4 ms·
What good are rights when corporations can just have users sign them away by agreeing with some policy? They already make users waive a lot of rights, including
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
What good are rights when corporations can just have users sign them away by agreeing with some policy? They already make users waive a lot of rights, including the right to pursue legal action, the right to reverse engineer...
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoRegulate as utilities/infrastructure. Nobody likes the Ma Bell type of anti-trust because it feels like infringing on private property rights but regulating as utility or infrastructure is much widely accepted and palatable. However if you have poor management then you end up in the P&G situation with blame passing from one generation of management to another and no real improvements.
- dredmorbius 6y agoP&G or PG&E?
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoPG&E, typo.
- Silhouette 6y agoThat form of broken legal system is, as far as I know, peculiar to the USA. In most of the world, businesses aren't allowed to arbitrarily negate laws specifically created to protect their customers just by including some weasel words in the fine print. In fact, here in the UK and at least across much of Europe, businesses are required to actively inform their customers of various rights and other details, and failing to do so can have significant consequences.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoThe problem is most big technology companies seem to be located in the USA. Foreign laws are meaningless to them.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agothis would explain why the big technology companies are always upset when they get fined by the EU and then pay the fine.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoUSA system isn't broken that way. Unconscionable contracts are void. One famous example is CA's anti-non-compete law that created Silicon Valley. USA also has mandated rights notifications. There are specific absences of laws in certain particular cases.
- MagnumOpus 6y ago> corporations can just have users sign them away by agreeing with some policy These shrink wrap licences can be legislated away. Lots of EU countries have consumer protection legislation that explicitly forbids/invalidates such imbalanced or unexpected terms in the fine print for consumer-facing contracts -- or indeed invalidates shrink-wrap licence terms outright.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoMy country does the same thing but it's meaningless since companies are usually located in the USA.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoAmazon is in USA but subject to EU jurisdiction when selling to EU residents.
- jerf 6y agoAs is often the case, a lot of these things are either illegal in the US too, or far less settled than the companies would have you believe. The companies stick them in the license clauses anyhow, because when you can just stick a severability clause [1] in there, why not grab things willy-nilly? Plus a lot of people simply assume there's no recourse even when there in fact is ("the US is an anarchist wonderland where consumers have no protections at all" is a harmful and false meme, what we have is the widespread assumption that consumers have no protections), and of those who don't, who really wants to spend a ton of time in any sort of legal or arbitration resolution over 40 books, which almost certainly total far less than any possible legal or arbitration battle will cost? The legal system, US, EU, or otherwise, doesn't have a good answer to when a company bones .01% of several million people to the tune of several hundred dollars, or bones its entire customer base for $1 or something. By the time you bust through their contract clauses against class action and even find everyone affected you've long since eaten up any value you're going to get from the lawsuit even if you win big and win punitive damages. Computers make it so much easier to do this kind of thing on the company's side, but they don't help anyone trying to fight it anywhere near as much. Very asymmetrical advantage for the companies to hit people like this at some scale. [1]: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/severability.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/severability.asp
- dredmorbius 6y agoThere are limits to contracts, including nontermimable or notransactable rights.