3 ms·
I think a lot of it is perhaps fundamental attribution error, which is ridiculously common in people. I actually tend toward the idea that people that manufact
by sneak 6y ago
I think a lot of it is perhaps fundamental attribution error, which is ridiculously common in people.
I actually tend toward the idea that people that manufacture and sell potentially harmful, but inanimate things are in no way responsible for their final use (or misuse). They're not forcing anyone to take these drugs, nor is the prescriber, nor is the pharmacist, nor is the truck driver who drove it to the corner store.
That said, I also recognize that while the person who put the opiates into a human body is the ultimately 100% responsible party for any harm caused by those opiates, the fact remains that many people would choose such self-harm in various circumstances (such as massively addictive drugs being prescribed by their doctor), and that we must consider the effects of circumstances on people and their decisionmaking.
Treating people as sheep that are entirely dependent upon their circumstances to determine whether or not they make good (in your and my view) choices is the wrong move, however.
Ultimately though, it's simply not the fault of the manufacturer or vendor if adults misuse their products.
There seems to be a lot of support for ending the drug war in the United States. (I'm one of those people.) If that happens, opiate addiction seems to become much more likely, as opiates will be cheaper, safer, and more plentiful/available. I guess I'm just not sure where the outrage at this manufacturer comes from, given the disaster that the drug war's been. What they're doing is (mostly) legal, and the parts that they're trying to hang criminal charges on shouldn't be crimes.
- Klinky 6y agoYou certainly should be liable if your product is highly dangerous and addictive, and you've purposefully created an environment that incentivizes over proscribing of your dangerous addictive product. If you actively encourage the misuse, you are the problem. You could make similar arguments against Wells Fargo account fraud or Boeing 737 MAX. Both involve executives creating environments that resulted in abuse or "misuse" by employees or customers. Did these policies cause harm? Were there safeguards in place to reduce abuse/misuse, or were those ignored because they would have stopped the gravy train?
- ves 6y ago> I actually tend toward the idea that people that manufacture and sell potentially harmful, but inanimate things are in no way responsible for their final use (or misuse). They're not forcing anyone to take these drugs, nor is the prescriber, nor is the pharmacist, nor is the truck driver who drove it to the corner store. This might be admissible in the case of the sacklers if all they did was create the drug and make it available, but they did much more than that: they marketed opiates heavily, they aggressively downplayed the negative affects, and they incentivized doctors to prescribe (which of course apportions some of the blame to the doctors as well). And even the prescribing doctors share in the blame through their deliberate actions: first, when a doctor prescribes opiates, they’re not prescribing some other treatment, but you (the patient) still have the issue, so you can’t really not take the opiates, ie forego treatment, especially since you’re also out the money and using up your insurance (if you even have that!); second, not behaving in line with your doctor’s wishes can have its own set of consequences, ranging from ticking your doctor off (which is bad, since you need them to help you with your condition, and finding new doctors takes time and money, and you’re ill all the while) to getting sent to the psychiatrist. So much to say, I think this attitude is incorrect in the case of the Sacklers, as it doesn’t comport with the evidence, and in the general case it’s naive.