4 ms·
I'm confident HN could handle an explanation of that that's evidence-based, or at least presents a self-consistent model, and doesn't just peddle conspiracy the
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
I'm confident HN could handle an explanation of that that's evidence-based, or at least presents a self-consistent model, and doesn't just peddle conspiracy theories.
If you have one, please share (or link to a previous discussion). I'm somewhat open to this view, given that it seems like a reasonable explanation that a good chunk of the influential people have gone through the same few schools, socialize in the same circles, etc. By itself that isn't nefarious per se, but it does limit the distribution of worldviews among the people with power.
- watwut 6y agoIn all seriousness, given that "good chunk of the influential people have gone through the same few schools, socialize in the same circles, etc" how come that "things are rigged and that competitors at higher levels know each other personally because even their kids attend the same schools" is seen as conspiracy theory and "fair meritocracy" interpretation is seen as self evident not requiring any evidence? It is not just top. Pretty much everyone have seen how this or that incapable person comes the ranks or how someone got leadership because he is son of the right person. Right person can be owner, or is not like it would be even illegal. Even the president is someone like that, someone whose achievements are all build on lies and excessive benefit of doubt due to his family of origin. The advisor is guy exactly like that too. But somehow, telling that this is how things work is still conspiracy theory.
- 0df8dkdf 6y agoThat is more nepotism, and it is not necessary bad. People work better with people they know and trust. Nepotism can lead to nefarious amongst a group with people who has a lot of power and money. That is probably what happened in US with Bushes, Clintons and Obamas. At this point, even mainstream pretty much admitted that use is an oligarchy: https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746 https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWhat I wrote does not necessitate nepotism. It doesn't have to be that those already in power actively select for their friends and relatives to join their rank. Just that if most people who become rich and powerful tend to go through a small subset of universities or networks, they all end up having a similar mindset.