9 ms·
Anyone have a sense of who is winning or losing here (besides the legal proceedings)? Outside of Hacker News, this story seems dead.
by MattGaiser 6y ago
Anyone have a sense of who is winning or losing here (besides the legal proceedings)?
Outside of Hacker News, this story seems dead.
- urda 6y agoIt will be real hard to argue to any judge that Epic has anything going for them when 1) they actively broke the TOS and were forward about it 2) they actively sneaked code past reviewers to push a feature that broke said TOS 3) They had an ad campaign and in-game-event ready-to-go from the moment they got pulled, which continues to demonstrate how premeditated this maneuver was. It will be real hard for a judge to have to agree with them. They could have corrected it, got back into compliance and continued their legal case, but this was not the route they picked. They gambled, and have (most likely) lost.
- oh_sigh 6y agoEpic could still prevail if the TOS terms they broke are found to be illegal, unenforceable, etc. The important point is Epic doesn't want to be compliant with the current TOS.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoSure, but that's something to be worked out in the pending trial. In the meantime what Epic wants isn't really important to anyone.
- trevyn 6y agoI get the sense that in order to have legal standing for a lawsuit, you have to be actually harmed. I'm under the impression that they had to do more-or-less what they did (minus the press blitz) in order to have legal standing to bring a case. In this case, I think they are arguing that the harm occurs because "who decides if you can be on the App Store" should not be a monopoly, and users should be able to decide if they trust Epic to handle payments instead of Apple. The argument is that the TOS itself is (or should be ruled), in its current form, illegal. This case is particularly interesting, because it is clear that Apple + Google have a duopoly on a very important market, and both companies exhibit near-identical anti-consumer behavior in this particular respect. So while consumers may have a nominal choice, they do not have a real choice about a decision facet that matters. I'm curious about any anti-trust precedent here, and how this was handled in the courts. (i.e. two separate lawsuits against the companies in question, some sort of unified legal plea...?) How is (implicit) collusion handled?
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> in order to have legal standing for a lawsuit, you have to be actually harmed They were paying the 30%. That’s harm enough. Civil disobedience isn’t something courts deal with favourably. In a society with rule of law, they shouldn’t. It’s designed to get the public’s and legislature’s sympathy. As such, I judge it poorly based solely on timing. In the middle of a pandemic and recession, in the midst of an election year, I suspect most Americans would be livid if the Congress prioritised a developer / tech giant compensation dispute.
- trevyn 6y agoIMO, the courts should deal with the issue at hand, and not judge if the parties have been being good bois. It's interesting to think about this in the context of "smart contracts" etc. -- the rule of law is stronger if it is more unambiguously encoded. If our current judicial system is deliberately interpreting morality, rather than encoding our sense of morality into the laws themselves, that seems like a rather obvious opportunity for advancing legal systems, especially in an age where we will be forced to codify human morality anyway. The check-and-balance can be moved to judging laws instead of individual cases, and a new system can be grown for bringing cases against laws instead of parties.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoIt's not about "being good bois", it's about whether Epic is facing irreparable harm. Epic alleges anticompetitive behavior on Apple's part. Sure, fine, there will eventually be a trial. Epic will probably lose because their arguments are ridiculous, but juries have been convinced by stupider arguments, so who knows how it will play out? In the meantime, Epic has deliberately violated a contractual agreement and has been treated exactly in accordance with that contractual agreement. Epic would like a court injunction to force Apple to pretend like Epic has already won the case in the meantime, alleging that Fortnite and Unreal Engine being banned from iOS is causing irreparable harm to Epic in the meantime. Apple's point, that the judge seems to agree with is "How can we be causing you harm when you did this to yourself?"
- judge2020 6y ago> It will be real hard for a judge to have to agree with them. They could have corrected it, got back into compliance and continued their legal case, but this was not the route they picked. To provide a source for this: (ctrl-f escrow) https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1310618271675105282.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1310618271675105282.html
- bananaface 6y agoThe basis of the lawsuit is that the TOS are unreasonable. It doesn't matter if they broke them, in fact they had to to even bring the lawsuit. They might still lose but the fact they broke the TOS won't count against them.
- viktorcode 6y agoSince TOS isn’t enforced on them, Epic will have to provide some evidence that they have no choice but to agree to those unreasonable terms. So far it looks like they can’t do that. Mobile monetary share of Fortnite is small.
- bananaface 6y agoI don't think that's correct either. They just have to show that Apple is engaging in anti-competetive behaviour as defined by the Sherman Act.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gostsamo 6y agoThose legal battles can go for years. We are hearing only the first shots now.
- galkk 6y agoBut could Epic afford it? Their largest hit is Fortnite, and will it be relevant (and bring them tons of money) in several years, if nobody will be able to play it?
- gpm 6y agoAs I understand the market - Mobile is a tiny portion of fortnite - Unreal engine is the long term money maker not fortnite - The 40% owner (tencent) has lots of financial motivation to support this outside of Epic's potential profit, and I wouldn't be surprised if they were willing to pay the company off to make this lawsuit happen
- gostsamo 6y agoWell, besides what the other commenter says, Fortnite was dropping in popularity according to Apple. And I'm sure that both Apple and Epic can spare a billion for lawyers.
- judge2020 6y agoFortnite is still doing good[0], but it'll probably settle at 10-20 million monthly active players, if it hasn't done so already. Reminder that it got popular at the end of 2017. 0: They don't release numbers, but it's always consistently on the first page of Twitch game viewership https://www.twitch.tv/directory?sort=VIEWER_COUNT https://www.twitch.tv/directory?sort=VIEWER_COUNT
- nmfisher 6y ago1) Epic is gobsmackingly cashed up. Fortnite brought in almost $2 billion in revenue last year, and they raised almost $2 billion in equity this year. If anyone is positioned to have a drawn-out legal fight with Apple, it's Epic. 2) Epic's endgame isn't Fortnite, it's the Epic Games Store. Tim Sweeney is a smart businessman, he knows that Fortnite's shelf-life is limited. He's seen Steam make an order of magnitude more money for Valve than its games. EGS would not only diversify Epic away from Fortnite, it would bring in far, far more revenue (not to mention tying up nicely with licensing the Unreal Engine to developers). 3) With EGS on the App/Play Stores, Epic would be positioned to capture literally billions of revenue. The potential reward is so large, it's worth throwing almost everything you have into the Apple/Google lawsuit.
- nmfisher 6y agoThe real trial hasn't started yet (scheduled for July next year, last time I looked), so there's no winning or losing. Epic vs Google was covered in The Economist this week. It's a very big deal.
- dayjobpork 6y agoThe cases get posted on ars, but there is an army that downvotes any comment on that isn't Apple positive.
- wccrawford 6y agoEvery time there's news, I see it on Reddit multiple times and on my newsfeed app as well from various sources. It's very much interesting to gamers and they're following it closely.