3 ms·
People reject info on existence of a prob if they object to possible solutions
- xbryanx 16y agoYale's Six America's study is a great companion read to this article. http://environment.yale.edu/climate/ http://environment.yale.edu/climate/ It demonstrates six different types of attitudes towards Global Warming and helps to explain the social dynamics associated with each opinion with a bit more nuance than the Republican/Democrat divide in the decidedly fascinating polling research in the arstechnica link.
- shawndumas 16y agolink to the report pdf: http://environment.yale.edu/climate/files/Knowledge_Across_Six_Americas.pdf http://environment.yale.edu/climate/files/Knowledge_Across_S...
- stretchwithme 16y agoI think that's true of many people (responding to the headline). Many people also accept existence of a problem more easily if they relish the possible solutions. For example, our currently developing budget disaster. I find it easy to talk about because it finally means some finite end to dumb government spending. But we don't exactly know how far the dumbness could continue or if sanity will kick in soon or if the die is cast. And, on the other side, there are people who love government spending who claim its not a problem at all.
- orangecat 16y agoMany people also accept existence of a problem more easily if they relish the possible solutions. Indeed. Testable prediction: as solar and wind power become more economically viable, harder-core environmentalists will discover many reasons why they're unacceptable.
- kenjackson 16y agoWhy would hardcore environmentalists not like those solutions? If anything I think they'll move to deploying these solutions to more targets.
- cydonian_monk 16y agoYou can test that prediction now. There are rumblings about the damage wind power does to local wildlife, and deeper questions about how large arrays of wind turbines change weather patterns by drawing too much energy / increasing airflow resistance. Some (random, via quick Google search) sources: http://www.livescience.com/7626-wind-farms-change-weather.html http://www.livescience.com/7626-wind-farms-change-weather.ht... http://www.gardenridge.net/wind-turbines-changing-weather.htm http://www.gardenridge.net/wind-turbines-changing-weather.ht...
- kenjackson 16y agoThey note climate change, but to quote: ""The message here is climate change, but that doesn't equal global warming," Keith said. "It's possible this would have benefits," by working against the atmospheric effects of fossil fuel consumption on global climate, he said. "
- iterationx 16y agoI'll bet it would have gained a lot more traction if Al Gore hadn't popularized it. You lose 50% of the country right there.
- hugh3 16y agoI don't think it's really fair to say that Al Gore popularized it. People were certainly widely talking about global warming (though usually under the name "the greenhouse effect") as long ago as I can remember, which is about 1990. Gore didn't hitch onto the bandwagon until sixteen years later. The real reason for the left-right divide is that the most widely proposed solutions always seem to involve more taxes and more government intervention. They are also, in my opinion, not the most effective way to spend that money on CO2 emissions reduction. Ultimately it's a technological problem and demands technological solutions -- we need to find ways to cheaply and efficiently produce the same amount of energy without burning fossil fuels. The solution is therefore throwing more money at R&D, not attempting to coerce people into using less energy. The "cash for clunkers" program, for instance, cost $3 billion. The budget of the National Renewable Energy Laboratory in Golden, Colorado, which is doing some really good work, is about $130 million a year.
- kenjackson 16y agoWhile there is a right-left divide, I think it is actually a different divide than what you suggest, because even R&D solutions propopsed by the left are shunned by the right. The issue that doesn't come up nearly as much, but you'll hear if you talk to hardcore social conservatives is that this planet is for humans to do as we please. And I've been in discussions where they will quote specific bible verses. Their view is that the secular left doesn't believe in God and therefore thinks they need to fix a problem that doesn't exist.
- pstack 16y agoI'm not going to comment on the particular facet of contention here. I do, however, think that there is a severe deficiency in critical thinking skills in modern society. Especially in America. It lends toward making many assumptions and accepting many claims on everything except facts and it encourages leaping to conclusions simply because it's better than an unanswered question. I am not a well-learned student of critical thinking, either. I'm just another public school cretin. I do value knowledge and evidence, however. I despise when people are reaching a conclusion or supporting a claim in a clearly disingenuous way, though. I don't think I ever participate in this, but I'm certainly not immune, I'm sure. The greatest way we could benefit society and advance mankind in a single generation would be to embrace critical thinking and teach the skills to every student and then allow them to draw conclusions to things instead of jumping on one bandwagon or another, based on variables unrelated to facts.
- hugh3 16y agoAlternatively, people are more likely to believe information on the existence of a problem if they like the possible solutions? e.g. "You have a severe dietary deficiency. It can only be resolved by eating more chocolate"
- zem 16y agoFaced with the choice between changing one's mind and proving that there is no need to do so, almost everyone gets busy on the proof. -- John Kenneth Galbraith