2 ms·
I've read several traditional variations of the Rapunzel story, and they don't -- in general -- make much sense. (A pregnant woman will refuse to eat anything e
by beagle3 6y ago
I've read several traditional variations of the Rapunzel story, and they don't -- in general -- make much sense. (A pregnant woman will refuse to eat anything except Salad from lettuce that grows in a witch's garden; sends husband to steal lettuce. Witch catches him, takes newborn instead. Then there's other stuff about the prince that makes no sense).
The Disney version, though quite far, keeps enough main elements to be recognizably related to the original story; and the storyline makes a lot more sense.
I made sure my children are aware that it's disneyfication of the original story, but I don't blame them for not caring much.
The Little Mermaid, by comparison, is much closer to the (sad, dark) original -- with a notable exception of the end being a happy one. In this case, my children do care about the two very different endings, and like both.
- InfiniteRand 6y agoThere’s a Japanese film adaptation of the little mermaid which is very close to the original, except in the original they make the mermaids death a little nicer by having her become basically an angel, but the Japanese version just has her turned into sea foam and that’s the end of that
- beagle3 6y agoOn the other hand, there's Ponyo - The Ghibli+Myazaki version, which has a disney-style happy ending where she just gives up everything magical to become a person.