3 ms·
I'll read up on the philosophy. But fundamentally, if not from the brain, then where else would morality originate from? God? But then if you look at every rel
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
I'll read up on the philosophy.
But fundamentally, if not from the brain, then where else would morality originate from? God? But then if you look at every religion that claims it speaks for God, you'll find something in the proposed moral standards you'll disagree with on moral grounds. "Structure of the universe"? That's meaningless unless you point out what aspect of that structure determines morality, and I'm willing to bet it'll turn out that that aspect can be fully captured in the workings of the brain. What else is there to ground on?
As far as I know, all moral questions under all moral philosophies, no matter how convoluted, are ultimately verified by testing the conclusions against examples simple enough that you can get a gut-feeling answer for them. Every criticism of a moral philosophy I've ever seen boils down to finding an example where applying some high-level rule leads to conclusions that cannot be reconciled with the gut.
- claudiawerner 6y agoIt is indeed a problem to justify the source of morality as anywhere other than the subjective perception of the brain. However, I think most people would agree that a rational action or chain of reasoning is rational regardless of the brain, or to what ends. Similarly, most would agree that humans are susceptible to various non-rational behaviours. I'm not here to argue for an objective morality, or the various arguments put forward for moral realism (since I'm not a moral realist myself). Also, the role of intuition in morality (and knowledge in general) is contested. I think that to commit to a system in which we only formalize our intuitions falls victim to three kinds of objection: those who have a reasonable case that we haven't caputered the intuitions correctly, those who doubt the role of intuition in moral decision making (several popular theories, from Kant's to Bentham's result in non-intuitive results in which their proponents will bite the bullet), and those who argue either that moral facts cannot be truthy, or that they can be truthy (but we always get them wrong), or they can be truthy (but we have no way of knowing which are true and which are false).