7 ms·
Why does organic milk last so much longer than regular milk? (2008)
- tus88 6y agoNews to me.
- ender341341 6y agoIs this more common in less urban places? I don't know that I've seen UHT organic milk in the Seattle area and pretty much only see UHT Milk sold for shelf stability without refrigeration or for packing in kids lunches.
- mogadsheu 6y agoMost organic milk is UHT, but not shelf stable since it’s not aseptically packaged. Without aseptic packaging UHT milk lasts for 90-120 days refrigerated.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoEvery Costco I've been to has UHT milk sold in a box with 3 half gallon cartons.
- dandare 6y ago> All "organic" means is that the farm the milk comes from does not use antibiotics to fight infections in cows.. In EU farmers must administer homeopathics to sick "organic" animals instead of antibiotics. https://fullfact.org/europe/eu-homeopathy-and-norwegian-vets/ https://fullfact.org/europe/eu-homeopathy-and-norwegian-vets...
- rzwitserloot 6y agoDid you, um, read the link? It basically shows that this isn't the text or intent of the law.
- dandare 6y agoNot sure if you are just trolling or malevolent on purpose. I did read the article and it literally says that is the intent and text of the law. Quote from the article: > More detailed rules from 2008 list products that should be preferred to medicine and antibiotics "provided that their therapeutic effect is effective". These include homeopathic products, but also various vitamins and compounds of mineral origin. Quote from the law: > Phytotherapeutic and homeopathic products, trace elements and products listed in [...] shall be used in preference to chemically-synthesised allopathic veterinary treatment or antibiotics, provided that their therapeutic effect is effective for the species of animal. Article 24, Section 1: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:02008R0889-20150101&qid=1427277713676&from=EN https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL... Let me borrow a quote from Tim Minchin: "By definition, Alternative Medicine has either not been proved to work, or been proved not to work. Do you know what they call Alternative medicine that's been proved to work? Medicine." So the EU law actually says that ignorant quackery (herbal medicine) and fraudulent for-profit quackery (homeopathy) shall be preferred to any natural or synthetic remedy that has been proved to be effective (allopathic = evidence based medicine).
- PaulRobinson 6y agoThat’s not true.
- dandare 6y agoUnfortunately it is. See my quote from the law above.
- mogadsheu 6y agoEU organic milk comes from cows who are only allowed to be administered antibiotics if they get sick. Those cows are removed from the herd when sick, but are allowed to re-enter the organic herd after they are taken off the antibiotics.
- andylynch 6y agoI'm really surprised this isn't the standard everywhere. In NZ it's quite similar and very strict; if any trace of antibiotic is detected in a batch of milk it is rejected, and the offending farmer must pay for it (easily $1,000s, probably much more). Aside from the resistance issue, one reason for this is quite simple; antibiotics in the milk mean you can't make cheese with it. If a cow needs antibiotics, they are separated from the herd for a few days until they are clear (and also can't be slaughtered for meat for a longer period of time).
- dandare 6y agoUnfortunately the us of antibiotics in farming in EU is still widespread - will be curbed in 2022. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/oct/25/european-parliament-approves-curbs-on-use-of-antibiotics-on-farm-animals https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/oct/25/european-par... But that does not mean the law should promote or enable quackery. See my other comment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ciconia 6y agoFWIW We buy raw non-pasteurized, non-homogenized cow milk from the neighboring farm (the cows are grass fed). We go there once a week with our bottles, get 5-7 liters worth (costs only 1€/l, cheaper than in the grocery store). It keeps without problem for up to 8-9 days. You do need a good fridge though. I could go on and on about the qualities of raw milk, the richness of flavor, the high percentage of cream (~6.5% in the case of our milk), beneficial bacteria and mineral content, but the point is that it keeps well enough for us to be able to buy it once a week.
- bartvk 6y agoAnd you accept the risks of bacteria from raw milk?
- xncl 6y agoFWIW via the wiki article on it there is weak to no evidence of benefits but strong evidence of danger. if taste is the reason go ahead and risk your health I've no problem. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/raw-milk-debate/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/raw-milk-debate/
- xncl 6y agoSorry unsure if I am allowed to edit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raw_milk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raw_milk
- ladberg 6y agoWould you mind explaining the qualities? I don't see how pasteurization or homogenization would change the percentage of cream or mineral content. I've never tasted it so I can't speak to flavor, and you're right about beneficial bacteria but I don't know if that outweighs the chances of harmful bacteria.
