5 ms·
> Instead of just writing papers for our "real" target audience (the community), we go all-in with "defensive writing" and we start iper-optimizing every single
by crazygringo 6y ago
> Instead of just writing papers for our "real" target audience (the community), we go all-in with "defensive writing" and we start iper-optimizing every single sentence to make sure it can't possibly be misunderstood even by the dumbest reader. Papers can't just be "clear" for a benign reader: they need to be bulletproof against capricious people who are ready to reject things for random reasons.
Considering how many papers I read that still are easily misunderstood even by smart readers... I think "defensive writing" is better understood as "good writing".
Of course papers are expected to be "bulletproof." It's called a standard of excellence. Peer review is supposed to be meaningful, not a rubber stamp. But the sneaky secret is, the bar isn't even that high. I read so many papers where I wonder why an obvious alternative interpretation isn't even mentioned, or an opposing viewpoint isn't cited, or where the author subtly misrepresents another author.
("Capricious people" are a separate subject, but they certainly exist just as much in industry as in academia...)
The rest of the post aside, this particular bit of the "rant" just feels like a defense of lazy writing. An academic paper isn't just a blog post, and it shouldn't be.
- redelbee 6y agoI took this to be more about writing for the express purpose of being accepted (or not rejected) instead of a defense of lazy writing. When the outcome of the work can only be “accept” or “reject” it incentivizes writing from a defensive perspective rather than one that is more speculative or questioning.
- saagarjha 6y ago> Of course papers are expected to be "bulletproof." It's called a standard of excellence. And sometimes it's just having to add verbiage in anticipation of a lazy or uninformed reviewer, who is not necessarily the audience that you actually care about. The net result is that there is a lot of work and fluff that interested readers often have to put up with that exists solely to get the paper through review and serves little other purpose. > The rest of the post aside, this particular bit of the "rant" just feels like a defense of lazy writing. An academic paper isn't just a blog post, and it shouldn't be. If your point here is that blog posts are "lazy writing", then I assure you I have read many blog posts that are much more thorough, well-researched, and worked-over than academic papers. I do agree with you that the two are separate things, but blog posts have a number of desirable qualities that academic papers have difficulty optimizing for–either because they are not prioritized, or because they would actively hurt the chances of acceptance.
- crazygringo 6y ago> who is not necessarily the audience that you actually care about But see, that hits the nail on the head. There's a reason papers are full of long intros, backrounds, and even mini-literature surveys. Because the audience isn't just other tenured professors in the same subfield. It's the rest of the field, it's grad students, it's undergrads, it's researchers in other fields it might be valuable for. It's also for people trying to figure out even which subfield the author is approaching it from, to contextualize the paper -- is this political science paper being written by a structuralist or a culturalist, even when they never explicitly say so, but it makes all the difference for judging it? It's easy but short-sighted to assume you're writing solely for your peers. Thankfully, the "verbiage" and "fluff" you disdain is deeply appreciated by many, many other readers. To reiterate: there are very good reasons for these standards. What's fluff to you, is extremely valuable to many others.
- saagarjha 6y agoI’m not actually really in academia, so when I say these papers have fluff I mean they actually have fluff, not content useful to professors or students or casual readers or whatever. These are things added specifically to get through review and only make the paper worse.
- crazygringo 6y agoI guess we read different papers. The ones I read are mainly in psychology, sociology, political science, and political philosophy. And in having read well over 1,000 papers (just by counting in Zotero), I can't ever recall reading part of a paper and thinking "this is fluff" or "this must have been added specifically to get through review". Not once. Maybe it's a problem in other fields, or in very specific journals? I honestly don't even know what fluff looks like, which is why I'm so confused by this whole thread.
- newen 6y agoIt sounds like repeating "state-of-the-art", "novel", never before seen, revolutionary new research that will change the entire world, you wouldn't believe how my method beats other baseline methods by huge margins, and you wouldn't believe how this paper will revolutionize the entire field, etc, etc, multiple times in the paper so the bored reviewers don't reject your paper. I'm exaggerating but it's close to the truth. You kind of have to turn your paper in an advertisement of your work to get past the reviewers.
