3 ms·
Perhaps, but for Tesla to go to being what Amazon is now would take so much luck/decision-making I just can't see it happening. They make nice cars, but they wo
by mhh__ 6y ago
Perhaps, but for Tesla to go to being what Amazon is now would take so much luck/decision-making I just can't see it happening. They make nice cars, but they would have to dominate the market in a way they can't even dream of today.
For example, Tesla sold 300k cars last year - ford alone sold something like 6 million. Tesla have to compete with the entire world's car industry including companies that have much more experience selling cars at that scale. Is it impossible, no, is it unlikely yes - Tesla will grow from now but I just can't see that P/E turning into cold hard cash.
Also, Amazon's P/E peaked at 3.6k but only for 2012. It's been around a tenth of Tesla's current P/E for almost all of their time on the exchange.
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AMZN/amazon/pe-ratio https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AMZN/amazon/pe-rat...
- Retric 6y agoI haven’t dug deeply into their financials, but directly comparing them to other car companies is misleading as they are far more vertically integrated. An EV charging network, direct sales, and building significantly more parts in house means they can extract more money even if they sold an identical product to the rest of the market. I doubt the solar business or grid batteries are particularly profitable, but it’s the same Apple vs Samsung song and dance. Outsourcing everything means you’re sharing profits with your suppliers and have little leverage over your competitors. That’s not to say they can or will do all of that profitability. Tesla’s self driving tech could fall behind rendering a massive investment worthless. But, the numbers aren’t so high it’s impossible for them to be a great investment just IMO unlikely.
- dd36 6y agoTesla is much more than a car company. It’s an energy company that also sells cars.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoWhat does that have to do with subsidies?
- cure 6y ago> For example, Tesla sold 300k cars last year - ford alone sold something like 6 million. Tesla have to compete with the entire world's car industry including companies that have much more experience selling cars at that scale. Is it impossible, no, is it unlikely yes - Tesla will grow from now but I just can't see that P/E turning into cold hard cash. Tesla sold 367,500 vehicles last year, Ford sold about 5,387,000. In other words, Ford sold almost 15 times as many cars as Tesla in 2019, which is a significant difference in scale. Fast forward to Q3 this year. Ford sold 551,796 vehicles (sales down significantly due to the pandemic). Tesla sold 139,300 (sales up significantly despite the pandemic). They are now just a factor of four apart. And that's just vehicles; Tesla is really an energy company, don't forget. The battery and solar parts of their business are just getting started. The P/E is extreme, but given how well Tesla is executing, and how steep their growth trajectory is, perhaps it's not so crazy after all...