7 ms·
The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon
- hanniabu 6y agoMakes more sense now than ever with the advent of starlink.
- DennisP 6y agoYes, and in a positive way. Starlink plays a big part in funding Starship/Superheavy, and giving it an initial customer to get launch volume up. That's what will allow the much lower space transportation costs, cited by an astronomer in the article as making this observatory feasible.
- _Microft 6y agoI have seen lots of complaints from astronomers about Starlink interfering with optical observations but cannot remember hearing about radioastronomy being affected. On the other hand - if it is up there, it sure can reflect radiosignals from Earth back again. Has anyone heard about Starlink and the radioastronomy community?
- gammarator 6y agoThe impact of these constellations on radio astronomy is arguably worse, not least because it’s harder for the average person to see the impact. https://www.thespacereview.com/article/3702/1 https://www.thespacereview.com/article/3702/1 (They don’t just reflect radio waves, they broadcast them!)
- whimsicalism 6y agoThere's just no way that we as a society when deciding between "some shiny new satellite thing produced by an American corporation" versus "the quality of the VLAs operations" will pick the latter. It pains me to say it, but the average person does not know what the VLA is, nor care at all.
- hutzlibu 6y agoI am not an average person, but have not heard of the VLA before either .. Anyway, evem when you rephrase it: Do you want fast internet everywhere? Or better conditions for science to maybe find aliens? Not many people would vote for science. Which is economically understandable, so I am all for a moon observatory.
- whimsicalism 6y agoIt's not just science to find aliens, radio astronomy answers so many questions that we might not even think to ask - and it is not cost feasible to do all of those observations from space. It's as if in the 18th century, you were like "do we want to spend more money on roads? or do we want to keep funding these stupid experiments that Edison is doing for science?"
- coryrc 6y agoNo. I love space science, but knowing the origin of the universe will not bring us indoor lighting, refrigeration, clean energy, or anything like that. It is valuable in so far as it's worth some investment, but not so much it prevents us from providing global Internet.
- wbl 6y agoStarlink is not going to solve last mile access problems except for a small number of people. Even rural areas have towns, and it's a matter of spending the money to bring Internet to them the way we did electricity.
- whimsicalism 6y agoYou have no idea of what basic physics could learn from cosmology a priori, and neither do I.
- _Microft 6y agoThanks!
- Mr_lavos 6y agoYes please.
- koheripbal 6y agoWhy does it need to be physically ON any planetary body? What are the advantages of having it on the moon rather than free floating in a moon-like orbit? ...or for that matter a more distant eccentric orbit?
- koheripbal 6y agoI should have read the article... the answer is shielding. even in lunar orbit, it's better than orbiting the Earth for brief periods.
- pueblito 6y agoOne advantage would be a foothold on a strategically valuable location
- whimsicalism 6y agoDemocracies are far too short-sighted for this to be an actual reason. Also, this is just a paper published in a journal.
- jvanderbot 6y agoSize also. It's easy to spool dish wires out on the ground on the moon, hard to spool them out and keep them where you want in orbit.
- a1369209993 6y ago> hard to spool them out and keep them where you want in orbit. Well, it's easy if you rotate the whole thing and use centrifugal force, but that has other problems.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoThermal management is easier when you can physically touch other objects, easier to know where you are, easier to maintain pointing accuracy, etc
- jcims 6y ago
- tgflynn 6y agoI'm fed up with titles like this that suggest that an entire scientific community, or at least some body with a legitimate claim to representing the interests of that community, wants something when all that is really happening is that some particular group of scientists has submitted a proposal. Here's the first line of the article: > On Monday, a group of researchers sponsored by Breakthrough Listen, the world’s largest program, submitted a paper to National Academy of Sciences’ Planetary Science and Astrobiology Decadal Survey that makes the case for establishing a SETI radio observatory on the farside of the moon. Note that this line is also incorrect due to a missing word. Breakthrough Listen may be the world's largest SETI program, but it is certainly not the world's largest program, whatever that would even mean. So this is some particular group of SETI specialists, which I highly doubt represents the interests of the astronomical community at large (I would guess that only a small fraction of astronomers even work on SETI). Don't get me wrong, I'm not criticizing the project itself, just the misleading title of the article and the general decline in journalistic standards.
