
- foepys 6y agoThe court will very likely not have to subpoena anything. Tesla has a history of publicly putting all blame on the driver when Autopilot once again kills a person by driving them into a divider or a stationary truck. They will go out of their way to show and twist the driver's harvested data to their advantage.
- kraigspear 6y agoUnless AP doesn't allow the driver to control the vehicle it is the drivers fault.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mikepurvis 6y agoAs a daily cyclist who has experienced many close calls over the years at the hands of inattentive, impatient, or unaware drivers, I would love to believe that this world is coming. But unless insurance companies can actually go to work on predicting how accident-prone a person is based on this kind of data, and raising premiums accordingly, I don't know if it will make much difference in terms of actually changing behaviour. Like, there should already be a lot of this kind of data out there to nail drivers to the wall post-crash, and you just don't really see it happening. Even when someone is killed, everyone involved basically shrugs, says it was a fluke, and tells the family they should get over it and move on (watch for the phrase "came out of nowhere" as a sign that everyone involved has checked out of a particular case). And how much will consumers accept a car that tattles on them about their bad behaviour? People already lose their minds over provably-effective external automated enforcement measures which rely on plate reading like red light cams and average speed cams.
- ZitchDog 6y agoWe are human, there is always a chance of falling asleep.
- adamsea 6y agoNot if we are well-rested in general and healthy, and choose not to drive when we are tired. If we have a particular medical condition / issue then that is a different story. But folks don't randomly fall asleep (I think?) if they're getting sufficient rest and they're not already tired.
- laumars 6y agoNot defending the GP but there are plenty of occasions where it’s unavoidable for some people to drive tired. Like families with young children and where adults don’t have the luxury of working from home nor good public transport links. Are they supposed to book a day off every time their child doesn’t sleep? But there are also measures one can take to mitigate tiredness while driving: winding the window down or turning the AC down, putting energising music on, stopping mid-journey and taking a break, etc. There are also medical conditions one can have where they can fall asleep even when not tired. However I believe you’re denied a licence if you do suffer from any of them so this might well be a moot point.
- frosted-flakes 6y ago> turning the AC down Wouldn't you want to turn it up? You're less likely to fall asleep if you're cold.
- laumars 6y agoYeah, I mean temperature rather than electronically. Though in the climate I’m from both would generally lead to the same drop in cabin temperature.
- fastball 6y agoDemonstrably untrue. Monotony can make you drowsy, regardless of how healthy you are or how much sleep you've had. And when this happens, it can catch you unawares even if you're looking for it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- missosoup 6y ago> Please don't get behind the wheel if you're drowsy. I know two people with the issue that GP is talking about, and it's not what you're talking about. They're perfectly alert when they get behind the wheel. They get drowsy on longer drives like 1hr+, which is why any time we do road trips I drive for them. And all that 'pull over and take a power nap' bullshit doesn't work. It's not grounded in any science to start with. I know both have tried coffee, breaks, stopping and taking a walk, etc. Of all those things, they said taking a nap is actually the worst because when they wake up they feel even more tired. So their choices are: have someone else drive them, don't drive beyond a 1hr distance range, or deal with the drowsiness. You can imagine how sometimes life just forces them into #3 even though both are keenly aware of their issue and do their best to mitigate it. Tech to detect when they phase out and save their life is absolutely the correct way to go.
- joosters 6y agoIf it's dangerous for you to drive, don't drive. It's as simple as that. If you can't stay alert enough for more than an hour, don't drive for more than an hour. If people think that #3 is acceptable, they should never be allowed to drive a car, for everyone else's protection.
- missosoup 6y agoThat's not how real life works. It's dangerous for everyone to drive and in the future manual driving will be as legal as riding horses on highways is today. People do potentially deadly risk reward calculus all the time. And of all potentially deadly things that people regularly do to crack down on, this one would have a pretty huge negative ROI for society. This issue impacts a non-trivial percentage of the population. You can't tell them all to change jobs or move their houses to be within whatever travel time limit. This purist notion of 'they should never be allowed to drive a car, for everyone else's protection' crumbles at the most trivial examination when you consider that you're talking about leaving millions of people jobless or in significantly worse quality of life conditions, while also completely reshuffling the housing markets and zoning. And even then, sometimes events will come up that force them to take that chance regardless, such as family emergencies. Rather than this purist isolated-logic bullshit that would probably crash the economy if seriously enforced because you have absolutely failed to consider the first and second order effects of what you're suggesting, we actually have a viable tech solution instead. I'm going to guess that most people who share this viewpoint are either high income earners living in a bubble who don't know what real life is like for most of the population, or are logical purists looking at this issue in isolation and not accounting for what life is like for most of the population. Life for most of the population is working paycheck to paycheck at whatever job you can get in order to make ends meet and keep your kids fed, and living in whatever housing you can get that doesn't make it impossible to get enough sleep to physically keep living due to long commute times. Being prevented from driving would absolutely destroy most affected families. You're going to do a lot more damage to society by preventing all those affected from driving than by doing nothing and letting it contribute to a small percentage of the road toll, which in itself is an insignificant percentage of the total death toll. Which is why every country on the planet has done nothing more drastic than awareness campaigns, despite being aware of this issue. Really, this is where this entire discussion becomes moot. Fatigue and microsleep as a cause of road fatalities are a well studied issue that every developed nation is aware of and has done the calculus on. And not a single one of them decided to ban those affected from driving, because the calculus of that policy results in a massive net COST, not gain. And that calculus shifts even further now that we have fairly cheap car technology available to mitigate the issue. When you think through all this, the only conclusion is 'ban affected people from driving' is moronic and does significantly more harm than good. tl;dr: you'll save more lives by replacing a single coal power plant with renewable energy than by implementing your policy. And you won't destroy the lives of millions of people and potentially crash the economy in the process. And there's already a viable solution on market that mitigates it almost entirely anyway. Pick your battles.
