7 ms·
Viruses depend on the existence of complex structures (the machinery in cells) to replicate themselves, so I don't think it's valid to point to one as an organi
by pfdietz 6y ago
Viruses depend on the existence of complex structures (the machinery in cells) to replicate themselves, so I don't think it's valid to point to one as an organism in the same sense as a prokaryote.
- pishpash 6y agoProkaryotes depend on the existence of complex structures (the world outside) to replicate themselves. Yours is not a good example. That aside, people have argued that the viral particle is like a gamete, which is also an incomplete stage of life unable to replicate itself. It would be like calling a sperm a human and saying humans are therefore parasitic and not living. A virus's primary life stage is lived within the environment of the cell which it commandeers, and from where it sends its progeny. The whole commandeered cell is the viral organism, and very much living.
- pfdietz 6y agoInvalid argument. Bacteria exist that can grow in very simple media with low structure. Viruses canmot. They absolutely depend on the existence of a very complex replication machinery.