- arbuge 6y agoI think these concerns would be addressed by adding a single word to the title. "Some", at the beginning.
- tgflynn 6y agoI think a more accurate title would be something like: SETI Project Proposes Building an Observatory on the Moon
- majkinetor 6y agoStop with this millennial shenanigans already. NOT everything needs to be predigested so that you save 3 seconds of your time. Article is fine, title is fine, you are the ones that need to change.
- dredmorbius 6y agoQuite, yes.
- jessriedel 6y agoThis is the millionth article on lunar far-side telescopes I've seen that conveniently fails to explain why you'd want to place a radio telescope on the surface rather than just at the Earth-Moon L2 Lagrange point (i.e., the point on the far side of the Moon that orbits with the Moon around the Earth and keeps the Moon between itself and the Earth). I'm sick of not having this obvious question answered, so I dug into it. Like the lunar surface, a telescope at L2 keeps the Moon permanently between itself and the Earth to block incoming radio waves. For a fixed telescope size, going down into the Moon's gravity well increases costs tremendously. And, although doing construction in a vacuum is never easy, it's a lot easier when you're in zero-g and you don't need a crane! Unlike the far-side surface, L2 has exposure to sunlight for power for ~90% of the time. (You would still need a relay satellite in a different lunar orbit for communications, of course, just like the far-side surface.) As far as I can tell from browsing the article https://arxiv.org/abs/2009.12689 https://arxiv.org/abs/2009.12689 and the much more helpful analysis of the lunar radio environment that they cite https://sci-hub.st/https://arc.aiaa.org/doi/pdf/10.2514/6.IAC-06-D4.1.01 https://sci-hub.st/https://arc.aiaa.org/doi/pdf/10.2514/6.IA... the only benefits to going to to the surface is (1) you get better shielding of the extremely low frequencies (≲ 1 kHz) which are long enough wavelength to diffract around the Earth, but don't think those are detectable unless you have a telescope that's many kilometers in size. (2) you avoid radio signals from satellites in geostationary orbits, but these should be very small since the transmitters are pointing toward the Earth. Indeed, the faculty member who is advising the undergraduate intern lead author says > “The first SETI observations that are done from the lunar farside will be done from orbit, there’s no question about that,” says Andrew Siemion, the director of the Berkeley SETI Research Center and the second author on the paper. “I think eventually we absolutely want to do something on the surface because we want to build a very large aperture telescope, but even when we’re at that point I don’t think that would negate the utility of doing things from orbit as well.” and I think he's downplaying how tremendously costly going to the surface would be for very little benefit. EDIT: Note that the FARSIDE array on the surface they mention is much better justified, but it's not SETI, it's an array, the surface benefits from solar storm shielding, and it probably only makes sense because it piggybacks on high bandwidth connection for the NASA Lunar Gateway. More details here: https://www.lpi.usra.edu/leag/white-papers-astronomy/FARSIDE_190710_Final.pdf https://www.lpi.usra.edu/leag/white-papers-astronomy/FARSIDE... https://twitter.com/di_goldene_pave/status/1312391572407955457 https://twitter.com/di_goldene_pave/status/13123915724079554...
- ArtWomb 6y agoThere's a NASA funded lunar colony simulation game for MS-DOS circa 1991. You begin with $10K ;) Playable on archive via DOSBox: https://archive.org/details/msdos_Moonbase_1990 https://archive.org/details/msdos_Moonbase_1990
- thepete2 6y agoIt runs in the browser? Archive.org is awesome :)
- sp332 6y agoYes, and they not only take the time to tweak each game's emulation settings to make sure it works, but they have the attention of the emulator devs too. IA just rolled out an update today! https://mobile.twitter.com/textfiles/status/1312464355812753409 https://mobile.twitter.com/textfiles/status/1312464355812753...
