6 ms·
Why We Let White-Collar Criminals Get Away with Their Crimes
- sasaf5 6y agoUndoing the clickbait: > many judges seem to believe that a fall from grace is punishment enough, especially since white-collar defendants (often older white men) pose little danger to society, at least with respect to committing violent crimes.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoWhich, if you think about it, works the other way around: the person gets a ton of media coverage supporting how dodgy they can be; which gives their future employer a direct sign of what they could be hired to do. You don’t even need to ask for it; just hire them and not stop them from continuing with their previous methods.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoIt's more that many judges believe that white color criminals break the same sort of laws that the judges do, so it's not so bad. This becomes clear when you judges that excuse violent crimes like rape when perpetrated by rich white (not just in the collar) men.
- Gibbon1 6y agoYears ago on HN I posted a link to an essay by a appellate court chief justice that basically claimed that. Poor people need the threat of prison to keep them in line. Middle class people need the threat of loss of money to keep them in line. The wealthy only need the loss of their good reputation to keep them in line. That flies in the face of everything I know about poor people. For them their reputation is the only thing of value they have.
- tolbish 6y agoHis solution is a vague sentence at the end: > Solving it will require a broad shift in an American culture that celebrates the accumulation of wealth and too often turns a blind eye to — or even glorifies — the success of the white-collar criminal. Food for thought: what does the phrase "law and order" mean to you? Does it mean to aggressively prosecute all crimes, or certain more visible crimes? I don't think I've ever seen the phrase "law and order" applied to white collar criminals.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoI think there’s a lot of culture “we have to do it this way because the real world is frightening and complex and therefore you have to be dodgy to succeed”. We need real conservatives today. With a strong outlook for the future. Not the 60-year-old pant-shitters given up on the ideas our society was built upon.
- avmich 6y ago> We need real conservatives today. Conservatism as an idea is morally deficient. We live in a changing world, especially at some periods, and what we need is adaptation of agreements to new ways of life propelled by increasing possibilities, from tech and quality of life. There are places for conservatism, stemming from slowly changing human nature, but for now it looks more like an exception than the rule. Popular vision of conservatism is hardly defendable today. Real - real - conservatives today would be progressives. AOC, Sanders, this kind. Not because they propose sticking with non-working mechanisms - they don't - but because they correctly see the ideas, intents of rules proposed for society - at times when changes weren't that stark. Edit: this is an opinion.
- sawjet 6y agoThere is nothing wrong with being conservative or having conservative ideas.
- avmich 6y agoIt looks like having conservative ideas is somewhat similar to having ideas that e.g. the Earth is flat. Surely, one can think whatever he wants, but from such thinking one can have more mistakes than otherwise. There is no justification to many thought platforms - but that doesn't mean they can't be wrong.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoWell, no. Anti-vaxxers are for example primarily liberal, because they believe that it’s the establishment that is trying to control them. Vaccination is actually a pretty conservative option politically.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoLet me guess, because rich people exchange favours with their rich friends in the government? If humans were perfect and incapable of evil, we would have never needed a government in the first place. The problem is that a government is made up of the very same people who are capable of committing evil. I think it's pretty naive to think that human beings will stop being evil just because they're in charge. Sure they will make a lot of gestures and speeches, give a few cents to homeless and poorly maintain some roads, just so people won't lift their heads from their smartphones. The real problem here is that it's 2020 and we still have entities that centralise immense power without considering conflicts of interest. This is not a US phenomenon, it's happening everywhere, it's been happening since the beginning of time and it's the real cause of inequality between the 0.01% and the rest.
- COVardsStayHome 6y agoWhy should't we? If its a crime without a physical harm - I don't see a reason for a harsh punishment - fine them and let them go on their marry way.
- kentbrew 6y agoSpoiler alert: it's because they're white.
- woah 6y agoIt makes sense for violent crimes such as assault and robbery, and crimes that can easily turn violent, such as burglary and theft, to be punished more harshly than nonviolent crimes. That being said, locking up perpetrators of victimless crimes, like drug dealers, drug users, and prostitutes is a travesty.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoWhy? Shutting off CA's electricity (Enron) killed more people than any simple murderer. Hooking millions on opioids causes violence. Stealing money via paperwork takes away the victims access to health care. Street crime is a absolutely trivial compared to the harm that white collar crime does.
- thundergolfer 6y agoYeah, it really only requires one to think one or two steps beyond the immediate act to see how horrible white collar crime is. In a country full of uninsured citizens and underfed children, exactly how do people find billions in wage theft to be a minor crime? Only by thoughtlessness, I’d say.