- yhoneycomb 6y ago> Considering how many papers I read that still are easily misunderstood even by smart readers... I think "defensive writing" is better understood as "good writing". I agree 100%. One thing I HATE HATE HATE is when research articles use unnecessary synonyms. Ie, plasma membrane in one sentence and then phospholipid membrane in another and then cell membrane in another. For someone just trying to get a grasp on a topic, it is REALLY fucking confusing. And even if you're an expert on the topic, it's still annoying. Just pick one and stick with it. OR uses stupidly complex words just to appear smart. Ie, ameliorates, a term I've ONLY ever seen in biology research articles and yet is a completely unscientific/unnecessary word. This isn't your creative writing class. Just fucking say that you found that your drug decreases lipid synthesis, NOT that it ameliorates it you big dunce. ALSO one more thing that annoys me - when people only use a term 3 or 4 times in a paper, but still INSIST on using the acronym. Ok, I get it - if it's something WAY more commonly referred to by its acronym like DNA or COPD, it's acceptable and probably preferable. But if it's central pontine myelinolysis, just fucking type it out instead of writing CPM so I don't have to waste mental energy trying to decipher what it means. If anything, scientific writing should be dumbed down more. PS. While I'm on my biomed-academia soapbox, I'd like to point out that the correct pronunciation of constitutive is just as it's written - similar to constitution. It's TUTIVE not TUITIVE.
- alextheparrot 6y ago> This isn't your creative writing class I think it is less this and more just code-usage to facilitate showing that they're part of the in-group. If I use the appropriate words ("Elucidate", "Ameliorate", "in situ"), I'm showing that I have learned the subject from a similar heritage. Partially an aside, but an interesting talk on academic writing, which I've enjoyed [0]. [0] https://youtu.be/vtIzMaLkCaM https://youtu.be/vtIzMaLkCaM
- yhoneycomb 6y agoBut in situ actually MEANS something. Elucidate is unnecessary but not terrible - at least it's used in everyday writing. If I had my druthers, I would ask for a less cumbersome word to be used. Still, I think most reasonably educated people would know what it means without missing a beat. Words like ameliorate are just wrong. Just absolutely wrong.
- 1337biz 6y agoBecause peer-reviewed ist often also friend-reviewed. If you attend conferences you know most of the time who is pushing which topic and in your field. And seen the draft version at the conference.
- toomim 6y agoYou are missing the point, by quoting out-of-context from the section with this big header: We optimize papers for the referee, not for the (intended) audience. The author's issue is not with defensive writing. It's with writing to defend against the wrong audience. Perhaps you haven't been in academia, and haven't experienced it yourself, but the author's problem is very real. Your intended audience will understand a point, and want you to go further. But the referees are often not the intended audience. Imagine trying to explain the value of a new type of N95 mask to an anti-masker. You'll be spending your time writing defensively to try to argue for the most basic aspects of wearing a mask, when you would really just like to go into details on what's cool about the new type of mask, for people who actually care about better masks.
- awild 6y agoI have a very recent example for this, we are a very research based shop and have recently submitted a paper about part of our open source software. One of two reviewers literally answered with 10 points, where every single one is a variation on it not being a study.
- abnercoimbre 6y agoThe reviewer is saying your paper isn't a "proper" study? I'm wondering about the nature of your shop. You said it's heavy on research, but it also doesn't sound like you're in academia.
- awild 6y agoNo this isn't a study at all is the joke. We are developing/offer a database for health insurance (specifically the German Market) data, for non technical people to analyse the effectiveness of certain treatments etc. Or create certain cohorts for studies. The paper was an overview/introduction to It. while I'm proud to have written it, it's basically marketing/legitimation for our field. Another division of our company does actual data science, research and publication on these topics. We're in a weird middle ground as our ownership is all health insurances which makes us technically public service, but our work environment is far more tech oriented (and 20 years young on average).
- generationP 6y agoI think the specifics of "defensive writing" depend strongly on the subject. In the author's subject (infosec), you probably need to defend against the "it won't work" and "the assumptions are unrealistic" schools of criticism, so you end up being overprecise and including unnecessary complexity just to preempt the critiques. In other subjects (the mathy side of TCS), you mostly need to defend against the "it's probably well-known" and "what is this good for?" attacks, so you end up providing lots of context that confuses more than it elucidates and speculating about possible applications you don't believe in yourself. I myself am a bit skeptical of how far this "defensive writing" is to be blamed for the unreadability of papers, and even if it's such a bad thing at all when done in measure. In maths, reading papers is about swearing and asking the author just as much as it is about actually reading; yet the reasons for the unreadability are often more natural than "we need to get this past the referees" (all else being equal, referees still reward readability). New ideas rarely are born easy to explain. Ugly ducklings need their time to grow. You can wait for 10 years hoping that by then your own work has taken the proper shape to explain to undergrads, or you can write it up half-baked in half a year and let others play with it. What is better for science? The answer is far from obvious, particularly because releasing your ideas into the wild will often get them properly explained faster than trying to do it yourself.
- Isinlor 6y agoThere is also problem of "defensive writing" as in writing that is not supposed to be understood. Math is very often used in this way - math is impressive, math gives vibe of rigor and formalism, math requires a lot of effort from reviewer to dispute, but is very often bullshit meant to sell a simple idea (sometimes even wrong idea) as a big contribution that is just simply hard to understand for uneducated. Nobody want to look uneducated, so it's unlikely you will be criticized.