4 ms·
What is the point to run RAID6 on 4 drives, instead of RAID10? With both, half the space is usable, but with RAID10 read speed is twice as high, and resilvering
by nine_k 6y ago
What is the point to run RAID6 on 4 drives, instead of RAID10? With both, half the space is usable, but with RAID10 read speed is twice as high, and resilvering is twice as fast.
RAID6 makes sense for 5-8 drives.
- oarsinsync 6y ago> What is the point to run RAID6 on 4 drives, instead of RAID10? With RAID10, if the 'wrong' two disks fail, the array will go offline. With RAID6, any two disks can fail and the array will still be online. EDIT: The author has also demonstrated that they've gone through various growth permutations over the years. 4 disk RAID6 under md-raid has a supported growth mechanism, allowing you to add additional disks and have it restripe data automagically for you. It's not a good idea as far as performance is concerned, but for a home use nas that is primarily intended for streaming media, it's not a major issue, and enables you to grow to your heart's content (even if it is a bad idea, as I successfully proved growing from 4 disks to 16 over a few years, before respinning as multiple 6-disk arrays)
- electricant 6y agoActually, according to recent testing by ArsTechinca [0] performance with RAID the topic is more complicated. The testing is focused on ZFS but, quoting from the conclusion: If you're looking for raw, unbridled performance it's hard to argue against a properly-tuned pool of ZFS mirrors. RAID10 is the fastest per-disk conventional RAID topology in all metrics, and ZFS mirrors beat it resoundingly—sometimes by an order of magnitude—in every category tested, with the sole exception of 4KiB uncached reads. [0] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2020/05/zfs-versus-raid-eight-ironwolf-disks-two-filesystems-one-winner/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2020/05/zfs-versus-raid-eigh...
- oarsinsync 6y ago> it's hard to argue against a properly-tuned pool of ZFS mirrors ... ZFS mirrors beat it resoundingly Emphasis on 'properly-tuned'. This doesn't hold as true as the OP states for the defaults (which is what the majority of home users will be using)
- barrkel 6y agoA pool of mirrored pairs is effectively the ZFS equivalent of RAID10. https://www.klennet.com/notes/2019-08-04-zfs-vs-RAID10.aspx https://www.klennet.com/notes/2019-08-04-zfs-vs-RAID10.aspx