2 ms·
IMHO the fact that the EU doesn’t have the UK anymore is a very good reason to define it as our main working language. That will of course never happen, but it
by dgellow 6y ago
IMHO the fact that the EU doesn’t have the UK anymore is a very good reason to define it as our main working language. That will of course never happen, but it would make sense to have a language that doesn’t advantage one country member over others given that we all have English as our secondary language.
In fact my personal wish would be the standardization on European English, at the same level as UK English, US English, Indian English, etc. and define it as our common EU language, bound to the pan-EU identity.
But I’m dreaming :)
- chrisseaton 6y ago> European English Doesn't European English as a separate dialect have a lot of problems? The English that Europe uses is so mangled that English speakers can't understand it. It often means the exact opposite of what is intended, sometimes dangerously so (see 'so-called' for example.) This leads to less understanding, rather than more. https://www.eca.europa.eu/Other%20publications/EN_TERMINOLOGY_PUBLICATION/EN_TERMINOLOGY_PUBLICATION.pdf https://www.eca.europa.eu/Other%20publications/EN_TERMINOLOG...
- dgellow 6y agoI see it as a different flavour of English. Every single flavour of English has its own distinction and incompatibility with the others, that's what defines it as its own thing. A US or UK English speaker will face issues when talking with a Indian English speaker, or an Australian English speaker. In practice we already use EU English, both in official documents and communications, and in casual exchanges. We just don't recognize it officially. The document you share is using UK English as the standard to follow, which explain why there are some differences. > This leads to less understanding, rather than more. That leads to a common language WITHIN the EU, which is what we don't have currently. I mean, again, we do have European English, we just don't recognize it, and it isn't as spread as it could be. The differences with other forms of English are small enough to increase the general communication between EU citizens and other English speakers in the world, but as you said also comes with a few differences that can cause misunderstanding. I work in international environments with people from all over the world, we already face those issues and they aren't a big deal.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> I see it as a different flavour of English. I think you're being very generous there in painting it as some kind of naturally occurring dialect of a culture. > The document you share is using UK English as the standard to follow Incorrect. It refers to and compares against Irish English and US English as well, as people would in fact normally understand it. It's not academic or prescriptive. > In practice we already use EU English, both in official documents and communications, and in casual exchanges. You can't convince me people are using contorted jargon like 'financial envelope' in casual exchanges with anyone. These are the problems in practice: > the European institutions also need to communicate with the outside world and our documents need to be translated – both tasks that are not facilitated by the use of terminology that is unknown to native speakers and either does not appear in dictionaries or is shown in them with a different meaning It's not just a case of 'not recognising it officially' - nobody understands it and dictionaries (of any dialect) don't help. What is the point of a dialect that only people writing reports, not reading them (the actual people they're governing), understands?
- dgellow 6y agoOk, I see that you completely misunderstood what I'm talking about. I don't really care if the EU standardize a EU English based on translation mistakes present in official EU documents. For example the case you point to, "financial envelope" seems to be a direct translation from French (at least that's how it feels as a native French speaker). Drop it if you want, it's just a detail. I'm talking about the way the language is used by European citizens. An example of some common differences can be found here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euro_English https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euro_English. Some of theme are quite funny if you're familiar with European languages :)
- chrisseaton 6y ago> An example of some common differences can be found here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euro_English https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euro_English. No we mean the same thing. The Wikipedia article you posted even links to the report I posted as a reference for what they mean! That’s an EU report, by the way, criticising EU English as confusing and not understandable by citizens of any country unless they’re EU officials. That’s not a useful shared dialect!
- pmontra 6y agoThe UK will be gone soon but Ireland is still a member.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> That will of course never happen, but it would make sense to have a language that doesn’t advantage one country member over others given that we all have English as our secondary language. Don't forget that English is indeed a secondary language in the Republic of Ireland - their first official language is Irish. So what they said still holds true including the Republic of Ireland.