6 ms·
> money can move much faster and more freely than labor. That's a result of political choices made in many jurisdictions, it's not a law of nature. The EU made
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
> money can move much faster and more freely than labor.
That's a result of political choices made in many jurisdictions, it's not a law of nature. The EU made a very conscious decision to tie free movement of labor to free movement of capital within its operating zone (probably the only such economic agreement of its kind).
The choices that the US has made are entirely favorable to capital, and entirely disfavorable to all non-professional labor. The only upside I can see (and I'm not alone in this) is cheap consumer goods that have obscured the true cost and depth of wage stagnation over 35 years.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoIn 1789 the US made a very conscious decision to tie free movement of labor to free movement of capital within its operating zone (probably the first ever economic agreement of its kind). The US is a union of sovereign states.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThe US (other than for 8-12 years after the revolution) is a federal republic. The EU is not federal and is not a republic.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoThe Union of States made that mistake too in 1781.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dehrmann 6y ago> That's a result of political choices made in many jurisdictions It definitely makes it more difficult, but a lot of it is a "law of nature" because moving is expensive, time consuming, risky, and you give up your local connections. There's a reason for the metaphor "putting down roots."
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThat's a very valid point. But it ignores the extent to which we've deliberately worked very hard to make capital mobile. As noted elsewhere in the thread, feudal societies used to see most wealth accumulated in the form of real estate, which is more or less the definition of immobile capital. We've built huge and complex social institutions around making capital mobile, and even allowed them to suck up a rather notable percentage of GDP. Imagine what a world would look like that put as much effort into the free movement of labor. And note: not all capital is internationally mobile, and in the same spirit, nobody would sensibly suggest that all labor would or should become mobile. There's plenty of room and benefits for investing both close to home (which is all part of "putting down roots"). It's a question of balance between local, regional, national and global for both capital and labor mobility.
- ballenf 6y agoSincere question: why is purchasing power not the defining characteristic of wage growth at least post-gold standard? If I can buy more stuff with the same salary, hasn't my salary effectively gone up? Or is your point that only some stuff is cheaper, but the total standard of living supportable by average wages has nevertheless dropped?
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago>"If I can buy more stuff with the same salary, hasn't my salary effectively gone up?" That would be deflation, but we've actually had inflation over the past decades. We can ofcourse discuss how wrll we are measuring it, but generally speaking some life necessities like housing have skyrocketed in price.
- chickenmonkey 6y agoIt makes sense if their point is that only some stuff is cheaper. It's cheap in the US to buy processed food and appliances but college and healthcare costs are pretty high, and it's hard for young people to find good housing.
- dpoochieni 6y agoOnly some stuff is cheaper, but the important stuff is the same or more expensive than before (housing, education, stocks).
- dtech 6y agoBecause purchasing power is quite hard to quantify. It requires you to define a set of goods the "average" consumer uses. This leaves much more wiggle room for manipulation and politicization. [1] Wage in currency is a lot simpler. The only real manipulation possibility is currency value and some minor tinkering in the definitions. [1] For example a major criticisms of the euro-zone inflation index is that it excludes housing cost: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmonised_Index_of_Consumer_Prices#Controversy_on_housing_prices https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmonised_Index_of_Consumer_P...
- LudwigNagasena 6y ago
- blibble 6y ago> The EU made a very conscious decision to tie free movement of labor to free movement of capital within its operating zone (probably the only such economic agreement of its kind). how is this any different for the US? I'm pretty certain Floridians don't need a work visa if they choose to go and work in California?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoWhen the EU was formed (originally as the European Common Market), it was an agreement between entirely sovereign nations. No federal government, no trans-national legal frameworks. The US has essentially never existed in this form. From the moment of its founding, it has been a federal, democratic republic. Before the EEC/EU, investing across Europe was much more difficult, and labor migration was limited to "high skilled" workers. There have never been any such limitations in the US.
- blibble 6y ago> The US has essentially never existed in this form. From the moment of its founding, it has been a federal, democratic republic. this isn't true at all, what about the first US constitution: The Articles of Confederation? Article II stated that the States are sovereign (bar delegated powers), and Article IV established freedom of movement and freedom of capital essentially the same structure as the current EU (with many of the same flaws)
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoerr, excuse me .. before the first US constitution (barring a few years when things were really up in the air), the "united states" was a wholly owned colony of Great Britain. If you're a historical revisionist, you could make the claim that the separate colonies constituted separate nations before the AoC, but I wouldn't agree with you. The AoC formed a nation, post-revolution, and formed it out of states. I would read Article IV as preventing the elimination of freedom of movement and capital, because when it was enacted there was honestly little to no barriers to either already in place. The EEC/EU was preceded by nations, continues to feature nations (1) and still has no actual federal structure (though quite a lot of Europeans wish it had more, and quite a lot of other Europeans wish it had less). (1) consider how easy it was for even the Schengen zone nations to close their borders and think about how difficult it would be for a state to do the same.