- Rebelgecko 6y agoThere's also 2010's Moonbase: Alpha[1], which became notorious due to how it applied text-to-speech on in-game chat messages [2][3] 1: https://store.steampowered.com/app/39000/Moonbase_Alpha/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/39000/Moonbase_Alpha/ 2: https://youtu.be/Hv6RbEOlqRo https://youtu.be/Hv6RbEOlqRo 3: https://youtu.be/CNPKXfb3rws https://youtu.be/CNPKXfb3rws
- tdeck 6y agoI tried for about 45 minutes to play this game (and lunar command) and couldn't figure it out. Is there any guide somewhere online? Specifically my habitat capacity never seemed to increase despite building and wiring/connecting/piping up habitats.
- cure 6y agoA manual would be handy, I agree... For the habitats, you need to hook up power and thermal pipes. As long as you connect the habitats together through the white tubes, they only need one hookup with electric/thermal for the entire site. It seems to take ~ a month in game time for the increased habitat capacity to show up in the 'Population...' menu.
- raverbashing 6y agoI think we need at least some 50yrs of physics to understand how to even begin tapping into the cosmic internet As with fusion and processing power, some things are faster if you wait for the advancements instead of building it with today's technology.
- poma88 6y agoI will change fields to use tha data and find life out there!! :-)
- feralimal 6y agoGood idea! 1972 was so long ago...
- jvanderbot 6y agoY'all might be interested in a robotically assembled km-scale antenna on the farside. https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/niac/2020_Phase_I_Phase_II/lunar_crater_radio_telescope/ https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/niac/2020_Phase_...
- sneak 6y agoThat's super cool, and I hope that they do this. It's also astounding that it's legal for NASA to embed that much crazy 3p tracker javascript into that webpage, considering that they're publicly funded.
- ieatmyownpoop 6y agoAh yes. The death star.
- jagged-chisel 6y agoBut it’s a moon, not a space station.
- skadamou 6y agoThat's no moon
- dang 6y agoTrollish usernames aren't allowed on HN because they effectively troll every thread they post to. I've banned the account, and would be happy to rename and unban it if you want to pick a more neutral username. Best to email hn@ycombinator.com if that's the case. https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix=true&page=0&query=by:dang%20trollish%20username https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...
- wazoox 6y agoIt should be made in the form of a black monolith, I guess. Just for the kick.
- aurizon 6y agoA number of smaller dishes can be made that will robotically unfurl. With the ability to drop a number of them on a flat maria. They will be made with as large as possible self levelling/rotating ability. They can be each driven with their own solar array and will have optical data links so they can work as a large array. They will need an optically linked set of orbiters - which is doable, that can report sequentially. This is a fairly complex task, but once the design is settled and works well, it can be tested and then it can be replicated and an array gradually built with successor dishes. The dishes can be improved as flaws emerge. Being mainly made of aluminum, with vaccuum/dust proof bearings with solar shades it will need to tolerate the temperature range. I think this is a good idea as the other side of the moon is indeed a quiet zone. The lunar lagrange point is also a good place, however the lagrange point will be a hard place for a number of dishes to be sited apart while maintaining precision array positioning.
- 7373737373 6y agoA while ago I read an article about which properties signals might have that could indicate that they originated from intelligent life, something about having "acceleration", higher order derivatives, that are usually not generated by natural events. Does anyone know how this is called?
- screye 6y agoSpace brothers did it first
- tambourine_man 6y agoAny observatory for that matter. I keep dreaming of humongous mirrors, easily accessible, with no clouds or atmosphere to get in the way. Or, you know, moon. Imagine what we would discover. I fell like we neglect the moon to a embarrassing degree. It’s right there (cosmologically speaking), it’s got water, plenty of sun light (24/7 even, on the pole), building materials… what are we waiting for?