- redprince 6y agoIt is all for taste. Heating leads to changes in the proteins and sugars (caramelization / maillard reaction) affecting the taste. The more heat and the longer the time it is applied, the more pronounced this change is. Homogenization has a slight impact on mouth feel and taste, usually described as an improvement.
- taneq 6y agoI've never seen this link between 'organic' and UHT before. I'd have to check but I think any 'organic' milk is just treated the same as normal milk, and there's a separate non-refrigerated section for UHT milk (which keeps for months without refrigeration).
- ladberg 6y agoIn the US I've never seen it in a non-refrigerated section, so I bet they just refrigerate the UHT milk even if it isn't needed to keep it all in one place and not freak people out.
- dexwiz 6y agoMy favorite is that you can find the same almond milk both in both the refrigerated and normal sections of the same store sometimes. Once food safety becomes ritual, it’s hard to shake.
- Xylakant 6y agoI’d consider it’s not about the safety ritual, but rather that both consumers and producers expect the almond milk to be found close to the milk. Consumers because they think of it as milk, and thus it should in the same section. Producers because they want that association.
- indecisive_user 6y agoBut the same is true for soda or tea. Sometimes I just want almond milk to be cold right now. And also, the refrigerated milk section tends to be much easier to find than whatever place the store decides to put non refrigerated milks.
- esperent 6y agoI think that's because they want to place the product in both the health food and dairy sections. I don't think it's from any desire to refrigerate it.
- 6y ago
- akamaka 6y agoThis article is very out-dated. Some organic milk brands nowadays are actually using very low temperature pasteurization, which heats the milk to 63°C for 30 minutes. It’s more expensive but considered to have a much better flavor. https://www.thekitchn.com/what-is-vat-pasteurized-milk-167433 https://www.thekitchn.com/what-is-vat-pasteurized-milk-16743...
- cmarschner 6y agoYep, usually that‘s called ESL (extended shelf life) method which I think has come about only 10-15 years ago. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5704146/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5704146/ Edit: In fact it was developed in 1996 but replaced much of pasteurized milk between 2005 and 2008 in Europe. Maybe it was a little bit later in the US? https://me-trading.de/what-is-esl-milk-a-comprehensive-guide/ https://me-trading.de/what-is-esl-milk-a-comprehensive-guide...
- redprince 6y agoESL is a whole different beast than pasteurization. It comes in two major versions: Microfiltration or a heating akin to UHT but shorter and at a lower temperature (127 °C vs 150 °C). Microfiltration won't change the taste, heating will. Microfiltration may be combined with pasteurization (heating to around 72 °C) to inactivate enzymes which may affect shelf life. Pasteurized milk will keep for 5 to 7 days, while ESL milk can keep for 12 to 21 days in the unopened container.
- akamaka 6y agoI think that’s something different from what I’m describing, since it’s higher temperature than the HTST that’s typical in North America. UHT milk never became very popular in North America, so I’m not to what extent ESL has been introduced. I think it breaks down like this: * Vat-pasteurized (63°C/30min) * HTST (71°C/15sec) * ESL (123°C/5sec) * UHT (135°C/2sec)
- e2e8 6y agoYes, this is the only kind I buy but even better is High Pressure Processing. This pasteurizes the milk with pressure rather than heat preserving all the desirable properties of raw milk without any of the risks. There is a company in Australia (Made By Cow) selling this kind of milk but it does not seem to have spread to other countries yet.
- _ZeD_ 6y agobtw, there are many different method beside pastorization and UHT. beside an "sterilized" milk (obtained with 20 mins at 116-120 °C) and others intermedied heat treatments there is also the microfiltration: the milk pass through a microscopic membrane, that "filter out" the patogenic elements
- hexbinencoded 6y agoI notice milk frozen immediately after purchase and then weeks later thawed doesn't last very long, a few days a most, before it curdles (US Costco organic 1%). We also get organic UHT chocolate milk in small boxes which lasts a few months. UHT organic heavy cream in small boxes last some months as well.
