6 ms·
US economy works best at extremes. Extreme poverty, extreme wealth. Europe, as a whole, seems to do better with a wider range of middle class. Personally I l
by dijit 6y ago
US economy works best at extremes.
Extreme poverty, extreme wealth.
Europe, as a whole, seems to do better with a wider range of middle class.
Personally I lament that we have very little tech industry. No Google’s or Apples- but at the same time the majority of the people living and working here seem better off than their contemporaries in the US. So it’s mostly selfish of me to lament the lack of tech.
Eventually though I guess, the tremendous wealth generated by US tech industries will enrich everyone’s lives in the USA, but, that hasn’t happened historically. So I guess we’ll see.
- kzrdude 6y agoThe dominance of the big tech companies is a mistake, a failure in market regulation - they are allowed to go too far in terms of company mergers and anti-competitive behavior. Of course, Europe can't "compete" in exactly that without loosening the shackles in the same way, but that's not something I, for one, would want.
- varjag 6y agoI think they refer to technology innovation rather than the size. Because there is really no shortage of European monster sized companies.
- Yetanfou 6y agoThere is plenty of tech innovation which heralds from Europe but comes to fruition after moving to the USA. It is not a lack of ideas or one of entrepreneurial spirit but more one of a lack of VC capital and a more stringent legal framework which keeps Europe from producing "the next Google".
- nix23 6y agoThat is so true! If you have a innovation (especial in the IT field) you run out of Europe as fast as possible.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoI wonder if it's the appetite for tech investment that causes this. In Australia (outside of a small enclave in Sydney) the only thing that investors know about and want to invest in is Mining (or occasionally Agriculture). I can see the same situation in Germany: investors want to invest in what they know, and very few of them know about tech products. There's little pockets of tech-savvy investors around Europe, but on the whole there's not that many. But California has an abundance of investors who know tech and are willing to invest in it. So it's easy to see why a Euro tech company that wants funding would migrate there.
- nix23 6y ago>But California has an abundance of investors who know tech and are willing to invest in it. Yes i think that's it, i can make a bet that more Windows Servers run in Europe than in the US, Europe is in that field (the mindset) at least 6 years behind the US and China, but some exceptions exists like Estonia.
- kzrdude 6y agoWhat is facebook innovating at?
- varjag 6y agoFacebook brought on transformation in information distribution and social discourse propagation that previously went mostly over top-down media channels. I think it turned to be a net negative, but it was a seminal change.
- Fnoord 6y agoFailure of market regulation, indeed. Look at big tech. Microsoft got big with dirty tactics. Facebook and Google get away with scandal after scandal. You can't compete with crooks. Not in US, nor in EU, nor in world.
- Aerroon 6y agoBut Facebook and Google didn't get big because of dirty tactics, did they? They genuinely offered something people wanted.
- nickfromseattle 6y agoFacebook, at least, did dirty stuff on the way up. I'm sure there are many more examples I'm unaware of. Facebook pays teens to download VPN to measure app usage on a users device: https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/29/facebook-project-atlas/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/29/facebook-project-atlas/ Facebook backdoor testing after their VPN was removed from the app store: https://9to5mac.com/2019/01/30/facebook-research/ https://9to5mac.com/2019/01/30/facebook-research/
- tomp 6y ago> Since 2016 Facebook won already in like 2012 or something. What was before that - MySpace? - it just sucked compared to Facebook. Terrible UI. Completely useless, siloed without the "real name" policy. Facebook was a genuine innovation, both in terms of UI, and in terms of marketing (targeting elite schools first was genius, but hardly non-competitive, anyone could have done it).
- Fnoord 6y agoFacebook's real name policy has been determined bogus in Germany (EU).
- mhoad 6y agoI feel like you are fundamentally misunderstanding their entire business model here. The fact that they happened to have popular products is somewhat secondary. They both got to the size that they got by data mining PII and selling it to the highest bidder in various forms.
- jb1991 6y agoWhat are those shackles you think that are preventing it?
- mettamage 6y agoWell, it does help when 320+ million people speak the same language. That's a huge consumer advantage that any US startup has.
- 0xfaded 6y agoTranslating and regionalization is cheap compared to adhering to 28 different sets of laws.
- mettamage 6y agoFair point. With that said, both are expensive for lean startups without outside investment. Many Dutch startups always look at the Dutch market first, before they fan out to a few European countries and only then do they look at Europe. And if that all succeed, only then do they dare to look at the US and perhaps the world. Case in point: takeaway.com
- weejewel 6y agoThis is very true. On the other hand, The Netherlands is a country that easily adopts new tech ideas and products compared to other European countries.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoFWIW, you have to adhere to couple dozen sets of laws as well, on top of translation and regionalization, when building EU-wide products. The EU works to harmonize a lot of these laws, but it's still made of sovereign nation-states.
- matthewmacleod 6y agoSingle market really makes this much less work than you’d expect.
- dgellow 6y agoIt isn't that cheap if you have to consider different branding and marketing campaigns when you want to expand to neighbor regions. The cost of covering the EU market can increase really fast. Edit: it's also an ongoing cost, so the earliest you start to support additional locales the more expensive your general product development becomes. Once start to translate your UI you now have to keep it up-to-date all the time. The more translations you have the more expensive that process is when developing new features, both in actual time/energy to be sure that your UI/UX work well in your supported locales, and expenses for translators.
- hawk_ 6y agoyes europe does work much better for the average person on street. i do wonder though how sustainable it is. for example a lot of the stability is due to pension obligations many european governments have. the current generation doesn't have that. and for every 1€ that goes in people seem to pull out any where from €1.25-2 from those systems. exactly what that will look like in 20 years is anyone's guess but it'sn't looking pretty.
- cpach 6y agoAs we both live in the same country I think this is a very interesting observation you make. One thing that the US is really good at is commercial innovation. Case in point: Silicon Valley. And in addition to that all the innovative companies outside of SV, which are quite a few. It would be amazing if we in Europe could increase our innovation without creating the same economical divide as in the US. And some more European tech companies wouldn’t hurt :)
- romanoderoma 6y agoEven though my job is in tech, tech is hardly the only market that innovates For example banking, finance and insurance is more advanced and innovative in Europe than in US Other fields of innovation where Europe leads are: green economy and energy production, small and medium sized businesses development, education, human resources, pharmaceutical products (mainly drug development, especially smart drugs as they are called) They are not equally capitalized as US tech giants, but that just mean that investment in Europe is more widespread than centralised and many smaller companies receive funding instead of a few very big ones
- latch 6y ago> US economy works best at extremes. I agree with you, but going on a tangent, I question if it really "works best". I'm not an economist nor sociologist, but I know there's some evidence/argument that inequality also hurts the obscenely wealthy. As two examples, inequality is linked to crime and terror and lower rates of innovation (e.g., not having a vaccine for Ebola) - both of which can be blind to someone's AMEX limit. There's also the fact that all people in countries with high inequality are less happy (1), which could be linked with the fact that they are less compassionate (2). (1) https://hbr.org/2016/01/income-inequality-makes-whole-countries-less-happy https://hbr.org/2016/01/income-inequality-makes-whole-countr... (2) https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/why_inequality_is_bad_for_the_one_percent https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/why_inequality...
- mads 6y agoYou say "tech" industry. Surely you mean "advertising" industry.
- agumonkey 6y agoextreme attracts youth, and USA is a young country.. at least it was