7 ms·
The Knowledge Machine: How Irrationality Created Modern Science
- throw0101a 6y agoBefore science can get off the ground, certain assumptions need to be made: > that there is an objective reality shared by all rational observers.[19][20] […] > that this objective reality is governed by natural laws;[19][20] […] > that reality can be discovered by means of systematic observation and experimentation.[19][20] […] > that Nature has uniformity of laws and most if not all things in nature must have at least a natural cause.[20] […] […] * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalism_(philosophy)#Providing_assumptions_required_for_science https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalism_(philosophy)#Provid... Not all world views accept these axioms. Some think that what we perceive is an illusion or that the material world is 'evil' (e.g., Manichaeism); some that the forces of Nature are governed by capricious spirits or deities; others still that the natural phenomena do not have innate causal powers themselves but their actions are divinely willed.
- cs702 6y agoYes... but your comment is not germane to the OP, which is a review of a new book offering an explanation as to why science advances over time that departs from the widely accepted explanations by Karl Popper and Thomas Kuhn.
- Kednicma 6y agoQuantum mechanics demolishes the first two bullet points, so in some sense, science has marched on and progressed past that naive ontic naturalism, and exchanged it for a humbler epistemic naturalism. The points become rephrased: > that there is an epistemic reality about which all rational observers can know half of the ontic facts > that this epistemic reality is governed by natural laws which are themselves epistemic And so on. Crucially, there are no local hidden variable theories which can reproduce what we observe already; there are situations where there cannot possibly have been an objective ontic reality in the laboratory.
- qsort 6y agoScience never in fact required ontic naturalism. The only real assumption is that "there exists something as opposed to nothing", i.e. that there are some phenomena independent of the subject doing science. It is a tenable position to argue that the theory of general relativity (or quantum mechanics, or anything else) is not what the world is, but merely a model of the world, that we accept because it's useful and provides correct (or "correct enough") predictions. Regardless of whether one agrees or not with that perspective, it's entirely possible to discuss a scientific theory with no consideration of its ontological status; one may at the same time disagree with the interpretation and agree with the mathematical account. It doesn't seem to me like any kind of 'naturalistic' assumption is required for science to work.
- throwaway9887 6y ago>The only real assumption is that "there exists something as opposed to nothing", i.e. that there are some phenomena independent of the subject doing science. Former does not imply the latter.
- qsort 6y agoIt's rather difficult to make sense of the concept of 'existing' starting from the point of view that everything is the product of one's mind, but yeah, strictly speaking I used imprecise language (which is why I put that sentence in quotes). The actual assumption is the latter.
- ncmncm 6y ago>It is a tenable position to argue that the theory of general relativity ... is not what the world is It is not just tenable, but unavoidable, because GR is, in detail, incompatible with QM. QM has been tested overwhelmingly more thoroughly than GR, and GR doesn't seem to predict any of it.
- voxl 6y agoPlease, I would love for you to explain in excruciating detail how Quantum Mechanics invalidates the first two points. Hint: you can't.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lisper 6y ago> assumptions need to be made No, this is false. Science is simply the process of seeking the best explanations for the observed data. It just turns out that the best explanation is some kind of external objective reality governed by natural laws. But it didn't have to turn out that way, and science certainly does not presuppose that it will or would turn out that it. It just happens that it does turn out that way.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agothese explanations are also judged with the aforementioned assumptions in the background. science absolutely presupposes that there is an objective reality governed by natural laws that are uniform throughout the observable universe, which is why experiments are constructed in a way to falsify specific hypothetical versions of those laws. for example, if the laws were not uniform then astrophysicists would have no basis for assuming that the wavelengths of light emitted by a star is evidence for the composition of that star.
- lisper 6y ago> if the laws were not uniform then astrophysicists would have no basis for assuming that the wavelengths of light emitted by a star is evidence for the composition of that star Yes, that's true, but that does not mean that uniform laws are an assumption. They are not. They are a conclusion. Uniform laws are the best explanation that anyone has been able to come up with that explains all the observed data. But this was not assumed, and in fact it still isn't. The idea, for example, that physical constants change over time is very much a hypothesis that is given serious consideration. It just turns out that there's no evidence for it.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoThe assumption of uniform laws is used when evaluating how evidence confirms or rejects a theory. The assumption of uniform physical laws is used when theories are compared to see which is the best explanation for the evidence. > The idea, for example, that physical constants change over time is very much a hypothesis that is given serious consideration. It just turns out that there's no evidence for it. In fact the hypothesis that the speed of light changes over time is a component of several heterodox physical theories that have appeared over the years. Whether or not there is evidence for a theory depends entirely on the assumptions used when attempting to explain a phenomenon.
- cs702 6y agoThe OP is a review of a recently released book, "The Knowledge Machine: How Irrationality Created Modern Science," by Michael Strevens, a professor of philosophy at NYU: https://smile.amazon.com/Knowledge-Machine-Irrationality-Created-Science-ebook/dp/B085SSXY45 https://smile.amazon.com/Knowledge-Machine-Irrationality-Cre... Streven proposes a new explanation as to how and why science has advanced over time, that builds upon but is different from the widely accepted explanations proposed by Karl Popper ("science progresses by disproving false theories") and Thomas Kuhn ("science progresses when popular paradigms stop working"). Streven suggests that science adanvaces because scientists (quoting from the OP): > have no choice. They are constrained by a central regulation that governs science, which he calls the “iron rule of explanation.” The rule is simple: it tells scientists that, “if they are to participate in the scientific enterprise, they must uncover or generate new evidence to argue with”; from there, they must “conduct all disputes with reference to empirical evidence alone.” Compared with the theories proposed by Popper and Kuhn, Strevens’s rule can feel obvious and underpowered. That’s because it isn’t intellectual but procedural. “The iron rule is focused not on what scientists think,” he writes, “but on what arguments they can make in their official communications.” Still, he maintains, it is “the key to science’s success,” because it “channels hope, anger, envy, ambition, resentment—all the fires fuming in the human heart—to one end: the production of empirical evidence.”
- disown 6y ago> Streven proposes a new explanation as to how and why science has advanced over time There is another theory of how science advances - technology. Historically, the discovery of new technology has advanced science. Whether they be telescopes, microscopes, glass, etc. Also, much of science derived from mysticism, chemistry -> alchemy, astronomy-astrology, so forth. Many times, new technology allows us to "see" ( production of empirical evidence ) to separate the mystic from the science. Newton, one of our great scientists was deep into the occult. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaac_Newton%27s_occult_studies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaac_Newton%27s_occult_studie...
- dr_dshiv 6y agoSee how the notion of resonance, which was the very essence of magic (e. G., two strings vibrating each other at a distance) was not adopted in science for 300 years. I suspect because of the magical association. But then we take resonance scientifically seriously and we get wireless communication and other technologies that are absolutely magical. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41567-019-0458-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41567-019-0458-z
- logicOnly 6y agoThe more pressing issues in science- Where's the cutoff of real science? Biology? Medicine? Psychology? Politics, economics? If Medicine is science, we need massive deregulation to allow scientists to practice medicine instead of a singular group. If psychology is science, there needs to be an effort to validate studies.
- 8bitsrule 6y agoMainstream science largely resembles a secular theology. 'Observations' are the deity, scientists are the 'authoritative interpreters' of the sacred insights for the faithful. The inquisitions are less physically violent; only careers die. Paul Feyerabend was a very likeable guy.