3 ms·
No, you are wrong. It is possible that we exist in a simulation, and if we are, that the creator of that simulation could change the code for that simulation w
by lisper 6y ago
No, you are wrong. It is possible that we exist in a simulation, and if we are, that the creator of that simulation could change the code for that simulation whenever they wanted to. There is a lot of evidence that this is not actually happening. This is not an assumption.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> No, you are wrong No, I'm not. > It is possible that we exist in a simulation, and if we are, that the creator of that simulation could change the code for that simulation whenever they wanted to. That's true, though “simulation” and “creator” bear no real weight in that description. > There is a lot of evidence that this is not actually happening No, there's not and there cannot be. Because literally any evidence is equally consistent with that as it is with constant physical laws; more consistent, actually, absent a complete model of the actual physical laws supposedly at work. The very concept of evidence requires assuming that there are constant physical laws governing the production of sense data from something else. Without that, nothing is evidence of anything. Now, there are lots of other assumptions that get marshalled to justify that assumption as a conclusion (my personal favorite being “God exists and he wouldn't allow me to be deceived the way thay that not being true would entail”), but you can't have evidence for it, because you can't have evidence without it.
- lisper 6y ago> No, I'm not. Yes, you are :-) > literally any evidence is equally consistent with that as it is with constant physical laws No, it isn't. The Kolmogorov complexity of the universe turns out to be very small. That is not consistent with an intelligent agent pushing changes to a simulation in real time.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The Kolmogorov complexity of the universe turns out to be very small. That is not consistent with an intelligent agent pushing changes to a simulation in real time. It's absolutely consistent if the intelligent agent is pushing such changes with Kolmogorov complexity as part of the criterion for selecting which changes to push. Well, unless by “in real time” you specifically mean “while respecting the subjective experience and record of time for entities within the construct”; if you don't assume consistent laws on some level, nothing stops changes pushed fromm rewriting apparent history within the simulation to be consistent with the new model. If you assume you have an accurate unmodified record of the past observations—you are already assuming consistent laws.
- lisper 6y ago> It's absolutely consistent if the intelligent agent is pushing such changes with Kolmogorov complexity as part of the criterion for selecting which changes to push. Sure. If an intelligent agent applies a filter that filters out all indications of intelligence, then yes, the observed data is consistent with such an agent. But then the observed data is also consistent with a universe that is controlled by a herd of invisible pink unicorns. > nothing stops changes pushed fromm rewriting apparent history within the simulation to be consistent with the new model Congratulations, you have just re-discovered last-thursdayism: https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Last_Thursdayism https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Last_Thursdayism