6 ms·
Strongtowns always starts with their answer and works backward to find questions. Your approach is similar... ie “it must be corruption”. The answer is always
by Spooky23 6y ago
Strongtowns always starts with their answer and works backward to find questions. Your approach is similar... ie “it must be corruption”.
The answer is always the same for local governments. ~70% of expenditure is for operations, and 60% of that is for cops and fire.
- netcan 6y agoThis is the problem of politics in a nutshell. We tend to have strong opinions, as is out democratic duty. It's impossible (or very hard) to form opinions based on specifics. So we fall into tragically cliched thinking. "The problem" is whatever the problem always is. Maybe its Capitalism. Maybe its "kickbacks, overregulation, collusion in bidding, and simple "match the budget" bids" It's probably whatever your worldview always points to.
- bosie 6y ago> We tend to have strong opinions, as is out democratic duty. How is a strong opinion a democratic duty?
- netcan 6y agoI meant that tongue in cheek.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoSilly me. I foolishly thought that careful investigations and analyses of situations like the ones described in TFA could help us figure out what "the problem" actually is.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoAnd that 60% does not include defined benefit pension and retiree healthcare benefits that are understated or unstated because the government can use extra rosy assumptions and/or just skip saving money and then dump those expenses on future taxpayers.
- Spooky23 6y agoUsually it does at the city/county level. The states usually are the only ones with the legislative power to duck payments.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoWhat rules require the use of proper assumptions or funding at the city/county level? There are many large cities with hugely underfunded pension plans.
- Spooky23 6y ago90% of state/local pensions are administered at the state level. Usually state plans mandate contributions to some degree -- in my state (NY) the year after a stock market crash is always a mess for schools and localities because the state requires increased contributions to make up for investment target misses. Even where the state isn't a good or responsible pension administrator, the pension system membership usually takes the obligation off of the city/county balance sheet. States have sovereign immunity, so at the end of the day, the pensioners will take a haircut.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> 90% of state/local pensions are administered at the state level. Source? There is no shortage of articles online describing cities’ budget woes due to underfunded pensions needing increased contributions. Jacksonville, Dallas, San Diego, San Bernardino, Detroit, Los Angeles, Chicago, the list goes on and on. The state government has a pension fund for state employees, cities can have one for city employees, counties can have one for county employees. Illinois actually codifies in its state constitution the fact that the government may NOT alter pension benefits. Here are some links about the obligations of individual cities: https://www.truthinaccounting.org/news/detail/2020-financial-state-of-the-cities https://www.truthinaccounting.org/news/detail/2020-financial... https://www.data-z.org/pension_database/ https://www.data-z.org/pension_database/
- specialist 6y agoCity budgets aren't the only balance sheets. Counties, corporations, charters, port authorities, states. I couldn't guess at all the structures and financing schemes that have been concocted. For instance, Port Authority of NY and NJ builds, owns, and operates a massive amount of infrastructure. Completely apart from NYC. The Port Authority in my own region is its own separate nominally democratic fiefdom with its own powers to raise taxes, fees, etc.