4 ms·
The fact the money is fungible should not be allowed to obscure the fact that money (the form in which capital is moved around) is a complex social agreement th
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
The fact the money is fungible should not be allowed to obscure the fact that money (the form in which capital is moved around) is a complex social agreement that exists only because of a highly evolved and history-dependent set of rules. Talking about money as "your property" typically bypasses the real nature of money, and encourages people to uncritically buy into a conservative/libertarian perspective that plays with people's sense of fairness to the interest of only those in positions of existing wealth and power.
The fact that one can "move capital" to other countries at all is not some law of nature, but a deliberate political choice. Had the choice been made in some other direction (such as taxing currency conversions), a totally different pathway would emerge. The fact that one choice appears to involve "removing" constraints and the other appears to involve "adding" constraints makes it appear as though one of them is somehow closer to the natural order or things. But the very existence of money at all is not part of the natural order of things, and the preference for choices that avoid constraints just favors the status quo over change.
- 082349872349872 6y agoFeudal economies were famous for encouraging their elite to acquire and store wealth in the form of real estate, which (unless one is a border lord) is not easily moved to another jurisdiction.
- maerF0x0 6y ago> is a complex social agreement that exists +1 agree this is a massively important distinction in a fiat currency world. Money was property when it was Gold (+gold backed). Now it's more social than that. Unfortunately it seems people are up/down voting me, presumably, on what they think is true and where they think I land on the choice set proposed (Social good vs freedom)
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoGold may have the appearance of property, but just like fiat money, this is still due to a complex set of social conventions and agreements. Gold does not have much practical use for most of the things that people do in life, but a reality-based consensus that it is relatively rare and a human-psychology driven fascination with shiny and malleable materials has led us to agree to place value in it. Even that took some effort, such as when gold-centric cultures and silver-centric cultures encountered each other.