3 ms·
> Now we have multiple free, high-quality sources of information that are far easier to access than libraries ever were, for example, Wikipedia or the many sit
by vkou 6y ago
> Now we have multiple free, high-quality sources of information that are far easier to access than libraries ever were, for example, Wikipedia or the many sites where people share their literary works for free.
You are vastly understating the problems of bitrot, linkrot, and the amount of quality information available at your local library, and are massively overstating the amount of quality information available on the internet. (And much of that quality information is gated behind proprietary walled gardens, or is monetized through adware and spyware.)
Not to mention the modern trend of burying five bits of useful information in an 8 minute video, the first two minutes of which are pointless small talk and requests to like/subscribe/follow, and the other six are an unsearchable morass that takes way too long to get to the point.
The internet does two things better - searchability, and multimedia. The rest is a hot mess of largely superficial depth, and dubious quality.
- _Microft 6y ago> burying five bits of useful information in an 8 minute video Videos are often even ~10:10 minutes long for a while already now. I think it's a monetization thing on YouTube. If you know keywords, you can search for them using your browser's search function in the time stamped transcript that might be available from the three-dot-menu below the video. Increasing playback speed also helps.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoI often feel the same about documentaries made for TV or DVD/Bluray. Even ones from National Geographic. While the production quality is excellent, I can perfectly live without dramatizing background music or sound effects. I often thought about some 45 to 60 minutes piece that they could have done that in 5 to 10 minutes without wasting my time.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThat Mitchell and Webb Look "Gift Shop" sketch: https://youtube.com/watch?v=7MFtl2XXnUc https://youtube.com/watch?v=7MFtl2XXnUc
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoDrum roll...: Head -> Desk -> ad infinitum!
- _Microft 6y ago> You are vastly understating the problems of bitrot, linkrot This is an important point too. If it's something I'd like to keep for later use and on a single page, I almost inevitably print the page into a PDF (from reader mode).
- sjy 6y agoThe low average quality of online information does not undermine the parent’s point that the internet substantially reduces the marginal value of (physical) libraries. Free online resources like Wikipedia provide more comprehensive, current and accessible reference material than small local libraries, and non-free academic research databases provide more accessible, and arguably more comprehensive and current, reference material than any single physical library. As the parent recognised, there are still many books that haven’t been digitised, but it is not fair to compare the set of freely available online resources to the set of all copyrighted works you could eventually get your hands on via an inter-library loan. The fact that libraries need to pay for these books, and readers need to return them after a short time, makes them much less “accessible” than online alternatives.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoWhere I live we have a good public central library with a very broad selection, which also is offering electronic media. If you happen to be downtown you can get your stuff there, and then casually drop that into one of the many (much smaller) branches in the suburbs. Furthermore you can extend your loan easily and online if you need to (where the standard loan time is one month). I can live with that. Though haven't used it since March for obvious reasons. I think it depends from where and when you look at it. While for someone living "out there" the online stuff is an enrichment, for someone used to live metropolitan or at least some university town, it's only so so and not really overwhelming. The same is true for (good) book stores dealing with dead wood. The haptics are simply different. You can stroll along there and find something interesting widening your horizon by random chance/serendipity. The recommendations from sites like Amazon or Goodreads don't offer that, even if they are trying to emulate that. Not the same, more like tunnel vision, and if something like "surprise me!" is offered, it's different from walking into some rarely or never visited part, quickly scanning a few pages and "seeing" how it's like. The same applies to reading "on-screen", no matter which device, size, and display technology. The haptics are mostly WORSE. Not having experienced the good parts of "dead wood" it may be excused, because not knowing it any better. Nonetheless there were and still are many good parts about "dead wood", and the ecosystem surrounding that. Just not everywhere. /endrant