- Already__Taken 6y agoit builds up static change and rains hyper abrasive Lunar dust into things I think I've read for one.
- jvanderbot 6y agoA ~100m telescope could be assembled in orbit from segmented mirrors and a few falcon heavy lifts. It could image exo continents. https://science.nasa.gov/technology/technology-highlights/in-space-telescope-assembly https://science.nasa.gov/technology/technology-highlights/in... Bias alert: I briefly worked on in space assembly and firmly believe it is the future of space travel, exploration, and exploitation.
- tambourine_man 6y agoI imagine it would be a lot easier to assemble on something you can stand on and mine from, right? Only an amateur here, but I see James Webb many years and billions overdue and wonder if it wouldn’t be easier, cheaper, faster on ground.
- mdorazio 6y agoHow exactly do you intend to mine, manufacture, and construct things where zero infrastructure exists? Every piece of equipment you would need to do those things would need to be launched not just to low Earth orbit, but all the way to the moon, which is massively more difficult and expensive than building things on Earth and tossing them into orbit here. Building a James Webb equivalent on the moon would cost trillions instead of billions and take decades instead of years.
- credit_guy 6y agoSETI is complete and utter non-sense. If you don't know why, here's a riddle for you: you are the first space colonist who reaches our closest star, Proxima Centauri. How do you send a message back, such as "We arrived" , plus maybe a photo of a planet you intend to colonize? Piece of cake, you say. Point your parabolic antenna back towards Earth and beam the message. Voyager is doing just that, but from closer to home. Only 20 light-hours away from Earth. Voyager is using a transmitter of about 20 W and an antenna of about 2 meters in diameter. You are about 2000 times farther away. Since radio waves lose power with the square of the distance, you have a problem 4 million times harder to solve than Voyager. Actually, your problem is much, much harder than this: your friends on Earth pointing their antennas towards you are blinded by the star that practically touches your spaceship. You are separated from that star by an angle measured in seconds of arc. You need to shout very loud to be heard over the tremendous noise made by your fiery neighbor. But you can do that, you presumably have a portable nuclear reactor with you and can use gigawatts to solve this essential problem. But now, imagine you are an alien chatting merrily over radio waves with a friend in the same planetary system around Proxima Centauri. If you don't take a humongous antenna, point it in the absolute exact direction of Earth, and use a few Gigawatts of power to beam a message, how are we, Terrans, supposed to hear you? How is SETI supposed to discover aliens who are not purposely beaming waves straight at us?
- nine_k 6y agoI bet you can build an antenna on / near Earth large enough to pick up the Voyager's signal at 4 light years. I don't think that a star emits much radio waves at the same frequently range you choose for your radio transmission, and especially has the same modulation side bands. That said, MW-class radio transmittets are not heavy, their cooling systems are. You also don't need to transmit continuously, you can send bursts as long as your thermal budget allows. For energy, you have unlimited sunlight.
- centimeter 6y ago> 4 million times harder I don't think you really understand the problem domain. There are 3 main independent parameters you can tweak to improve maximum transmission range: transmit power (100,000x more power has been done commercially), antenna size (we now have a dish antenna over 250x larger), and you can increase the transmission frequency to substantially improve collimation by many orders of magnitude (e.g. use a laser instead of sub-GHz). > your friends on Earth pointing their antennas towards you are blinded by the star that practically touches your spaceship A star puts out a lot of power, but it's spread pretty evenly across a blackbody spectrum. You can certainly overpower it within a very narrow frequency range. Your bandwidth/power ratio might be quite abysmal compared to wifi, but it's workable. > How is SETI supposed to discover aliens who are not purposely beaming waves straight at us I think the idea is that perhaps they would be beaming waves straight at various stars. This is something I can easily imagine humans doing in the near future.
- sytelus 6y agoOne of the problems that no one talks about: how do you protect against meteor strikes on moon? On Earth mountains form slowly over thousands of years but on moon they appear instantly when something strikes the surface. It’s like waiting for bullet coming from sky all the time.