- kryogen1c 6y ago> You shouldn't be driving. Period. what a stunningly pretentious and ignorant thing to say. reasons to be tired and drive: rotating shiftwork, working multiple jobs, caring for a newborn, caring for the sick. that covers millions of people, off the top of my head, without doing any research. and those are only the most black-and-white examples. more ambiguous cases include: driving from physical activity like OP mentioned, long drives to visit friends/family, events like weddings. if you want to make the argument that sleepy driving is more dangerous than we give it credit for, then we can talk - but thats not what you said. "You should never get behind the wheel if there's a chance you'll fall asleep!" is an absurd thing to say.
- wobblyasp 6y ago> "You should never get behind the wheel if there's a chance you'll fall asleep!" is an absurd thing to say. No it isn't? We expect drivers to be able to react to situations that can arise when your driving a ton of metal and plastic. 24 hours w/o sleep is equivalent to having a BAC ~0.1%; well above the legal limit. Sure; most people aren't staying up 24 hours and going for a cross-country road trip, but you need to be aware of what affect is has on your ability to operate (https://www.cdc.gov/sleep/about_sleep/drowsy_driving.html https://www.cdc.gov/sleep/about_sleep/drowsy_driving.html)
- andrei_says_ 6y agoIt is a sensible request but an absurd demand. Unless we first institute livable wages with sane working hours and paid commute time along with free childcare. So that survival does not demand that people abuse their bodies with lack of sleep. agreeing that externalities like house work, parenting, commuting exist, have cost, and need to be considered in a viable economy could be a great step. Doughnut economics is one such approach. https://www.ted.com/talks/kate_raworth_a_healthy_economy_should_be_designed_to_thrive_not_grow?language=en https://www.ted.com/talks/kate_raworth_a_healthy_economy_sho...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- root_axis 6y agoSome people don't have that privilege. Ever known someone that works two jobs trying to make ends meet? You don't have a choice except to drive home from work.
- wow_yes 6y agoTake the bus
- t-writescode 6y agoSome people don’t have that privilege either.
- spike021 6y agoI would argue that a car is totally a privilege that is above that of finding other means of transportation. I couldn't even afford one until I graduated college and was working full-time. Before then I walked if I had to, sometimes over a mile depending on the destination, or took public transportation.
- quicklyfrozen 6y agoLiving somewhere where you don't need a car is the privilege, at least in the US. I'd have to walk 2 miles to get to public transit, and that includes crossing a pedestrian unfriendly major road.
- root_axis 6y agoNot a realistic option for daily life in the U.S. and often not even possible if you work late hours. Ride sharing is way too expensive to use every day.
- konschubert 6y agoYou can try to emigrate to a richer country, you can try to reduce your expenses, you move in with relatives, you can sleep in the car. These are all terrible choices but endangering other people is also a choice.
- foobarian 6y agoOne time I was driving between cities at 2am for unavoidable reasons, and was drowsy. At one point my brain interpreted the shifting red taillights in front of me as a game of Tetris. That's when I knew it was too dangerous to continue so I pulled over (rest stop was close by) and took a 15 minute nap. I found that powernaps like this are really effective at energizing me past browning out and letting me finish the drive safely. Measures like opening windows in the middle of winter, playing loud music, pinching, etc. stop working eventually and a nap really is the only way out.
- sangnoir 6y agoYou need discipline to avoid inattentive driving more than advanced technology. You know roughly when you will get tired from driving: plan around that. Technology won't save you from poor judgement. I do agree, power-naps are amazing to help you regain focus. One time I was driving and it was almost dawn, and I was desperately trying to force myself to reach the next town so I could get a room. I realized I probably wouldn't even make it that far and pulled over at the next rest stop and slept for 30 minutes. I woke up feeling more well-rested than I had any right to be. When you start having micro-sleep episodes (your attention/memory has inexplicable gaps), or start experiencing sensory hallucinations, it's well past the time for you to rest.
