4 ms·
Right. The point is, the definition you posted is one of several, and doesn't really address the issue at hand. You can't pretend that "guys" is gender neutra
by klyrs 6y ago
Right. The point is, the definition you posted is one of several, and doesn't really address the issue at hand. You can't pretend that "guys" is gender neutral; that's one of many "tainted" contexts that invalidates the claim.
When folks say "software guys", does "software" similarly taint the meaning because our society has decided that programming is "men's work?" In my experience, as a woman who talks to other women about this precise nuance of our language, it does feel othering to many if not most of us.
Furthermore, when I overhear a coworker talking about a need to hire "a packaging guy", and then refer to this hypothetical person (comprising zero actual candidates for an ad which hasn't even been written) with he/him pronouns exclusively, am I then expected to believe that this use of "guy" is gender neutral?
- Chris2048 6y agoI said its used for groups of either sex, which it is. I didn't claim (or "pretend") it was gender neutral. It's not as simple as having multiple definitions: it has different meaning for different contexts, but it otherwise consistent within those contexts. A "tainted" context is one not generalisable because it is an idiom; much like proper nouns are not generalisable. Using "guys" to refer to mixed groups is generalisable to all situations with similar context - its not an idiom. > a packaging guy Is use of "guy" as plural, which I've never seen refer to mixed groups, hence is not the same context.
- Chris2048 6y agoI meant "singular", not plural.