3 ms·
> That's really the doctor's issue to address, not the device's. Sticking your head in the sand isn't the right solution to the problems of dealing with informa
by acdha 6y ago
> That's really the doctor's issue to address, not the device's. Sticking your head in the sand isn't the right solution to the problems of dealing with information too aggressively.
Again, it's not that simple. Doctors do not have perfect knowledge and have factors to consider other than the current academic consensus. Some fraction of people will get scared and demand _something_, which will for some people lead to them doing something worse than nothing at all. If you have many people seeking out treatment for a notification which has them scared, some of the patients will try something other than good medical treatments and some of them will have doctors who recommend things which used to be or are no longer best practice, make a recommendation skewed by a financial incentive or what will turn out to be a biased study funded by a company with a financial stake, etc.
Engineers building tools like this have a tricky ethical line to walk between making information available and considering how that information could be misinterpreted or faulty. One of the biggest things I'd want to see on a system like this is careful treatment of showing confidence levels and present them in the UX. “️ Heart anomaly detected!” is not the same as “Our sensor reading was unusual but the signal was low-quality. Do you feel okay?”, etc.
- ebg13 6y agoYou're bringing up very real issues that I think really have nothing to do with whether we decide to measure, report, and learn more about cardiac anomalies or not. I agree that we should be careful about how we report and apply information, but that isn't the same as saying we shouldn't look in the first place. Right now practically nobody ever bothers to look for symptoms of something that we believe full well to be the #1 leading cause of death by a large margin. That should really not be accepted by anyone.