- arketyp 6y agoAs a kid I used to sneak UHT (long-lasting) milk in the shopping cart because the sweeter taste went well with cereals. It always seemed like a magic trick by Nature, along with roasted bread (the Maillard reaction) or simply leaving a pear to become ripe, soft and sweet.
- ivan4th 6y agoI wonder if irradiating by say 10 MeV electron beam could work for raw milk. Perhaps with the right dose, the taste shouldn't be altered significantly, yet the bacteria should be gone
- foxyv 6y agoFood irradiation is a bit expensive compared to ultra pasteurization. I'm not aware of any brands of milk that use it. However it doesn't affect taste or nutrition of food as far as I can tell. It would probably work pretty well, although it would be pretty expensive for something as cheap and safe as milk.
- mandeepj 6y agoI have experienced reverse. Few times when I bought organic milk, it started to smell foul after couple days. Even though the printed expiry date was far away in the future
- anonfunction 6y agoSame with me, especially the Horizon brand.
- anonfunction 6y agoI've noticed UHT milk has an unpleasant smell after a few days.
- foxyv 6y agoOnce you open it you have to start refrigerating immediately or it will curdle. Open air is full of bacteria and people have a cloud of the bugs surrounding them. They come off of skin and your breath and clothes. An opened container will be infected almost instantly.
- _-___________-_ 6y agoSummary: it doesn't. UHT milk does, and some organic milk is UHT.
- qalmakka 6y agoAs a European I grew up on UHT milk, and boy, I didn't like it a bit, but my mom only went shopping once a week, so it was either that or no milk at all. I still find it repulsive and a bit tasteless, the worst offenders being the half skimmed and low fat varieties.
- akamaka 6y agoAs a Canadian, I was amazed to see unrefrigerated milk in boxes on my first trip to Europe. I agree about the taste. That being said, it is easier to get raw milk in Europe, so I envy that.
- quietbritishjim 6y ago> [UHT is used] for most milk sold in Europe. > A lot of Americans find [UHT] offensive ... Europeans, however, don’t seem to mind. Here in the UK, this statement is not true at all. UHT milk is certainly available in the supermarkets (not in the chilled section) but the vast majority of milk sold is fresh. I guess this is the risk of generalising a whole continent of people in such a short statement. (Probably the article's claims about Americans don't generalise to every part of that either.) The most ridiculous thing about this statement is that it is claiming Europeans care less about UHT. Yet it's evident that at least some Americans don't care that much because they needed this article to be written to even notice that some of their milk was UHT. I'm confident that if all organic milk in UK was UHT then its consumers would be furious, without needing it to be pointed out to them. I suspect part of British preference for fresh milk is due to the tradition of milkmen delivering fresh milk every morning, now almost entirely stopped but still in living memory. I'm reminded of a quote from the excellent British/Irish comedy Father Ted, where Father Dougal becomes a milkman: "You better get going, milk gets sour you know. Unless it's UHT milk, but there's no demand for that because it's shite".
- rusk 6y agoMilkman has come back into fashion recently. I’ve a guy delivering milk to my door three days a week now along with some other goodies. Super handy.
- pujjad 6y agoIn Germany, the consumer demand for UHT is low as well. Fresh milk is prefered over that, UHT tastes weird for most. No idea where the article gets the idea from that Europeans care less about UHT.
- silvester23 6y agoI was going to comment basically the exact same thing but tried to do some reasearch first and came across an article [1] claiming that UHT (H-Milch) has a market share of a whopping 70% which does not match my personal experience at all. But it was the only article naming an actual number that I could find within a 5 minute google search. [1] https://www.bwagrar.de/Aktuelles/Kuenftige-H-Milch-soll-mehr-Geschmack-Naehrstoffe-besitzen,QUlEPTY2NDI0OTUmTUlEPTUxNjQ0.html https://www.bwagrar.de/Aktuelles/Kuenftige-H-Milch-soll-mehr...
- arh68 6y agoInteresting! I could swear organic milk in a carton lasts at least twice as long as regular milk in a jug. It does say ultra-pasteurized (the carton), so I guess I've been drinking basically-UHT organic milk along with regular. The organic tastes way better to me, so maybe I don't mind the UHT flavor (or lack thereof). The milk I buy is all refrigerated fwiw, I haven't tried room temperature UHT to compare taste.