- Ntrails 6y agoResting eyes for long blinks is my main memory of drives I shoulda died on. Mostly around 4am on deserted country roads I knew well. Good news is I would only have killed myself. But honestly there is a reason young people have more car accidents, they make bad fucking choices. I was nothing but lucky!
- reaperducer 6y agoPlease don't get behind the wheel if you're drowsy. You're shouting at a wall. People think "drowsy" isn't a problem, the same way they think that texting and driving isn't a problem because they saw someone jump backwards in slow motion in The Matrix. Drowsy driving is no better than buzzed driving, which legally is drunk driving.
- znpy 6y agoYeah i wanted to write pretty much the same. If you know you can't drive in a safe manner, you shouldn't drive at all.
- xyzzy_plugh 6y agoThis is such a bad take. If a system can help prevent accidents due to drowsiness, it's a net positive. There are plenty of reasons to be drowsy and still have to show up to work/commute: Maybe you have a newborn at home, and... Got a bad sleep. Or were woken up by a fire alarm. Or maybe you're just drowsy in the mornings, like me! I used to have a real easy 35 minute drive to work, on a single, straight road with a few sets of lights. I probably nodded off a bit while driving at least once a month, if not more. Especially at a set of lights. I'm not a morning person!
- echelon 6y agoWhile this technology can help prevent some percentage of accidents under the existing regime, it will likely lead to some population of drivers putting more faith in the technology and becoming more reckless. It's hard to say if there will be more or fewer accidents as this becomes prevalent. I'm wary of it by default given the already prevalent incidence of DUI and sleepy driving. Those individuals seem likely to use this as an excuse or crutch. I'd be happy to be surprised.
- fastball 6y agoWell humans can't get any better than they are now, and they're quite dangeous. Computers are always getting better. My money is on the computers.
- epistasis 6y agoUnfortunately, if the poster lives in the US, there's a really high chance that laws have prevented suitable non-car transportation from being available. There's a few places where one can live daily life without cars: a subset of really huge cities, some downtown areas of mid size cities. But usually we highly restrict housing from existing in such places, and we strict zoning prevents mixing of residential and commercial in areas that did not have it before these restrictions became prevalent in the last century.
- irrational 6y ago> You should never get behind the wheel if there's a chance you'll fall asleep! So, I should never drive? Not OP, but I experience the same thing. Driving just makes me tired. I've tried running A/C at full cold, caffeine, loud music, audiobooks, etc. Nothing helps. The strange thing is, outside of driving I don't get tired or want to fall asleep except at bedtime. I don't drive when I'm drowsy. Driving make me drowsy. The bad thing about it is I usually don't realize that I'm getting sleepy until after I've dozed off once. Then I've got to keep myself awake long enough to get to the next rest stop. 20 minute nap and I'm good to go for another few hours.
- zingermc 6y ago> So, I should never drive? > The bad thing about it is I usually don't realize that I'm getting sleepy until after I've dozed off once. I'm not trying to be rude, but this sounds reckless. You absolutely should not be driving while you have this issue. Also, consider that you may have a sleep disorder.
- buzzerbetrayed 6y ago> So, I should never drive? As other people have said.. yes, you should never drive until you get this issue taken care of.
- matthewmacleod 6y agoNo, you should never drive. I appreciate that this sucks if you live in an environment that requires you to drive, but you are way too blasé about something that runs a decent risk of killing someone, and is absolutely not normal.
- fastball 6y agoDriving in general comes with a decent risk of killing someone. You probably shouldn't do it either.
- vikramkr 6y agono but the comment that this comment is replying to is not a normal case of a drowsy driver - it is definitely not normal to not know you are drowsy until you already fall asleep, and that is wildly dangerous
- trhway 6y ago>No technology should compensate for this. not surprisingly that the "holier-than-thou" purists' arguments in this thread sound the same as the typical conservative argument against contraception - "by decreasing the weight of consequences it will encourage vice behaviour", and not surprisingly that these style arguments just outright fail in real life.
- newacct583 6y ago> You should never get behind the wheel if there's a chance you'll fall asleep! I don't know about the upthread commenter or how common a thing it is for him/her. But this isn't feasible advice. It is never possible to drive perfectly safely, it's just not. Everyone makes mistakes in cars, and preventing them needs to be a defense in depth treatment and not an impossible prohibition like this. Saying "people sometimes drive tired" (goodness knows I have) leads to "maybe a driver-facing camera might save lives". Saying "You should never drive tired!" is just a recipe for blaming the driver and fixing nothing.
- dafoex 6y agoWhile I on the whole agree, there are some cases where its unavoidable. You could be coming home late from work, and you can't power nap in the car park there as the lock the gates, so you need to drive to a location where its safe to park and nap. Its admittedly an edge case, but its not unlikely by any stretch of the imagination.